Please recall that our society has always "cancelled" people &, in the past, this cancellation was often for bad reasons. Rupert Everett famously said that coming out ruined his career. Being openly LGBTQ is still perilous for actors. "The Chix" were cancelled for being anti-war.
I'll repeat what I've said before: that "cancel culture" is an amorphous euphemism that encompasses all kinds of disparate phenomena. In the case of companies "canceling" a creator, conservatives have always been fine w/ it when this "cancellation" fit their ideology.
In any case, conservatives don't have any real issue w/ art or artists or anyone being "canceled." They've done this themselves all the time. What they care about is that the tide has turned & that "canceling" now often involves the bigot, rather than those who are persecuted
Well I did and they're terrible 😬. I hope this doesn't undermine the point that it is very hard--even today--for actors to come out as LGBTQ. I remember Everett struggling w/ this in the 90's, when he was a rising star.

Imagine what Elliot Page has had to go thru. 1st coming out as gay restricted his roles (it has for many actors). Then affirming his gender may have further restricted them. LGBTQ ppl have to worry about *unjustified* "cancellation" their whole lives. But conservatives love this.
The Venn between conservatives who support j.k. rowling in her anti-trans agenda & those who wanted to ban Harry Potter b/c it had wizards in it and/or b/c rowling said Dumbledore was gay is likely almost a perfect circle.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Mangy Jay

Mangy Jay Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @magi_jay

3 Mar
What happened to Neera Tanden was wrong, not just in terms of her personal story, but also because of the larger socio-political dynamics at play. Tanden was attacked because she is a woman who is confident in her political affiliation & who justifiably criticized Republicans.
This interacted with other dynamics, such as grudges over the 2016 primary, the fact that twitter amplifies & even creates stories out of thin air, & the tendency from some in the media to drive scandals motivated by perceived personal conflict, rather than objective evidence.
This resulted in an evidence-free situation in which a woman’s reputation was bound to “mean tweets,” despite the fact that the "mean" tweets don’t exist. And, yes, this was made possible by the fact that Tanden is not just a woman, but a woman of color.
Read 27 tweets
2 Mar
One interesting thing about pieces on this issue is that they rarely mention whether the Iraqi government was consulted about the U.S. strikes & whether that would change anyone's calculus about justification. The government certainly wasn't happy about the militia strike
The Middle E. is really hard to talk about & one could take a maximalist position that the U.S. should just leave entirely. However, there are also positions requiring we address how to best fulfill our responsibilities to Iraq, given how we ravaged the country & region
However, regardless of which position one is inclined to take, it seems curious to me that we argue a lot about what the U.S. should do that would be best for Iraq while rarely discussing what the Iraq government thinks about the same issue & whether that informs our position
Read 5 tweets
1 Mar
There are a number of legitimate debates to be had re: the recent airstrike, w/ various possible left-leaning positions to take, yet so many have landed on a "say their names" approach to militias, as well as a conflation between these militias & the civilians they terrorized.
It sounds a bit tinny to my ear to hear, over and over, "Biden bombed Syrians," when actually the U.S. struck 22 Iranian militia members. Whether or not you think the strike was justified, Iranian militia members are not the same as Syrian civilians.
In any case, there are legitimate debates to be had here, like I said. These include, but are not limited to: executive strike authorities & restrictions that should be placed on them, whether there can be exceptions, proportional response, LOTS of sovereignty considerations, etc
Read 8 tweets
1 Mar
In the next sentence the staffer told the Post, “I object to this invasion of my privacy with the use of personal texts. . . These statements are taken out of context and completely misconstrue my relationship with Neera. We had a very close working relationship.”
It's an interesting choice by the @washingtonpost to first publish the texts against the best wishes of one of the participants' & to then go on to promote those same texts w/out citing her objections on social media

What would a journalistic ethics class have to say about this?
We're not talking about a national security issue here. We're talking about a leaked text message from an employee about her boss. A text message she said she didn't want published. A text message that has since been promoted by @washingtonpost reporters w/out that context.
Read 6 tweets
28 Feb
I'm willing to believe that stage was a mistake (or not), but y'all can't support politicians who believe Jewish people are running a global child-murdering cabal then turn around & clutch your chests & proclaim, "Nazi symbols? Us? Impossible!" You lost your plausible deniability
If the Nazi insignia had occurred at a beauty pageant or awards show, wondering about its significance would be conspiratorial. It's not actually conspiratorial to ask questions when we're talking about people who "stumble" upon this imagery while supporting politicians like this
"How dare liberals question whether we used Nazi insignia?! Now let me recommence tweeting about how a Jewish man masterminded & funded all of our political opposition in a grand scheme to destroy 'society,' which bears no resemblance whatsoever to 1930's Nazi propaganda."
Read 4 tweets
27 Feb
These allegations are well-corroborated and fit a pattern of alleged behavior. I think Cuomo should resign.
If he's gonna wait for an investigation, ok. But I don't see how an investigation is going to show something different than we've already seen. There are contemporaneous text messages about his behavior.
Look, I liked Cuomo during the initial stages of the pandemic too, though it looks like he mishandled several things (nursing homes) in retrospect. But my primary concern here is to principles re: sexual misconduct + the fact that I don't want the Dem party to have this baggage.
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!