Okay, this is going to be hard, but you're still going to get Erin's Optimistic Takes. Because the Department of Silver Linings never sleeps, and finding positivity matters the most when it's not easy to do.

1. Every team in the NHL will play a "worst game" this...
...season. This was ours. It was painful to watch from start to finish. Everything that could go wrong did, from bad plays to misread cues to injuries to significant missed calls (no, boarding is not okay, especially when the player you just slammed up against the...
...wall by the numbers only just got back from concussion protocol). Attempts to fight for possession and regain the offensive zone were better than Thursday but had little success; same with shots on goal, which, again, were better than Thursday but didn't phase...
Markstrom in the least. It was a terrible game for the Habs, and they know it.

But...and you knew this was coming...I feel confident enough to say that this was the worst game the Habs will have this season. It has to be, unless Ducharme and Bergevin both want to...
...lose their jobs. They don't. It's as simple as that. So our worst game is behind us now.

2. One thing about a game like this is that it clarifies some issues. The fact that the Habs started winning again--albeit not as much as they need to---under Ducharme showed that the
...coaching change was the right idea, for instance. What we saw tonight, to me, highlighted something really important. Yes, our forwards need more support from the Ds. That was painfully clear. But, also, you can't spend years prioritizing defense over offense...
...(with poor results, no less!) and then turn around and be surprised when, again and again, someone's got the puck near the net and an open shot and fails, somehow, to score. Sure, Markstrom is good. Sure, Calgary defends their zone. So does every team in the NHL...
...and you need at least some people who can score under these and every other kind of adverse conditions. Defense alone won't win you the game whether it's baseball, basketball, football, or hockey. We have one prospect coming who will help immensely with that...
...as we all know, but we have to have more than one. There are serious, painful decisions ahead. But at least every player on the team has seen that reality clearly and can't object to the changes yet to come.

3. I like Ducharme and believe he's the right man for the job...
...but some of his lineup decisions in recent games have been head-scratchers, and this was one of them. Unless this was a last chance for Byron or something like that, the decision to start Byron at 4C ended up being particularly harmful as Danault showed that he was...
...in pain and not himself. Had Evans been in his usual spot, Byron could have been moved from wing to C to cover for Danault instead of making him play on. And when Suzuki had to leave for concussion protocol Drouin had to take a bit of time at C. I cheerfully admit...
...there may be things going on no fan knows anything about, but that decision tonight ended up being costly. Why is this in the "optimistic takes" section? Because it's a reminder that as much as Ducharme is still teaching his team their new system, he's also...
...still learning too, and not all of his decisions will be perfect or anything.

4. Still awaiting final faceoff stats, but faceoffs were 50/50 between CGY and MTL tonight, which is an improvement for the Habs in an important area. Down the road, continued improvement in...
...the dot will be critical.

5. Jesperi Kotkaniemi finally played more than his usual. Current stats show 18:46 TOI. Surprisingly, Suzuki still had a little more despite how badly tonight's game went for him, but that has to be because of the early penalty kills.

6. Last...
...but not least: the Habs won't reach the halfway mark--28 of 56 games--for two more games (this was game 26). Anyone who is ready to throw the whole season away now is being as unrealistic as anyone ready to plan the parade after the victory over the Canucks the other night...
...er, the other morning? Whatever. We have as many games ahead as behind, plus two. I expect a few drastic changes in the next week or so, though I'm not going to guess what those will be. Most of them will be things the fans expect or at least won't find...
...surprising.

And re: that victory over Vancouver the other night: I said, and do believe, tonight was our worst game. I don't believe for a moment that the victory over Vancouver was the best game of the season. The Habs will show us that game soon. Game 35 or so, maybe.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Erin Manning Writes

Erin Manning Writes Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @emanningwrites

12 Mar
Last thoughts on tonight's #Habs game: the only conclusions anybody can draw from this game is that this is not the kind of game from which you can draw conclusions. Unusual season, unusual schedule, and unusual circumstances led to a team that played a game...
...that ran from roughly 8 p.m. to 11:30 p.m Van. time, got on a plane around 2 a.m., flew into a slightly different time zone, got settled into their hotel between 3 and 5 a.m. local time (according to Mete) after that, and had a game to play later that day. Why didn't...
...they stay the night in Vancouver and fly out after a decent sleep? Most likely explanation I've heard is Covid testing requirements, though I don't know for sure. In ordinary seasons, a back-to-back game usually has 24 hours between games, and if...
Read 5 tweets
12 Mar
Time now for Erin's Optimistic Takes. You didn't think I was going to skip them, did you? 😊

1. Yes, we lost to the Flames, in regulation. Not good. But not the end of the world, either.

2. Corey Perry. Enough said. The man...
...is a treasure to this team.

3. Jake Allen. It's his doing that the score remained within chasing distance until the (slightly bitter) end. He made some unreal saves and made it possible for Perry to ruin Markstrom's shutout.

4. Markstrom did not get a shutout. That...
...deserves its own take.

5. The boys were not on their game tonight, and it showed. They also played less than 20 hours earlier. I hear the "no excuses" crowd, and the people sneering that a one-hour plane flight is no big deal, etc. Do tell me: does the Habs' plane...
Read 8 tweets
11 Mar
We've all seen the reasons the #Habs may struggle tonight, and they are legit concerns. But in the spirit of Erin's Optimistic Takes, here are the things that may make all the difference:

1. Jake Allen. Sure, Price has been so terrific you almost wonder if it's...
... even necessary to start the backup goalie until you remember that it's Jake. Goalies are the only players on ice for the whole 60 and a b2b like this would be brutal for Carey. It's nice not to have to worry about it.

2. The forward lines. I sincerely hope...
...the top 3 are exactly what we saw last night. As for the 4th, the option to play Lehkonen exists--not that Perry wasn't wonderful last night, but fatigue may be a bigger factor at his age. Again: just nice to have the possibility.

3. Fresh Mete. Can't help but think this...
Read 5 tweets
11 Mar
Before I head to bed for the night, #Habs friends (I wasn't kidding when I said 3 a.m. was my bedtime; if anything, I was ignoring that it's often 3:30): a word about Suzuki.

I've seen people wondering what's wrong with him, questioning whether he's hiding an injury...
...and so on. He's not being dominant, so they say.

I can see what they're saying, but I'd be surprised if injury or anything else was going on. He was slipped into the 1C role before Julien was fired, and has quietly handled top line minutes, matchups, pressures...
...and responsibilities with no visible sign except the slight fall-off in the brilliance we've come to expect from him. And while many kids playing on outdoor rinks may dream of being top line center of a team like the Canadiens at the age of 21, the reality of...
Read 10 tweets
11 Mar
Confidence.

The word comes up again and again when we talk about the #Habs these days. Price's confidence is back, along with his game. Drouin and KK are visibly more confident, with results on the ice. From the kids to the vets the team radiates it, and tonight we saw...
...the results when the new system plus the little fixes plus that quality we call confidence all come together. Because it takes confidence to believe you can win, to avoid collapsing when the opposing team cuts a fragile lead in half, to stop and reset when discipline...
...falters and too many penalties rise.

Confidence. The Habs have got it back.

It raises the question: what happened to make them all lose it so badly in the first place? In a season where they started hot and everything was clicking, to all appearances, what happened?

In...
Read 6 tweets
13 Feb
I read Stu's column with some interest, because this theory--that it's the rolling of four lines that isn't working--is the opposite of my own inclination to think that rolling four lines *does* work for the #Habs, and getting away from it is what hurts.

So I ran the numbers...
...and found something intriguing.

CAVEATS:

1. Very small sample size. 14 games, 8 wins, 4 losses, 2 OT losses.
2. Comparison can only involve even-strength times on ice. Special team usage in reg or OT by definition is not "rolling lines".
3. Game situations...
...will cloud the issues; a player may have a short TOI due to injury or illness, or a situation might lead to a player being on the ice longer than usual. These impacts would be mitigated in the stats if we had a lot more games to draw stats from.
4. Most importantly, all...
Read 8 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!