Koshiek Karan Profile picture
Apr 7, 2021 19 tweets 7 min read Read on X
Derivatives, Black-Scholes & complex financial instruments explained [Thread]
A derivative is any contract that “derives” value from an underlying asset. So if you buy a contract that pays you out every time Arsenal wins, you have a derivative.

You will also be poor & depressed.
You’re a football manager looking to sign 19yo wonderkid striker Jose from OnlyFans FC. Nobody really knows how much Jose is worth.

You figure Jose is worth at least €60m if he can bang in 25 goals this season. But a bigger club might buy him by then.

Enter derivatives...
You approach OnlyFans FC & negotiate for the option to buy Jose at the end of the season for €40m, no matter what happens

OnlyFans FC think Jose will be worth €45m by then. They ask you to pay €5m for this option to buy him for €40m

Option premium: €5m
Strike price: €40m
Scenario 1

Jose bangs in 25 goals over the season and is worth €60m. You exercise your option to buy him for just €40m. But you also paid €5m for this option.

60-40-5= 15
You made €15m on this deal.

At the end of the season, your exercised the option "in the money (ITM)"
Scenario 2

Jose spends all season popping bottles in Mayfair and starts doing coke. He scores three goals that season. He’s worth €10m.

You decide not to exercise your option to buy Jose for €40m and lose your €5m. OnlyFans FC gain €5m

Your option is "out the money (OTM)
Scenario 3

Jose scores 14 goals including a hat-trick against Liverpool when Trent played RB, so it doesn't really count.

He ends up being worth €45m. At this point, the option was fairly priced. You & OnlyFans FC don't make or lose anything from this arrangement.
The option to buy Jose at a pre-specified price in the future is a call option.

OnlyFans can also protect themselves from the downside of Jose's coke habit by negotiating an option to sell him for €45m (put option)

If he ends up worth more than €45m, they don't sell him
Black-Scholes is a differential equation solving option prices. Pretty big deal in finance & economics, these dudes won a Nobel Prize for their work. Still, the original equation had many limitations.

In an investment bank nobody works this stuff out manually... ever
Intrinsic value is basically the difference between underlying asset value and the option strike price

Jose is worth €55m half-way through the season, you have the option to buy him for €40m, the intrinsic value of your option is €15m

...but there's still half a season to go
Time decays the value of options

With fewer games left in the season - the fewer goals Jose will realistically score. More games = more opportunities for goals = higher value for Jose.

Time isn't a linear function, decay speeds up faster in the second half of the option life
Volatility impacts the time value of options

If Jose has 40 games ahead of him & either scores 5 goals or no goals (volatile performance), the time value component of the option to buy Jose will be higher

If there's just 2 games left, volatility will have much less of an impact
If you're thinking options are a pretty neat way to gain massive exposure without putting down too much capital - you're right BUT with the wrong strategy... your losses have no floor. It's a bad, bad place to be on the wrong side of an options trade.
Derivatives start becoming dangerous when you stack them. What if you invest in options that are based on the value of your options based on Jose's goals? A derivative of a derivative

Sounds like inception? It really is

Here's Margot Robbie explaining mortgage backed securities
Many of the early derivatives products were designed to de-risk & hedge out exposure... the irony is it has ended up incentivizing taking on more risk and speculation.

There's a ton of Greek letters behind options strategies, short story - it's easy to get tangled up in them
What happens when you have excess liquidity, "stonks always go up" & this frenzied volume of call option buying (especially deep out the money options)?

It ends badly.

This is like betting Jose will score 120 goals a season instead of 25. Worse, it creates massive volatility.
Before rolling the dice on Jose banging in goals this season & buying up naked call options, remember he may not even be 19yo

That's the market we're in - Fed stimmy pumping liquidity & inflating valuations make everything look attractive

Shout-out for making it to the end!
If you're into sexy bedtime reading there's a paper I wrote with @Kanshuk a few years ago on pricing & designing a commodity based volatility security using Geometric Brownian Motion. Unlocked countless IB roles before I graduated.

Now I don't use fancy math, I just buy the dip

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Koshiek Karan

Koshiek Karan Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @iamkoshiek

Jul 6
South Africa ranks among the highest levels of income inequality globally

“middle income” is a highly flattering & deceptive term

it gives a false sense of comfort & security 🍾🥂

being a few missed salaries away from poverty isn’t “middle class”, it’s “premium poor”
the “middle income” bracket in South Africa is closer to being homeless than becoming high net worth

living standards are extremely fragile

one retrenchment, uninsured accident or unexpected financial emergency changes life completely
you see companies report on the “shrinking middle class”

more people are likely to downscale than upgrade their living standards

lower enrolments in private schools, downgrading medical aid plans, moving into affordable suburbs, a shift towards cheaper vehicles
Read 11 tweets
Jul 2
Breaking Benz! ㉦㉦

popping the hood on the global struggles of Mercedes-Benz [thread]
🚨Mercedez-Benz suspends operations in SA

the tragedy of paywalled media is headlines go viral & nobody actually reads the content

1. this is a planned shutdown & all workers are still paid

2. Mercedez-Benz exports 90% of its cars made in SA

3. tariff impact is VERY minimal Image
SA/ US trade relations are in the media crosshairs

naturally the media finds ways to scapegoat South Africa for Mercedes-Benz challenges

this time, they used the wrong argument (tariffs)

Mercedes had a closed investor call yesterday & dismissed tariffs as a major issue Image
Read 22 tweets
Apr 23
South African household income stats 🇿🇦📊

median monthly income = R7, 891
average monthly income = R17,030

- White: R56,365
- Indian: R34,786
- Coloured: R21,735
- Black African: R11,969

Source: Stats SA, IES 2022/ 2023
monthly household income by education level 🇿🇦

tertiary education: R48,188
secondary education: R12,480
no schooling: R7,015

for households headed by those with tertiary education
- income is 7x higher vs no schooling
- income is 4x higher vs secondary education
South Africa is a majority low income country with widespread unemployment & high levels of inequality

if you could access the debt profiles, credit scores & payslips of people on twitter -- you would likely see more honest takes on money

the truth is in the data
Read 8 tweets
Apr 20
do you ever feel the news you consume is overwhelmingly negative?! 💔💔

you’re completely right — it really is

I ran a deep, content sentiment analysis for every article, social media post & headline published across media houses

in short: SA media LOVES bad news 📰 Image
the biggest culprits of publishing paralysing fear & doomsday prophecies:

Daily Maverick, Daily Investor, BusinessTech & eNCA

but there’s a strong chance you already knew that based on their relentless, negative headlines
quick note on how this sentiment tracker works

each content piece (article body, headlines, summaries, social media post) is classified using natural language processing

then you aggregate to compute an overall sentiment score (e.g. -0.40 means 40% more negative than positive)
Read 13 tweets
Apr 17
South African stocks are crushing record highs & gold is at all time highs 🇿🇦🔥

SA is now ranked among the best performing markets globally this year 🏆

the rand (relative to the US dollar) remains unchanged this year 📈📈 Image
wait — why is there such limited local media coverage for positive news?!

SA media LOVES reporting currency weakness, stock market crashes & negative news on South Africa

fear, outrage & clickbait drives clicks & engagement — opportunity doesn’t sell
my favourite strategy of financial media is using two completely independent events to force a useless correlation

“SA politician seen buying 3 chocolate Easter bunnies — rand collapses as investors flee!!”

this works GREAT in countries with low levels of financial literacy
Read 9 tweets
Mar 26
MTN just ended their eight year front of shirt sponsorship with the Springboks 🏉🏉

here's an inside look at the big business behind the most iconic jersey in world rugby [thread] Image
what isn't being widely reported (yet) is how the ongoing Springboks private equity ownership discussion has impacted anchor sponsor relationships

the recent failed takeover bid from Ackerley Sports Group (ASG) has sparked friction & uncertainty at executive level Image
SARU stood to pocket a 15% success fee for brokering a successful equity deal

except this was a terrible deal for South African rugby

I covered the deal mechanics in extensive detail here (worth a read)
Read 14 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(