Immigration law doesn’t target Indian immigrants. They take the largest share of employment-based Green Cards each year.
The problem is the dual-intent nature of the H-1B program that pushes a business model to displace/discriminate American workers using cheaper Indian workers.
75% of H-1B visa go to Indian nationals each year & the top 10 sponsors of H-1B visas are Indian IT outsourcing firms. These aren’t “high-skilled” rocket scientists either. These are low-end IT workers that are coming in to displace American IT workers through fissured work.
The massive oversubscription of the H-1B program by Big Tech & Indian IT outsourcing firms crowds out other nationalities from getting H-1B visas.
If anything, the current H-1B program is stifling true high-skilled talent:
To ensure diversity & no one country being able to monopolize all Green Cards, country cap quotas were introduced to our immigration laws.
Because the H-1B allows foreign workers to also seek Green Cards, naturally Indians make up a HUGE block due to the broken H-1B program.
Removing country caps would ensure only Indian nationals would receive employment-based Green Cards for the next decade & larger backlogs for the Rest Of The World (ROW).
Why do Indian nationals make up the highest share of H-1B recipients?
1. India is the mecca for IT outsourcing. They have established offices in the US to take contract work. They use H-1B visas to help facilitate offshoring & to increase profit margins through wage arbitrage.
2. Indian nationals make up the second largest cohort (China is first) of international students. The intent of these students is to find jobs in the US right after graduation & are willing to do whatever it takes for an employer to sponsor the H-1B: motherjones.com/politics/2017/…
3. Nepotism.
Indian immigrant managers tend to hire their own. Many of them in Silicon Valley not only discriminate against US workers, they discriminate against the hiring of other non-Indian workers.
The H-1B program is a total sham!
DC-Libertarians are corporate funded fraudsters that have no idea how immigration policy works & don’t have the interest of American workers.
Their solutions involve expanding immigration so as to enrich the corporate oligarchs that fund them.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
America is one giant playground for the elites who have engaged in harmful arbitrage profiteering schemes.
They displaced our labor using cheap visa workers; off-shored manufacturing; & purposefully bankrupted companies for stock wins.
Destruction for profit.
The Boeing Company was once driven by innovation. Then an MBA-finance type CEO took over & started looking for quick shortcuts to increase profits. Result: two plane crashes.
Disney had a cutting-edge IT team consisting of high-skilled American workers who were good at what they did. Disney decided to lay them off but not before training their foreign H-1B replacements. They were forced into early retirement.
Progressives often look to Denmark as a beacon of success & want those successes replicated in the US.
What Progressives fail to address is Denmark’s restrictive immigration policies. They have a Social Democrat/Liberal (party) PM who is an immigration restrictionist.
The Danes aren’t anti-immigrants. They just understand that a more lenient immigration policy would create an economic burden to the country because of their numerous social welfare programs (healthcare, education, paid vacation, etc), & effect on wages.
Denmark has a capitalistic system that ensures their citizen’s benefit first. They realize there’s no utility in having a country if the majority of their people are suffering. They don’t try to make a quick buck by screwing over their citizens as is emblematic in the US.
The @GOP inaccurately claims to think that our government and taxpayers are able to keep up with the masses of people if they only happen to come in "legally".
The GOP will constantly ramble about how illegal immigration is bad. Truth be told, they love undocumented workers. Why? Because they can exploit them and increase their profit margins because these workers have no choice. Look at Gov. Ricketts R-NE:
Why is Gov. Ricketts (R-NE) allowing meatpacking factories to hire undocumented workers? Why isn't he prosecuting these businesses if he is so against illegal immigration?
Reality is that Ricketts et al. see undocumented workers as a benefit because it enriches his funders.
Essentially what Noah is saying is that because immigrants not only work, but they “also buy stuff”, that implies wages go up for the labor to produce that “stuff”. A child breaking a window doesn’t mean it’s a good thing because it creates a job for a window repairman.
Charles Pfizer was an established German businessman and scientist before he relocated to the United States in 1848 - a period when the US had no immigration laws. He cofounded Pfizer with his brother in 1849 (one year later).
As the number of new migrant arrivals started skyrocketing in the 1880s, economic conditions began to worsen in some parts of the country which led to formal immigration policy being implemented by the government.