This evening I am attending the @MellonFdn's "Storytelling for Justice: How Libraries & Archives Hold History to Account," featuring Elizabeth Alexander (@ProfessorEA), Jarrett Martin Drake (@jmddrake), Carla Hayden (@LibnOfCongress) & Kelly Lytle Hernández (@klytlehernandez)
In the opening talk, @ProfessorEA describes some of the Mellon's support of work to advance "the sacred and urgent mission of increasing equity in archival work."
First question: Archives are treasure troves. After lots of work in them, we find something wonderful. What was an archival discovery that deeply affected you and the trajectory of your work?
Carla Hayden: Describes seeing the papers of Frederick Douglass, one of her heroes bc of his emphasis on literacy. Serendipitously found his thoughts, in his own hand, on Lincoln's assassination. Seeing the emotion jumping off the page.
Hayden later learned that she only discovered the item bc it had been misfiled. This has helped her generate her commitment to improving discovery of archival collections.
Kelly Lytle Hernández: I was taught that you show up at an archives & work with what is there. But the stories that I cared about had not been told from the perspective of the folks most affected: undocumented, overpoliced, etc. We need to find and build the archives.
Lytle Hernández: Tonight I want to talk about getting access to policy records, which are notoriously difficult. I worked with the ACLU to get access to LAPD records that had never been seen before and were on track for destruction.
Lytle Hernández: One gem was a use of force file from a helicopter that identified a car without headlights on, chase them down on foot and by air, and shoot Alonzo Simmons. LAPD said he was a GTA suspect and deserved this shooting. Reparative work for those most impacted.
Alexander: What does it mean for historians and researchers to be able to reconstruct the record? There is a transformation that takes place. The work required to gain access to an FBI file is another example. The repair work has so many applications.
Drake: I worked at the Maryland State Archives on a project about the legacy of slavery. Uplifting narratives of people who fled slavery and those who assisted them. The Eastern Shore counties were a special focus.
Drake: There was a free Black man John Brown who in the 1850s in Kent Country helped three enslaved individuals escape. He was jailed for 6 years per enslaved individual he helped escape. He died in prison, shot by prison officers, allegedly for having a razor blade.
Drake: Our obligation is to hold history to account and to do that we must continue the unfinished project of abolition.
Alexander: What was it like to use the @BeineckeLibrary as a Yale undergrad for African American Studies? Drake: I didn't know that I could become a professional archivist. Seeing the James Weldon Johnson Collection, papers of Langston Hughes, was moving.
Hayden: We had the neighborhood libraries open in Baltimore during the uprising following the death of Freddie Gray. In the moment, we helped people channel their anger, show them context. I often think of the Rosa Parks papers, which Library of Congress was able to digitize.
Alexander: Hayden is yards away from the impeachment trial. Hayden: Describes efforts to gather materials and record stories from Black Lives Matters plaza, the insurrection, the impeachment/trial, etc. Ensuring the story is documented.
Lytle Hernández: Explaining the concept of "rebel archives," collecting the documents and ephemera that evade police destruction. Many people work with such archives in a variety of ways. We need to ensure we are retaining the rebel archive.
Lytle Hernández: Even before the uprisings this summer, LA was on the precipice of moving past the era of mass incarceration & we wanted to document the voices of those from South Central, Watts, East LA, etc, who have borne the burden of excessive policing & overincarceration.
Lytle Hernández: We're collecting ephemera, oral history, mix tapes, love letters, police records, etc. Community members are driving and selecting what gets preserved. Thanks to Mellon for supporting this work.
Alexander: I am hearing about individual lives, private things, letters, without any intention of them being seen outside that context.
Lytle Hernández: Emphasizes the importance of having folks from the affected communities charged, in perpetuity, with managing and protecting their records.
Hayden: It's important that stories stay in communities but also that they not be excluded from the larger narratives. Alexander: Yes, that is the hard work of reintegrating American history.
Lytle Hernández: Our UCLA Million Dollar Hoods is a big data project gathering info on policing and incarceration. Probably one of the few Black and Indigenous led big data teams in the country. The story that comes out looks a lot different as a result.
Alexander: Having the ability to look at something and see and know why it is relevant and what are the consequences of it, and many eyes and angles with that perspective, that is the importance of the work.
Attendee q on what data are necessary to reform the US criminal justice system? Drake: Reform is incompatible with Black life. We have an abundance of data. I arrive at an abolitionist praxis & politics. I am looking for data to build the type of world where we want to live.
Lytle Hernández: Very interesting remarks about the transition from enslavement to Jim Crow to mass incarceration and will there be liberation now? Or simply a new vise? This is why documentation of this moment is just so important now.
I'm really fascinated by several things about this acquisition. 1. One could posit that APC business models in structural decline as they are replaced by transformative agreements. Will Hindawi titles be folded into Wiley TA's or offered as a separate "pure publish" model?
2. Seems that there is little concern about geopolitical risk: "Wiley…saw value in Hindawi’s strong position in Asia, the world’s largest and fastest growing academic publishing market…“Hindawi’s significant footprint in in China is a major benefit from that perspective”"
Now, we will have a debate about preprints between @jessicapolka and @kanderson. I hope we will have less of a formal debate seeking a "winner" and more of an opportunity to learn about the array of issues. @_IanMoss is moderating. #STMAnnualUS
Polka shares "tremendous growth" of preprints, including new services some associated with incumbent publishers. #STMAnnualUS
Polka: A significant share of coronavirus research is being issued as preprints. And as preprints grow in significant, there are also valid concerns about malicious or invalid results. #STMAnnualUS
Elsevier's new CEO Kumsal Bayazit starting her opening plenary address at #ChsConf2019
Bayazit: "My hope and ambition for Elsevier is to work constructively with all the stakeholders in the system of research...and to evolve our services for the future." @chsconf2019
Bayazit: "It's clear there are serious issues and I want to use our time today to begin to address them." #chsconf2019
@lisalibrarian@paul_abrahams@bc_butler@acochran12733@CharlesOppenh Friends, I am not replying to any specific tweet here, just the latest in this long thread. I'm not familiar with the specific measure of market concentration that Paul points to. But perhaps I can offer some perspective to this conversation. 1/
@lisalibrarian@paul_abrahams@bc_butler@acochran12733@CharlesOppenh For academic libraries, bundles have been nearly irresistible, because of how they (& standalone journal titles) have been priced -- & bc of the principal-agent problem associated with buying on behalf of faculty members. This problem is compounded in a consortia negotiation. 3/
Now, ITHAKA president Kevin Guthrie interviews Elsevier chair YS Chi. #ithakatnw18
Guthrie: How do you square revenue with purpose in a commercial setting? Chi: You have to balance the two or you cannot persist. Sometimes it is a matter of timeline. Shareholders demand short term; Leaders must ensure longer term perspective. #ithakatnw18
Chi: We are trying to ask the market to be on a journey with us. If you want only short term returns, please do not own our shares. #ithakatnw18