Just Trump's opening remarks are lunacy. His first reason for asserting fraud is rally size. He claims 50,000 voters were told they couldn't vote because they already did & 100,000s of ballots were forged. No court has seen *any* evidence for any of this. washingtonpost.com/politics/trump…
At about 7:29, he says, "We won every state and every single statehouse.... We won Congress..."
I had jokingly suggested that Trump should just claim that he won every state. Why limit himself, if he's going to make stuff up? Lo and behold, he did.
He claims 5,000 dead Georgians voted. "They" (whoever "they" are, they sure work hard) "went through obituaries." I wonder if they have a mole inside the top-secret obit-reading operation. My God, Trump just monologues, on and on and on. Now he's making up numbers about Detroit.
On the call, Trump repeats an insane claim, made in a dismissed lawsuit, that Detroit had a turnout of 139%. To quote the Detroit Free Press, "The city’s official results show that turnout in the city was actually 50.88% of registered voters." freep.com/story/news/loc…
Brad Raffensperger, Georgia's SOS, reminds Trump that they responded to each of his loony claims point by point in court. Then he said a hand-recount showed the machine tally was accurate, so he assumes complaints about Dominion machines are off the table. Trump differs.
Trump rambles. He doesn't need to look at the machines. "What's the difference in winning by two votes, and...half a million votes. I think we probably did win it by half a million.... I can tell you by our rallies.... It's just not possible to have lost Georgia. Not possible."
Raffensperger responds specifically to Trump's 5,000-dead-people-voted claim. He points out the correct number is exactly two. Doesn't mention that they were votes for Trump, who asks Cleta Mitchell to reply. She makes a complaint about records requests. Trump says he's "sure."
Trump then repeats claims, based on a misinterpreted video, of a poll worker feeding the same ballot in three times. Says that one incident alone adds up to more than the margin. Doesn't explain how a hand-recount of the ballots gave the same count as the machine tally.
Raffensperger then complains that Giuliani edited the tape in question, says he examined the full tape without editing, which showed no crime. Trump doesn't miss a beat. He just drops it and moves on to, "But where were the poll watchers, Brad? ...There was no security there."
Trump has clearly absorbed every crazy myth that feeds his conviction he could only win. He repeats the 3-time ballot-feeding claim. Raffensperger says forcefully that they disproved it and did a hand recount that verified results. Trump just goes for another baseless claim.
Trump's performance on this tape shows that you couldn't trust him to drive, let alone be president. He would drive right through a red light, claiming that he never gets red lights—"not possible." He cannot accept any fact that he finds disagreeable, believes every lie.
Trump claims fake ballots were dumped in when everyone was forced out of the room. "Only a child" could believe it was not a vote-rigging operation. He's told there was a thorough investigation by the FBI, GBI, & others, who found nothing. "Then they're incompetent," Trump says.
"There's only two answers, dishonesty or incompetence. There's no way, there's just now way," Trump says. Cleta Mitchell makes loony claims as well. "We watched the tape!" Claims out-of-state voters. Trump is told that every single ballot they're discussing was checked.
The context for Trump's complaint that Dominion moved machines out or replaced part makes it even more nuts. He's been told already that each ballot was checked by hand, and that count matches the machine count. He just doesn't absorb contrary information, comes back to machines.
Trump turns a defense of his sources into a weird attack:
"This is Trump media.... I don't care about social media... Social media is big tech. Big tech is on your side. I don't even know why you have a side. Because you should want an accurate election. And you're Republican."
Trump is the perfect distillation of the Trump true believer. He cannot absorb contrary information, but believes any crazy claim that affirms his convictions. He repeats claims that Raffensperger debunked on the same call, says, "they're laughing at you" dig, his worst insult.
It's interesting that the call is largely a monologue, but the pushback gets firmer as he goes along, then he starts with the threats. It's like a rally speech—wild lies. He claims ballot-shredding and machines being moved, ignoring the prior *two* recounts—including one by hand.
He exhausts the Georgia officials, repeating over and over the same conspiracy theories, after he's told they've been disproved.
"Did you ever check?"
Exasperated pause. "We investigated as I explained earlier."
"Why do you keep fighting this thing? It just doesn't make sense."
Told this has been fought in courts and Georgia's numbers proved accurate, Trump is dismissive & incredulous. "Sure, we can play this game in the courts.... They don't even assign us a judge. Hey Brad, why wouldn't you check out [bleeped name]." He's been told already why.
Trump's lawyers make a big show of fighting at the end. Cleta Mitchell makes some crazy claims, but mostly they complain about not being given records. They're told Georgia law doesn't allow certain records to be given out. Trump says his losing is false and that's not allowed.
Listening to it all shows that Trump is deeply deluded. He truly believes he cannot lose. Toward the end, he says defiantly, "Ultimately I win." He doesn't have demential, but he's not mentally competent to be president. He just cannot process information. It's scary.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Historian @KevinLevin mentioned a new biography of Lee coming this fall. I have no knowledge or opinion of it. But some historians asked, "Do we really need a new biography of Lee?" The answer is easy: always—if done right. The reasons are complicated. 1/7 penguinrandomhouse.com/books/253141/l…
Of course, I wrote about a man who is even more frequently chronicled and even more unpopular than Lee—though he contributed materially to Lee's defeat. I'd argue it was worth doing. I see four reasons for new biographies of old subjects. 2/7 indiebound.org/book/978030747…
First, new questions. I explored Custer in Reconstruction, his role in politics, his place in intellectual, environmental, & economic history. Unexpected contexts change how we see familiar figures, leading to surprising historical insight—though they don't rehabilitate.
3/7
Trump's reelection slogans come straight from the long history of white supremacy: 1) "Law & Order" 2) "Radical left governors & mayors" 3) "Protect the suburbs [from black people]"
Jesse James's life illuminates their meaning.
1/10
I'm not the great scholar of white supremacy, but I see a repeated pattern, including in Jesse James's life.
1) "Law & order" represents the *aggression* of white supremacy. Before the Civil War, the growing challenge to the slaveholders' dominance bred aggressive demands.
2/10
The proximate cause of the Civil War was the demand for *more* by slaveholders—especially new territory. Proslavery militants in Missouri (home of Jesse James, born 1847) organized "Border Ruffian" paramilitary units to force slavery on the neighboring Kansas Territory.
3/10
As a public service, here’s a summary of President Trump’s message to the American people so far: 1) The virus is nothing! You won’t even notice you’re sick. Go to work. Shake a lot of hands. 2) IT’S A FREAKING CHINESE INVASION! 3) A hoax. Fake news & Democrats want to ruin me...
4) I’m so focused on this. I’m super aggressive and a natural born scientist and took all the steps no one thought I should take before I was even president. In sum, Obama—swine flu—total disaster. 5) It will go away in a miracle. It’s more of a February virus. Hates April...
6) You reporters with your questions, always questioning me! I hate you all! You die now! 7) There’s this hair-loss drug I’m super-sure will cure the China virus. Right, doctor? 8) Don’t look at me. The governors are in charge. They should fight each other for the ventilators...