So, something film-related from the weekend that shocked me and which has stayed with me, is that late on Friday night I dipped into the #Cesar2021 hashtag to see who had won prizes at France's top cinema awards, and was greeted by a torrent of reactionary/racist hate towards it.
People were annoyed at Fathia Youssouf and Jean-Pascal Zadi, two black actors, winning awards. They were pissed off with Fary, a black comedian. They were gleeful that Camélia Jordana, a French-Algerian actor, hadn't won an award. They were obsessed with Adama Traoré.
Perhaps above all, there seemed to be real disgust towards the perceived elitism and detachment of the event, towards Paris's "gauche caviar" (champagne socialists). It felt like a tidal wave of so-called "anti-woke" hatred. And all of this on the battleground of culture.
I was just fascinated, and dismayed, to see to what extent culture in France had become a crucible for an identitarian struggle, for a class-based swell of racially motivated anger. Looking through these tweets you could tell that the country is currently gripped by a disease.
Perhaps the difference is that cinema doesn't cut through here the way it does in France, but on BAFTA coverage you wouldn't get anything like that sort of vitriol. Maybe the equivalent here is TV - people fucked off at adverts featuring POC instead of "normal" families.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Sorry to come back to this, but the issue is not so much whether the individual writer's copy was sexist, but about the conduct of Variety, the publication who employ him. I really think fellow journalists should show solidarity and focus on that.
I don't think it's good enough to say that the writer's wording was ambiguous, and that whether he intended to be sexist or not, he gave the appearance of it. His editors assigned him to review the film, received his copy, and ran it as is. Then they made a show of disowning him.
What we need is to advance solutions, not use heavy language to snipe. I would expect journalists to put forward some ideas, rather than snipe at a colleague. Here's one: Variety could have assigned Amy Nicholson or Jessica Kiang to review the film instead.