I gotta say, while there were many gems in the #NewPublicFestival session on online safety, watching the convo dynamics was v uncomfortable, even triggering. Without meaning to, it illustrated why moderating just “for safety” is not enough.
That said, some points that stood out:
On being asked to choose b/w "creative tension" of online spaces optimizing for inclusive presence vs for courageous engagement, @natematias notes research shows without spaces where folks feel truly welcome, they cannot engage courageously. (So we all lose.) #NewPublicFestival
.@Anasuyashh made many excellent points (+ much needed rebuttals) but I'm most grateful for her reminder that our modern day digital public squares are built on slave labour. Content farms are exploitative and dehumanizing, with profits to Western corporations. #NewPublicFestival
“The person that is first to feel unsafe is the person that has traditionally been the most marginalized.” @Anasuyashh
Which is why these communities must be driving design. Not as research subjects but as full designers. (And not just for online spaces.) #NewPublicFestival
.@krmaher noted in the common calls to “creating welcoming spaces”, we assume that there are those that are “the welcomers” and those that “get welcomed”, which reinforces traditional powerful hierarchies.
I have 5 invites in my inbox to "co-create the future”.
I’ve architected, negotiated, led a lot of co-creation work. True co-creation. With stakeholders from diverse backgrounds (regionally, economically, politically, culturally) + some that hate each other.
What I've learned:
Co-creation is not throwing a bunch of people into a space / process / initiative and expecting magic to happen.
That’s wishful thinking—and usually comes from a place of privileged myopia.
Co-creation is not gathering ideas from a bunch of people, then figuring out what you do with them later.
That’s a consultation. One that is at best poorly planned, and at worst highly insulting.
Gives me chills to read this from a state recovery plan:
"The road to economic recovery should not be across women’s backs..."
[thread]
“Economy” comes from Greek, meaning to “manage the household".
Women in our communities have never been busier taking care of loved ones, provisioning supplies, finding ways to offset the enormous economic and social burdens of this time."
"These aspects of the economy usually go uncounted + hidden yet there would be no economy without them.
The cheap value of caregiving is not natural; it has political origins. Caregiving, associated with / expected of women, is necessary for economic production to take place..."