Okay so I read the article. Good lord what a steaming pile of special pleading disingenuous garbage. Here’s one emblematic example from the part where Glenn claims it’s ‘propaganda’ to call it ...
2/ an ‘armed insurrection.’ Here’s the logic. “That protesters were found before and after the riot with weapons does not mean they intended to use them as part of the protest.” So just because they had weapons when they were doing the insurrection doesn’t mean it’s ...
3/ an armed insurrection. It’s way too big a leap to say it was an armed insurrection. There’s no causal connection! Lol. Of course Glenn’s big push is Sicknick Trutherism, where he goes whole hog with the white nationalist site that got it started.
4/ Glenn’s fast and loose flim flam is worth some momentary unpacking. As Glenn would have it news reports had Sicknick brutally murdered with his head bashed in. Sloppy interested journalists used this to discredit the stop the steal movement and their insurrection.
5/ But now it turns out the whole story was fake and the liberal media won’t come clean. This is shall we say a rather distorted take on the story. From the very beginning there were two versions, significantly contradictory, of how Sicknick died. One had him ...
6/ struck on the head with a fire extinguisher. Another had him engaging with protectors, going back to his office and then later collapsing. One can sort of wrench these stories together. But again, they’re not really consistent. And they both originate from the first ...
7/ reports of Sicknick’s death. We still don’t know enough about how Sicknick died. And that is part of a larger story and failure of the relevant authorities to update the public on their investigations. From the limited reporting what seems clear that investigators don’t ...
8/ know exactly what or who killed Sicknick. The clearest evidence of that is the fact that no one has been charged with his death. But to Glenn the whole thing was a fake and totally discredited. But remember. Sicknick is actually dead. And as I explained ...
9/ here it is all but certain that he sustained an injury battling insurrectionists. talkingpointsmemo.com/edblog/the-sic…
10/ For Glenn either Sicknick was “brutally murdered” and left for dead on the floor or basically nothing happened. It is not uncommon for people to get head injuries which seem unremarkable and then later have blood clots which kill them. The relevant fact is that ...
11/ Sicknick died as a direct result of the insurrection. Just because we don’t know the exact cause of death doesn’t materially change that. It is also worth noting that we have very detailed and confirmed accounts of other officers who suffered severe bearings ...
12/ which easily could have been fatal but weren’t. One officer was severely beaten, lost consciousness and suffered a heart attack as a result of the beating. Another was struck in the head with a fire extinguisher. There’s video of it. Just the video isn’t of Sicknick.
13/ It’s of yet another officer who was the victim of a violent assault that could have easily been fatal but wasn’t. Let’s focus on the core issue here. Glenn has glommed on to a story by a white nationalist website which claims that Sicknick was cremated as part ...
14/ of a cover-up to discredit the MAGA movement. That’s Glenn’s source. Based on uncertainty or confusion about Sicknick’s exact cause of death he’s laundered the whole insurrection into a largely peaceful sit in that has been maliciously defamed to advance the ...
15/ interests of neoliberalism. As is now always the case with Glenn, his embittered animus toward mainstream Democrats or really anyone who doesn’t embrace the tenets of Glennism leads him to happily embrace authoritarians, dictators, racists, fascists, revanchist ...
16/ nationalist parties, really anyone if they can in any way be helpful in making the case that the real threat to democracy, human rights, transparency, your comfortable couch or freedom is Hillary Clinton and Joe Biden.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Josh Marshall

Josh Marshall Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @joshtpm

19 Feb
2/ There's a worthwhile point that we can draw out of this otherwise useless dumbshittery. Folks on the right who stile themselves "constitutional conservatives" generally know next to nothing about the constitution and treat it as a kind of go to unicorn to validate what ...
3/ they want to be true. But even to the extent some have a decent understanding of the original document, or even the original with the first batch of amendments, there is a strong implicit and sometimes explicitly assumption that the "real" constitution is what we might ...
Read 9 tweets
18 Feb
For anyone curious it's a complete misstatement/misunderstanding of the how the government operates to claim that only Govs and Mayors are hands on players in a major disaster. Reps and especially Senators actually play a very key role QB'ing liaison and assistance from the ...
2/ federal govt. Govs and Mayors have hands on authority with local government. But Senators have built in robust relationships with the various agencies of the federal govt. And also clout. They oversee the federal govt. Lots of individuals, localities fall through the racks ...
3/ in major disasters. It's a element of constituent service to QB and lobby for aid for those people and communities. There's a bunch of other stuff folks in Congress organize, do during these situations in addition to things that are more performative, showing up ...
Read 5 tweets
18 Feb
It’s a very weird thing with cons and Limbaugh. I begrudge no one their grief. I celebrate no ones passing, even people I loathe. Death is too central to the human condition; it affects too many beyond the person who died. But the aggression and provocation that was ...
2/ central to Limbaugh’s political and media persona seem to follow him in death. His followers imitate it *about* him. Limbaugh was born in Missouri. He got famous in New York. He lived his final years in Florida. I’m not aware of any connection he has to Wisconsin.
3/ Does Wisconsin have any history of flag lowering for media figures who aren’t from Wisconsin? I strongly suspect not. Obviously to his followers he’s not just a media figure. He’s a big big deal. But that’s the point. Even bring generous he’s a highly and intentionally ...
Read 6 tweets
12 Feb
To give you a sense of the article behind the conspiracy theory being pushed by McCarthy, Carlson, Greenwood, et al here’s the article’s description of the insurrection itself ... talkingpointsmemo.com/edblog/the-sic…
2/ In other words, the story now being pushed by Trump apologists suggests that the insurrection was basically a misunderstanding by some tourists who took a wrong turn at the visitors center.
3/ It’s not clear where the author of the article was during the insurrection. But he appears to be close to many of the organizers of the insurrection and spent the two or three hours of the insurrection tweeting out tweets to various prominent African-Americans to ...
Read 6 tweets
11 Feb
There's now a Brian Sicknick "truth movement" on the right, which suggests Sicknick either died of natural causes or was murdered to tarnish ex-President Trump. Today this new conspiracy theory made its way to National Review. I trace it to its source. talkingpointsmemo.com/edblog/the-sic…
2/ The conspiracy theory seems to originate with a former Trump speech writer, Darren Beattie, who was fired in 2018 after @KFILE unearthed the fact that he'd attended a white nationalist conference in 2016. After Trump lost the November election he appointed Beattie to a ...
3/ commission charged with overseeing Holocaust commemoration.
Read 8 tweets
7 Feb
@HeerJeet This shld really be seen in the context of the larger absurdity of much of the legal academy in which amateurs freelance in fields they have no expertise in under the imprimatur of elite university distinction. We might call it the Law and Economics Grandiosity Problem.
@HeerJeet 2/ I shld anticipate the criticism that many law profs do important work outside narrow study of law. But those are the ones who actually seek to learn from and operate within the knowledge of other fields, even if they lack formal credentials (which are often overrated.)
@HeerJeet 3/ This problem doesn't affect all communities equally. Incidents is much higher on the right. But alas it crops up across the ideological spectrum. I was first introduced to it rather roughly. Not long after I started as an editor at The American Prospect I was assigned ...
Read 16 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!