#AMPA2021 Side Thread on Standing rules.

-Equity related amendments to Standing Rules are coming. Will report that here, then return to Equity Plan.

-One amendment passes - no speeding up of debate until budget is passes.
-Next amendment to Standing Rules - Remove "cannot rise on another red card when this issue has been addressed." Who decides when the issue is "addressed". Again, can be used to silence members.

-Some simple debate, working to clarify how the red card rule works in practice.
-All speakers are in favour of removing the line that "red cards shall not be used to rise on the same point that has been been addressed". Some questions peppered in.

-Mover to close, then voting.
Result: 48% in favour - 52% opposed. Motion defeated. (With no one speaking against it on the floor (other than through questions))- this is what today's threads are referring to re: parliamentary rules and potential silencing.
-We are back to the Standing Rules (after campaign speeches and the Green Party Leader).

-We are 20 minutes from end of day, and have no agenda or standing rules.

-Red cards on the vote on the last amendment - due to tech, not all voices were heard - explanation in next tweet.
-Prior to speeches the point was raised that not all debate was heard on the amendment. Red card raised the point that this should have been dealt with prior to speeches, as there is currently no agenda, and no rules, and we were in the middle of the debate on a motion.
-This is an interesting case of Robert's Rules being applied in a way that is convenient...not accurate (and therefore subject to bias, and wielded by those in power)

-Parliamentarians from the floor are now schooling steering and chair about Robert's Rules.
-From the floor: Quoting RR, no motion needed to reopen debate on previous amendment where a speaker was missed, and a restatement that that should have happened immediately when the point was raised over an hour ago, rather than continuing with the meeting (out of line with RR).
-And instead of falling in line with the above (timed items are meaningless with no agenda, etc.), we are in recess, and will deal with the re-opened amendment, tomorrow "when we can" (i.e. after a variety of timed items). My brain hurts. Maybe be back tonight re: campaigns.
SOOOOOOOO.... Election of Prov. Leaders is on hold for tech reasons. Back to Standing rules (11:00 AM, second day of meeting).

We are still working through if you can rise more than once on a red card for the same point. Question called on amendment. May get standing rules soon
-I can't even begin to summarize the last hour, so I will just refer to the below tweet with respect. Ending the Standing Rules thread unless we are still here tomorrow.

Nope! One more thing re: OSSTF "doing the work", Robert's Rules, and colonialism:

If their internal equity reviews haven’t identified that using colonial structures is harmful then those internals reviews weren’t worth sh*t.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Ontario Education Workers United

Ontario Education Workers United Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @OntEdWorkers

15 Mar
Final #AMPA2021 Thread - A Reading List

Much was made this weekend of reading, learning, and personal journeys. Clearly more is needed.

Here is a list.

-Curated briefly, by me, with what the meeting made me think about.
-It is non-exhaustive.
-It is clearly necessary.
-21 Things You May Not Know about the Indian Act - Bob Joseph

-Seven Fallen Feathers: Racism, Death, and Hard Truths in a Northern City - Tanya Talaga

-The Truth About Stories - Thomas King
-White Rage - Carol Anderson

-Nice White Parents - from the Serial Podcast

-Letter from a Birmingham Jail - Martin Luther King Jr.

-Policing Black Lives - Robin Maynard
Read 5 tweets
15 Mar
#AMPA2021 Protest Thread

As a result of some of the statements, and actions, over the past few days, including the ongoing silencing, there are currently a number of members with the below profile picture. Image
In response to this, the leaders of the meeting, predictably, per the past few days, couldn't leave it alone.

We are now in a sea of red cards pointing out the arbitrary enforcement of rules, more parliamentary schooling, and more people expressing the harm being done.
The house was forced to vote on a challenge to the chair on their ruling. House voted 68% (or so) that the rules should be enforced, and those with the picture up would not be on camera when speaking.

Tells you where OSSTF is right now.
Read 23 tweets
14 Mar
Good morning! It's 'pots and pans' day at #AMPA2021.

(It's a long story).

This is the ⭐️Leadership Election Thread⭐️, as that is the big event this morning.

Voting for OSSTF President in progress.
Results for President:

Muna Kadri: 173
Karen Littlewood: 397

😞
Read 11 tweets
13 Mar
#AMPA2021 - Speeches thread.

-We are on to candidate speeches.

@munakadri - Talking about childhood and family coming to Canada as a refugee.

-When the government made cuts, she felt compelled to do more.

-We need to take back our stories from their lies.
-Muna has set out to frame and shape the communication about public education through CPAC, and has been extremely successful in that.

-When the gov't announced little COVID funding, she, working with community and grassroots campaigns, worked to get millions in more funding.
-What has happened during the pandemic. Have we been surveryed, communicated with, townhalled, by the union. No. Why have we not.

-In response to that lack of action, Muna launched parent and ed worker actions to advocate for a safer return.
Read 7 tweets
13 Mar
New #AMPA2021 thread.

-Immediately after Carol Wall's call to dismantle colonialism, a delegate posted a background stating "Open the chat. Stop defending white supremacy".

-Of course, the chair calls this out based on no "signs" being allowed in the house.
Note: No house rules have been passed yet.
Note: Last year, many members had t-shirts about not having benefits.

-Delegate changes background to "white fragility"

-Delegate gets phone call asking to take the background down.

-Delegate's video blocked, as it is "harassment".
-Chair and white delegate have advised to focus on unity, moving forward, wait for the equity motions and reports.

-The above points are now also experiencing a sea of red cards.

-Parliamentary policing feels like colonialism. (Editorial, not a quote.)

#AMPA2021 #OSSTF
Read 4 tweets
13 Mar
Good Morning!

Today is the start of #AMPA2021 - the OSSTF AGM.

We will be live tweeting it. Not all the administrative stuff (promise!), but the important motions and election news!

Here's where we are right now...No shade; virtual meetings take time to get going!
Tech issues done! Carol Wall is opening guest speaker!

Great talk about equity, anti-Black and anti-Indigenous racism, and how we have all breathed in this racism.

"Unions must work to dismantle this. This is the labour of unions."
"I hope that you work to decolonize your constitution and your practices."

"While you need to improve your representation in the union, that isn't enough.... these systems are not neutral, they are build on colonization and racism, and must be dismantled. You must do the work."
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!