Perfectly true. Statist social democracy is an inherently cross-class, and ultimately nationalist, project. This is the party Labour has been for the vast majority of its existence. Criticise rightwards lurches by all means, but they’re reversions to type, not aberrations.
This doesn’t mean Labour left should shrug and accept this stuff on a “well, what do you expect?” basis, but if we’re going to transform the labour movement we have to actually *contest* its dominant ideology, not just be despairingly outraged at the fact that it *is* dominant.
I am aware that I risk sounding like a smug know-it-all here - “*I* have an analysis of the cross-class nature of Labour, *you* are merely despairingly outraged” - and whilst that is, ultimately, what being a male leftist on Twitter is all about, that’s not actually my intent.
A healthy of dose of outrage is, of course, a necessary ingredient, but unless it impels action, it’s at best merely personally cathartic and at worst incapacitating. The question needs to be: how do we build an effective class-struggle internationalist tendency in Labour?

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Daniel Randall

Daniel Randall Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @therubykid

16 Dec 20
Some thoughts on how the socialist left should think about media/press, both in terms of our attitude to the “MSM”, and the development of the movement’s own media, a propos of... well, check the TL.
Firstly, we need to junk conspiracy-theorist attitudes to the “MSM” and replace them with a rational understanding of the role of the media/press in capitalist society. Their role is absolutely ideological, and different media institutions have different ideological slants...
...but suggesting “the MSM” is a relatively homogenous entity engaged in a wilful project to lie and misinform is a mind-rotting conspiracy theory. Some sources *do* tell lies, but extrapolating from that an attitude of default refusal to believe anything “the MSM” says is wrong.
Read 11 tweets
6 Oct 20
This seems a positive development, making a vital case for worker-led transition in a key union. Currently unions like GMB and Unite are wedded to policies like support for airport expansion. Rank-and-file campaigns like this have the potential to change that.
There are ongoing discussions around these issues in my union too. In 2019, our general secretary opposed an AGM motion supporting a socialist Green New Deal on the basis that it would put our offshore energy worker members out of jobs: theclarionmag.org/2019/09/04/why…
In the year since, our offshore energy workers’ branch @RMTOILC1 has worked with @PlatformLondon, @GreenpeaceUK, and @FoEScot, who produced a report about oil and gas workers’ struggles for job security, and the possibility of a worker-led transition: rmt.org.uk/news/rmt-react…
Read 4 tweets
5 Sep 20
Safely distanced @CampaignUyghur protest outside the Chinese Embassy. @MahmutRahima currently speaking. ImageImageImage
Polish LGBT+ activist Jarek addresses the protest. “Solidarity between the oppressed all over the world is vital.” Also draws links between historic struggles against Stalinist totalitarianism in Poland and struggles for freedom and democracy in China today. @CampaignUyghur Image
Igor from @razem_londyn now speaking. Great solidarity from the Polish comrades today. @RazemInt @CampaignUyghur Image
Read 5 tweets
3 Sep 20
Skwawkbox’s promotion of ultra-reactionary religious bigots like Stern tells you a lot - ditto the continued lionisation by a section of the left of the Neturei Karta cult. They’ll big up some the worst reactionaries going as long as it fits their narrative.
It’s important to break down what’s actually going on here. The reason they love Stern and Neturei Karta is that it gives them figures who appear more “authentically” Jewish - ultra-Orthodox, beards, shtreimels, and payes - who’ll echo their talking points about antisemitism.
It’s a toxic form of vicarious identity politics. Stern, Neturei Karta, and the rest of the Jewish religious far right (and make no mistake: that’s what they are) are, first and foremost, bitterly hostile to expressions of Jewishness that are modern, secular, and progressive.
Read 6 tweets
24 Aug 20
This almost certainly says as much about Murray himself as it does about Corbyn, but in any case, this definitely speaks to some of the reasons why some of the far left struggles with antisemitism.
It’s true that, relative to our historic position, Jews in Britain *are* better off now. And antisemitism isn’t a form of “oppression”, in a systemic sense, in this country: I’m unlikely to be denied a job or a tenancy, or face police brutality, because I’m Jewish.
Does that mean antisemitism is therefore a marginal prejudice, not worth bothering with, essentially “victimless”, and maybe even a form of “punching up”, because of the “relatively prosperous” position of the Jewish community? Emphatically not.
Read 9 tweets
23 Aug 20
Yes, crudely equating Nazism and Stalinism is wrong, but a) there *are* many obvious parallels, and b) I’m not interested in celebrating “Communism” as a liberating force any more than I am in celebrating UK/US imperialism, which also liberated death camps, as one. Image
Trotsky was on the money when he said that the “political apparatus” of Stalinism and fascism “does not differ, save in more unbridled savagery.”
“Communism” (which in this context means “Stalinism”) was an oppressive system, featuring prison camps and enslaved labour. The idea that that system was a force for “liberation” in any consistent sense is as ludicrous as the idea that British colonialism was “liberating”.
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!