It is a rather old story.
Few generations back, our affluent ancestral home was attacked by unknown immigrants.
They robbed our home, set fire to the barn, looted what they could, tried to misbehave with the womenfolk and ran away into the night.
1/n
My ancestors fortified their home, made better provisions for security, kept 24 hour guards. A few years later, again one night an attack happened. This time the guards were killed, the cattle stolen, large part of the house burnt down. My ancestors survived but barely so.
2/n
The village came to offer succour, even some financial help to rebuild. But there was no finding the attackers. They just vanished into the dark.
Life gradually began to come to a normal. Hardwork and effort brought the household back to normalcy.
3/n
In the meantime, some new immigrants settled into the village. They had a haughty demeanour, eyed the womenfolk, took umbrage at every issue and were generally aggressive to the older inhabitants. They would often have fights with other villagers.
4/n
Once they stole a calf and were caught. They made a fight of it and refused to give it back. A huge altercation followed with the entire village collected at the choupal. My uncle spotted one fellow who reminded him of the first attack at our home, but he was not sure enough 5/n
to accuse him. The village elders decided to keep the newcomers at an arms length. The older immigrants gave them a wide berth. A gradual social distancing followed. This made the newcomers more aggressive.
They would wait for opportunities to get into a scrap.
6/n
Their men folk were constantly looking for a fight. Women would not venture into area were they lived. Our village was torn down the middle.
Then one day, a youngster from the newbie group entered our home.
We caught him in our aangan, where he had no business to be.
7/n
What resulted was natural. He was thrashed soundly.
Thats when Print, The Wire & Shekhar Coupta jumped in, defended his right to enter our home.
We were accused of killing seculaism, whatever the hell it is!
Our village is called #Dasna. And we thumb our nose at the media.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Since the time of these agri reforms, it has become convenient to blame Adhatia/middlemen/commission agents for every ill of farming.
NOTHING CAN BE FURTHER FROM TRUTH.
Middlemen exist because they serve a purpose. It deep rural communities, they are a single point source of 1/n
loans and advances, guidance and help. Yes, there are people who may exploit, but that doesn't make the entire system malafide. Where does a poor farmer get advance in emergency? The adhatia who knows him, his farm, his crop and his credit reliability.
2/n
The adhatias also are the farm produce aggregators, much like Amazon/Bookings etc. Large buyers place their order with adhatias. They are ones who buy from small farmers, sort pack and make it acceptable quantity for the buyer. How would you imagine a 2.5 acre farmer trying 3/n
If all subsidies and govt support to farmers is removed, agriculture in India will crash in less than one crop season.
It is an artificially sustained system to help 80% people to sustain their work.
Can any country whose 80% people survive on artificial income progress?
We have the lowest land holding per family than most agri nations and it is dwindling with every generation. We have poor yields and mechanisation. Poor crop diversity. Non existent demand intelligence, meagre cold chains.
And agriculture in India is not yet deemed an industry.
But this artificially sustained sytem accounts for 80% votes in most elections, so no govt wishes to touch it.
Time to take stock and dismantle an artificial, rotten system. Agriculture needs to completely reboot.
But it wont because of political considerations.
Let me share this interesting story I heard last night. Tucked around a bonfire on a hill top forest guest house, our Forest Personnel host shared this little episode. The backwaters that you see here, dry up at a lot of places to no more than 3-5 feet depth. 1/n
Most shoreline is Tribal villages where no change can happen. Folks are poor and rear cattle. Across the waters is the Satpura National Park with a healthy tiger population. Even yesterday, there was news of 2 ox attacked by tiger. So here is how the story goes. 2/n
In summers, some cattle cross over and get into the reserves of the tiger. Now the poor owner cant afford to lose his cattle.
There is this young tribal boy, who is an expert of finding lost cattle. His skill is informally acknowledged by the Forest Dept too. The cattle owner
3/n
A legend that walked the earth passes away.
Not sure how many of you had the opportunity of interacting with the man behind the maestro.
35 yrs back I had a brief but indelible exchange with him.
It was mid 80s. A music appreciation group had invited Panditji to Bhopal. 1/n
It was a small gathering of people who profess to appreciate classical music at Bhopal’s Ravindra Natya Grih. Half actually did, the other half thought it fashionable to attend the concert.
A friend from the organisers persuaded me to design an exhibition on Panditji’s life.
2/n
With zero wherewithal and no budget I set about doing it and could make it reasonably presentable.
When Panditji reached the venue, he was pleasantly surprised.
I was introduced to him and he was full of praises.
I took it as a generous elder encouraging a young man.
3/n
More thoughts on China:
In last 30 years, China has pumped enormous money in buying, cultivating and using media support. It worked from 90s to 2015s.
Then, to their utter surprise, the world changed. Social Media democratised opinions and information.
1/n
The assets suddenly became ineffective. They could not control a democratised SM.
So in the last few years they have been hiring an army of bots.
The trouble with bots is they cannot engage. They cannot argue. They can only cut paste pre determined views and amplify them
2/n
If you notice today, their completely rattled state mouth pieces are belting out laughably preachy sermons.
This is their natural weakness in the information age.
No understanding of SM, local language/english barriers.
What China fears most and betrays its weakness..
3/n