For four years, this account has asked social platforms to simply follow their own Terms of Service which they, themselves wrote around hate, harassment, disinformation & violent threats.
Tonight is huge, as many of the platforms are finally doing it. 1
As good as it is seeing platforms like @Twitter@Facebook and @YouTube take action on the most extreme cases, they have largely ignored these problems for years, which has led to a significant degradation in everything from democracy to personal safety, including Tuesday’s coup.2
This is not and has never been a free speech issue. These platforms are massively profitable advertising and data mining companies. They are under no obligation to provide anyone with a platform, especially violent & racist users. No one is owed a spot on these networks. 3
Until now, they’ve only taken quarter measures to both placate their critics while trying to maximize their engagement and profits at the same time. The more anger, disinformation and harassment, the more money they make, so they largely did nothing. 4
Tonight is a big step, yes, but the problems will absolutely continue. These companies deserve no thanks or congratulations for what they should have done years ago and should do in the future. These companies helped take us to the brink this last week. 5
As cynical as this sounds, it seems like these companies made a change because of a change in the administration. If so, this is not good. As they control the flow of information around the world, they cannot and should not be so susceptible to the political winds. 6
Social platforms cannot simply pander to ruling parties, giving them the chance to manipulate an electorate. We’ve already seen what this did in Myanmar and now in Ethiopia, where these platforms are creating an environment for political strife and human rights violations. 7
It is time for common sense reform, regulation and oversight of these companies. It will not be easy, but it’s necessary. We cannot leave the fate of our society in the hands of 6 or so CEOs that we did not elect and who are in no way qualified to be making these decisions. 8
Today is good, but the work continues.
Let’s keep it up. END
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Yesterday, we asked @AppStore and @GooglePlay to enforce their own Terms of Service on Parler based on the sheer number of violent threats on the platform with #PullParler.
Look at the VERY CLEAR terms set by these two app stores below:
These are the Terms for both user-generated and Objectionable Content as published by @Apple’s @appstore.
The threats and inability for Parler to moderate these violent threats on their app should disqualify the app instantly from the AppStore. #PullParler
Over on @GooglePlay, the Terms of Service are even more clear, forbidding both violence and hate explicitly as well as harassment on any app distributed by the store.
Again, @google has created these rules *themselves*. They should enforce their own policies. #PullParler
1) Stop conflating “free speech” with advertising and data mining businesses. Moderation is done for customers (advertisers), not for 1A, which does not apply to them.
2) Competition is great! Let it happen. It will take the power away from monopolies!
3) The entire point of neo-Nazis, disinformation-peddlers and foreign influence operations using these big platforms is to recruit, amplify to more people and monetize. If they go to smaller platforms, great. But they don’t want to because they don’t have the reach.
4) The entire FrEE SpEeCH argument is blown up within this piece by the author. When you go to other, smaller platforms, you’re STILL POSTING! No one is being stopped from speaking their mind. They just don’t get to amplify. Freedom of speech doesn’t mean freedom of reach. Duh.
.@instagram has somehow succeeded in convincing the world that it’s a fun, friendly platform.
In fact, it’s just like every other platform, filled with hate, disinformation and harassment, unable or unwilling to do the sizable moderation that it requires.
Having been a victim of intense harassment on this platform and others, it is beyond ridiculous that users, who have voluntarily given these platforms their data, are regularly left to fend for themselves and helpless to deal with what should be the simplest right: To feel safe.
NEW: Not only is @youtube doing the bare minimum to stop election disinformation coming from OANN, they’re allowing it to be profitable by placing major advertisers on these videos. This is unbelievably irresponsible.
Examples below:
Here’s @Athleta sponsoring one of OANN’s videos that is labeled by @youtube to be election misinformation.
Here’s @QuickenLoans inadvertently sponsoring a debunked Project Veritas report on OANN because @YouTube placed them there.