Some thoughts on how to think about the rebound. What was hoped would be a sprint has become a marathon of a pandemic with hurdles along the way. We have just crossed our proverbial hardest mile. Fatigue set in this winter.
Vaccinations and a lot of fiscal stimulus has given us a much needed shot of adrenaline. We replaced incomes while waiting for jobs to come back, and then some. The euphoria is already unleashing pent-up demand for travel, indoor dining, spas, gyms, etc.
Domestic air travel hit its highest level in over year in recent weeks. Popular domestic spots will see a surge as travel to other countries will remain suppressed. This will shift some spending away from goods to services.
This is where it gets tricky. The virus mutates - all viruses do. Some mutations are benign, some are not. Why do we care? Because the course of the virus still determines the course of the economy. We don’t want to allow more contagious and more lethal variants to take hold.
That would create new hurdles and threaten to set us back, again. It’s time to start learning from our mistakes. The goal is to open, stay open & let the economy rip. Sadly, the pandemic is global but vaccinations are not. A mutation anywhere is a mutation everywhere.
We also need to get further along our own path of vaccinations - it is now within reach - before allowing another outbreak that could make for worse mutations. That requires a few more precautions - masks, encouraging more widespread vaccinations.
Too many are still resistant to taking vaccine to get to level needed for herd immunity. We will also need to leverage testing, tracing and therapeutics to wrestle the virus to its knees and manage outbreaks. The vaccines also show some promise in helping with long haul COVID.
Cases of new variants are already rising in a dozen states. We want to embrace our progress and each other, not squander it. Growth could *easily* hit its fastest pace since 1984 in 2021 after worst year since 1946.
Prices will flare as that demand is unleashed. The algorithms that set prices for travel and tourism are designed to push prices up as demand spikes. It is also easier to close than reopen, as we have already seen in manufacturing and construction. Bottlenecks are inevitable.
The Fed has decided it will allow a flare in prices rather than get in the way of an economy that still needs to restore jobs. They see that inflation as transitory. We are in unchartered waters & the Fed could be wrong but the risk is worth taking given where we are.
The Fed has the tools to fight inflation. Their view for the moment is “make my day.” A hot economy is much better than a stone cold economy, and can much more easily cooled than we saw in the 1980s. That period represented years of unchecked inflation & bad policies.
Workers also had a lot more bargaining power in previous inflation episodes with wages boosted well before we hit anything close to full employment. The pendulum has swung to the other extreme, one of many reasons to roll the dice on allowing the economy to boom, safely.
Also. Bond market could get ahead of the Fed. This would derail steam in housing and goods purchases and alleviate the upward pressure on prices there. We just don’t want the bond market to get too far ahead of the economy.
For the bond market, the current environment is a paradigm shift. They don’t trust that a flare in inflation will be transitory - we haven’t had one - and they do not benefit like workers do from the Fed’s decision to overshoot, even if it is a modest overshoot.
We have lost at least 1-1/2 yrs of the economy to the pandemic - let’s not lose more. We now have the means to learn from mistakes & convert a catastrophe into a catalyst to more inclusive, robust & sustained growth. That is worth reaching for.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Diane Swonk

Diane Swonk Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @DianeSwonk

21 Mar
Some thoughts on inflation. Bond market participants rode a multi-decade deceleration in inflation. That came at a cost over last two decades as wages decelerated as well. Some of gap between men and women was closed bc male-dominated (mfg & construction) jobs fell.
The Fed has shifted its stance on inflation. It has said 1) It would “look through” - not raise rate later - a transitory flare in inflation. This will come in 2 ways - inflation measures get easier to beat, starting in Mar, as prices decelerated/dropped as crisis hit yr ago.
The Fed shouldn’t be curbing the recovery to contain inflation that is a result of a technicality triggered by the crisis. It should abate. However, just as those “base effects” as they are called play out as we move into summer, we could see flare in prices tied to reopening.
Read 11 tweets
20 Mar
These kind of slights compound. They cause too many and, devastatingly, some economists to conclude women are either not good enough to do what they do and draw the crowds to games. When, in reality, they are being held to a higher standard with fewer resources to achieve.
The result is an economy that is grossly inefficient and growing much less than it could if all its potential were unleashed. Leveling the playing field, in this case, would ⬆️ the competitiveness of the game, enhance earning power and boost the economy.
Leveling the playing field would also create more role models for girls that they can succeed in different ways. In that way, leveling the playing field pays it forward. There’s a reason that the first thing developing economies do to develop is to ⬆️ opportunities for women.
Read 5 tweets
10 Mar
One reality that gets lost in translation when discussing emergency aid and stimulus plans is how important they have been in keeping the US from a double-dip recession as we have seen abroad.
The rebound in growth last spring was triggered in large part because of the funding triggered by the CAREs Act. It was much more robust than elsewhere but then the momentum on jobs petered out over the summer and into the fall, as another wave hit the Sunbelt.
People moved indoors without masks in scorching heat, which bolstered transmission of an airborne virus. This overwhelmed hospitals and triggered fear & restrictions that slowed pace of job growth. The cushion provided by the CAREs Act for the millions unemployed ran out.
Read 16 tweets
11 Dec 20
Where are we?

The the resurgence in COVID cases, hospitalizations and deaths is overwhelming our health care system.

Employment slowed to a crawl in Nov as temps dropped and restaurants and bars cut back or closed for good. Traditional retailers cut back or closed for good...
State and local governments shed jobs, mostly in education for the fourth month in a row.

Cases and hospitalization predictably picked up *again* as social distancing was discarded and community spread of COVID during the Thanksgiving holiday.
The percent of the labor force working from home in November edged higher. They spent online and created a false sense of security about how well the economy is holding up and the prospects for a rebound once we are all vaccinated.
Read 20 tweets
18 Nov 20
I was working on a long thread of all the work I have done on the risk we are going into a double dip recession - we are - and the scars left by COVID. I realized no one reads it. So here is the short version. Spoiler - it still long.
Low-wage workers hit harder than high-wage workers but don’t get too comfortable in your work-from-home bubble as that could change if this recession metastasizes into a more traditional recession w say a lot of zombie firms and a moribund commercial real estate mkt.
Black, Hispanic, Native American and Asian workers hit harder than white workers.

Women hit harder than men.

Millennials hit hardest of age groups w job losses. They were already trailing other generations w blow to lifetime earnings due to 08-09 recession.
Read 15 tweets
17 Nov 20
Retail sales rose only 0.3% in Oct after downward revisions in Sep. That marks slowest pace since height of job losses in April. Vehicles rose slightly, despite a drop in unit sales. The pandemic has triggered demand for more expensive luxury, SUVs and pickup trucks.
City dwellers are looking for safer modes of transportation, while higher wage households needed larger vehicles to tow boats and RVs. Home bullders also need pick up trucks to transport building materials.
Only big positives in categories were online, electronics and building materials. Apple product introductions are a major mover for electronic sales. Gains at big box discounters couldn’t offset a drop at traditional department stores. Much of those sales were online.
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!