Among other things, this law would require a high school teacher to notify the parents of any 18-year-old student (or 20-year-old school employee) who used they/them pronouns.
(I don’t THINK it applies to college professors, based on the wording of the Bill, but I’m not certain.)
I say I don't think the bill applies to profs because the duty to report is one of "government agents," which is defined in such a way as to exclude professors.
But in another section the bill says any state "entity" with knowledge that anyone under 21 "under its...supervision" is gender nonconforming must notify that person's parents. So that seems like it could apply to colleges.
And again: The NC bill requires BOTH parents of anyone under 21 to be informed, in writing, if certain individuals become aware that the person is gender nonconforming or "demonstrates a desire to be treated in a manner incongruent with the minor's sex."
The bill also prohibits any state employee from "encourag[ing]" anyone under 21 "to withhold information from [their] parent." Even if the "minor" is a legal adult.
And all of this stuff applies whether or not the gender nonconforming person in question has any interest in medical transition or not. It's not just about transition—it's literally about pronouns and self-presentation, too.
And if a teacher overhears a student using they/them pronouns, and the teacher doesn't immediately narc the student out (to, again, both parents, separately, in writing), the teacher can be not only fired, but sued. By the parents. In the student's name.
And the student wouldn't even need to be trans or nonbinary. Lesbian student wears a tuxedo to a school dance? That's gender nonconformity. Any teacher who witnesses it has an obligation to inform the student's parents. In writing.
And if the teacher decides it's not gender nonconformity, guess what? The parents can sue the teacher. For damages, court costs, and "any other appropriate relief."
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
This is important. Berenson often presents himself as a gadfly from within, drawing attention to studies and data that the media are downplaying because they don't fit the accepted narrative. But he's not that.
Every time Berenson says "Here's an important study you're not hearing about!", he's wrapping himself in the cloak of the people who wrote the study, using their expertise to give him weight.
Heading back down to Javits for the second shot today. Will livetweet again, though I expect it to be a much shorter and more boring story—from everything I've read, the lines pretty much evaporated about two weeks ago.
"They loved each other and believed they loved mankind, they fought each other and believed they fought the world."
—John le Carré, 1961, on British communists at Oxford in the 1930s.
BTW, I don't read this as a condemnatory quote. I recognize in it movements that I've been a part of, and movements that I have written about with love.
I initially followed the quote up with a "possible relevance to present-day internet subcultures is left for the reader to assess" tweet, but that wasn't (I promise!) intended as a specific subtweet of any particular group.
A lot of people I respect are wondering whether the Alexi McCammond incident means nobody can be forgiven for anything anymore. But it does strike me as a very particular situation. nytimes.com/2021/03/18/bus…
McCammond is 27, which means incidents from when she was a teenager are less than a decade old. And Teen Vogue is ... well, Teen Vogue, a lefty-multiculti magazine targeted at folks the age McCammond was when she sent the tweets.
Plus McCammond was a Wintour hire, which means any whiff of bigotry in her past was always going to take on outsized symbolic significance. theguardian.com/fashion/2020/j…
A college is a community that is made up of smaller communities. Some events are for everybody, some events aren't. That's totally benign—and inevitable!
If you think it's fine that a college has a Black Student Union and an LGBTQ student organization, why would you think it was bad for there to be get-togethers associated with those communities to commemorate community members' graduation?
People are mad about Eddie Izzard saying she's been "promoted to she" on the cover of The Guardian, but the actual quote is a bit different than that, and much more interesting.
What she says in the piece is that she'd initially intended to go back and forth between using he/him and she/her pronouns, but that once she said her pronouns were "she/her" one time, that stuck—it was out of her hands.
So the interviewer asked how she felt about losing that flexibility, and she responded: "Great. I’ve been promoted to she, and it’s a great honour."