The "Two Cultures" debate ceased to mean anything the minute Quillette used C. P. Snow in order to attack humanities and social sciences and defend scientific racism and eugenics.
https://twitter.com/JamesBSumner/status/800618088282648576
It's just culture-war shorthand for "worldviews" that answer neither to Snow's actual descriptions nor to the current realities of research in any of the fields concerned.
Notably, Snow's targets were not social scientists, nor "humanists" in any general sense; notably, too, he distinguished between the situation in the UK and that in the US. Finally, he wrote before most people working today -- and many research fields -- were born.
As with commentators whose only point of reference for political danger is "1984", it might be time for writers whose only way of thinking about different kinds of research is "The Two Cultures" to take the plunge and read a second book.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
