1) The senate has standing rules to allow it to do legislative work while taking testimony; the tension between them is largely a canard.
2) It’s vitally important to preserve testimony and very hard to call these witnesses in other forums.
3) It will be easier for Republicans to defend acquittal votes politically without hearing sworn testimony or seeing damning subpoenaed documents. They’ll have a ready excuse if it comes out later.
4) The moment the acquittal takes place the whole political dynamic will shift.
5) Putting on the best case you possibly can is self-evidently the right thing to do. It honors the lives that were lost and stands up on behalf of the people who were traumatized. I’ve heard voters prefer that to half ass efforts.
6) A lot of us want to know the whole truth. As the late breaking McCarthy call shows, it hasn’t yet been told and could have political ramifications beyond what we presently imagine.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
The Democrats could have appointed a committee to take testimony under Rule 11 and run through whomever managers wanted to call plus Jason Miller’s 301 witnesses or whatever over the next eight months without using a day of floor time for it.
Failing that, they could have used the time while depositions were being taken to advance their agenda on they floor. They could have passed rules limiting the trial to half of any given day and the conducted regular business in the other half. They control the Senate.
“Investigators have determined that initial reports suggesting Sicknick was struck with a fire extinguisher aren't true, CNN previously reported.” cnn.com/2021/02/10/pol…
Those initial reports were, of course, also attributed to multiple anonymous law enforcement officials. nytimes.com/2021/01/07/adm…
It’s something a Capitol Police briefing on the events of Jan 6th would do a lot to clarify, because a reporter could ask a briefer on the record what the cause of death was, or whether there was a medical examiner’s report, how they decided to release the body for burial, etc
The first order says that the court took into account Maxwell's and others' reliance on the protective order in the case when it ordered those materials unsealed.
The first order notes that the court of appeals distinguished btw testimony about 'consensual sexual activity with adults" (kept sealed) and about "purportedly non-sexual massages" (ordered disclosed); the judge says she's following that rubric for the depo.
So it’s going to pass and be more bipartisan than the most bipartisan impeachment in history.
The 11 Rs:
Brian Fitzpatrick (PA-1)
Carlos Giménez (FL-26)
Chris Jacobs (NY-27)
John Katko (NY-24)*
Young Kim (CA-39)
Adam Kinzinger (IL-16)*
Nicole Malliotakis (NY-11)
Maria Salazar (FL-27)
Chris Smith (NJ-4)
Fred Upton (MI-6)*
Mario Diaz-Balart (FL-25)