1/10
It is absolutely necessary as citizens we never tire of highlighting the policy flaws. We made the emphatic point many times, that ZWL is being created to buy US at the fixed auction.

Belatedly, RBZ seems to have taken notice of this. The apparent speculation & arbitrage.
2/10
Money supply of ZWL has been increasing at 315% by Nov 2020. Most of this ZWL finds its way to the fixed Auction rate. Giving importers a 40% discount.

ZWL “productive loans” are less than 40% p.a when inflation is at 322%.

This creates the perfect arbitrage.
3/10
The arbitrage is not only with importers. The speculation goes further in the market. Eg a firm/individual can buy steel/gas/ non perishables priced at 83 & simply hold the stock. When shortages arise, or when the inevitable devaluation occurs they’ll offload at a profit.
4/10
Money is fungible. Meaning $$$ osmosis is inevitable. Money moves from high areas of concentration to low.

Some market players may not be consciously aware of their actions, but many understand that it’s better to keep stock funded by borrowed ZWL. It makes economic sense.
5/10
The RBZ moral voice is in its policy instruments. But if the central bank naively believes inflation will be 10% at the end of the year. They fuel the credit creation bubble as banks try to lock in “high”interest rates. At least that’s what banks will argue
6/10
RBZ & GOZ by printing excess money & credit creation has led to lots of ZWL in the market. It’s so much, that most will queue at the FX auction or go to the stock market. Both markets are way overvalued at the moment arising from excess money in the economy
7/10
Any demand in the economy is mostly speculative, anticipating shortages or inevitable depreciation.

This is unsustainable. Soon enough RBZ will be forced to raise interest rates & devalue Fx rate. Without offshore loans, this is inevitable. GOZ is scared of shortages.
8/10
Importers are locking in ridiculous margins at the expense of exporters. Funded by borrowed ZWL. Banks are becoming more creative in fleecing the exporter dollars. Eg using uSD cash cover to create more ZWL. Everyone else is speculating on the ZSE.
9/10
The whole market is removed from production.

This is GOZ own making, urged on by the very people taking advantage of the cheap ZWL dollars & fixed FX. There is a serious moral hazard.

Why believe a guy getting FX at 83 when they congratulate GOZ for a job well done?
10/10
There are serious international headwinds. Eg high oil prices, USD strengthening, lower remittances in 2021 & No new loans for Zim.

Before the situation gets out of hand, it’s time the country resolved its structural problems for the sake of the future generation.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Tinashe M

Tinashe M Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @baba_nyenyedzi

16 Mar
There is a fundamental difference between a stimulus package & government guarantee.

Perhaps let’s start with Biden’s $1.9trillion package. Perhaps far from Zim, cooler heads can prevail. Whence it becomes obvious what GOZ has done.
The $1.9tn Biden stimulus works this way;
(1) Treasury spends more than its revenue through issuance of a bond. This over expenditure is why it must go through both houses of the legislature.

This means treasury is running a deficit.
(2)Treasury issues the bonds in the marketplace, but investors are weary of future high inflation & thus hesitant to subscribe. Besides there is not enough money in the world to allocate to new issuances.

So the FED literally prints money to buy the Bonds. Treasury owes the FED
Read 15 tweets
22 Feb
1/

Political Economy of Zimbabwe

The President Mnangagwa, has announced GOZ new policy to repossess unused land, big farms, multiple owned farms & state land. This land will be redistributed to the youth.

The new policy is Political & NOT economics. See the attached thread.
2/
With a restive, unemployed, unskilled youth, albeit the largest voting block, Zanu PF has decided to placate the youth with Land.

As a political party, this is well within its rights. But this is dangerous for the Economy & will destroy what little activity is in Agriculture
3/
Agriculture in Zim requires security of tenure. It requires title deeds & private property status.

Private property is not necessarily needed for banking finance. But for innovation to take place. Land is just a factor of production no one has the right to dictate its usage
Read 7 tweets
15 Feb
1/

Zimbabwe - Afreximbank loans

On the 12th of Feb 2021, compelled by a court order, the MOF gazetted loans taken by RBZ it guaranteed.

It is very clear why RBZ & GOZ were secretive about these loans to the point of making its apologists deny the very existence of them.
2/
For example, over the last 3yrs it has been pointed out that;

(a) RBZ is involved in quasi fiscal activities
(b) GOZ treasury has no surplus

These two points are linked. RBZ comes directly under the Minister’s armpit. RBZ took over treasury responsibilities & its deficits.
3/
RBZ losses, are directly treasury’s losses & by law must be included in the consolidated revenues & expenditures. This never happened, so the right hand claimed it was clean, when all the time the stolen goods were in the left hand.
Read 21 tweets
6 Feb
1/
Not many countries in the world have a budget surplus. Not even fake surpluses. Well run countries found themselves in manageable deficits - without need to print. Borrowing directly from the market place.

Luxembourg is such an example- in normal years it runs a surplus.
2/
Mthuli made a mistake touting a surplus when it really wasn’t necessary to propagandize. The economy was already in a depression with the 2nd highest inflation in the world. GOZ domestic debt was being inflated away. Offering pensioners 8% interest when inflation was over 500%
3/
Perhaps his colleagues didn’t understand. They were happy to be told GOZ domestic debt was falling fast. Remember this was at a time the official ZWL inflation was banned.

The false euphoria resulted in 2 mistakes;
(I) Pension industry crushed to only $1bn.
Read 6 tweets
4 Feb
1/

I am of the strong view that the private sector should lead the vaccination program.

The insurance & pension industry must lead the private sector initiative. The NGO’s & aid agencies must support the private sector initiative- for free inoculation of the most vulnerable.
2/

Relying on a clueless GOZ will not solve the problem. But will perpetuate the endless lockdowns. Zim is already a laggard in the purchase of a vaccine. Israel made the order in April 2020. As of now, no order has been made by GOZ. Zero proof has been given
3/
Zimbabweans don’t realize how bankrupt the state is. And if the state was honest then the public would have been more sympathetic to Mthuli. Mthuli sees an opportunity to further fund raise. AIDS, rural electrification, Zinara levies go to central treasury & not intended uses
Read 7 tweets
1 Feb
The diamond/water paradox goes as such. Diamonds are of no use to human beings yet valuable because they’re scarce. A carat is 1/5th of a gram & can fetch up to $20k. While water which is life saving, which humans cannot do without is free to $1 per 0.5l. Because it’s not scarce
Therefore value is determined by scarcity. A painting can fetch up to $400m, yet no matter how much a farmer produce can save starving kids, maize will fetch $200 per ha.

This explains why an Actuary is better paid than a Doctor. An entrepreneur better rewarded than a manager.
As an anecdote, Aristotle failed to solve this problem. So many are in good company. Yet Hesiod a contemporary of Homer figured it out by just observing the price of produce during the seasons. He identified the scarcity problem.
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!