A 'Harvard study' says that "Yogi's UP" was "heaven on earth" for migrants.

Over d last few days, we have been seeing such headlines all over Indian media.

But there's a catch: None of these reports mentions the authors' names, the study's title, & where to find d actual study
Harvard Univ already has a lot of baggage, recently in terms of many graduates workin for d Trump admin.. I m sure they do not want to extend this baggage to hateful, divisive, violent regimes elsewher. The content of d news reports makes it clear that if such a Harvard study..
.. exists, it wasn't primarily done for academic reasons.

Or maybe it was, in which case it would be really great if @Harvard or @HarvardChanSPH make sure that the study is made publicly available so that other experts can assess how valid its observations & conclusions are.
It is also imp to point out that all the news reports, esp @htTweets (who shud know better), skip any identifying info regarding this mysterious study. Hope at least the journalists got a copy of it.. Or were they simply taking the "heavenly" UP admin's words to be the truth?
All of this is assuming such a study exists. Which I believ cud be the case, considerin the number of NRIs & desi Ivy Leaguers who have been cheerleaders of both Trumpian politics in the US and Sanghi politics in India.

But in case no such study exists, all apologies to Harvard.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Kiran Kumbhar

Kiran Kumbhar Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @kikumbhar

2 Apr
A while back I saw a v good article on healthcare in India mention that Ayurveda goes back to "more than 5000 years." Like so many origin stories around the world, those of Ayurveda have also acquired many mythical elements (like the above) over the centuries. Hence this PSA...
When it comes to Indian history, we tragically lack what's called "critical thinking skills" (or in common parlance, "logic and common sense"). In the late 1800s and early 1900s, Sanskritist Ramakrishna Bhandarkar urged us to work on such mental skills: thewire.in/history/grand-…
Keeping that in mind, let me intro u to an awesome 2005 article by historian Projit Mukharji. He explains well why claims over ancientness became more imp than any other characteristics (like therapeutic efficacy) for Ayurvedic publicists in the 1800s.
academia.edu/761638/Bengali…
Read 21 tweets
31 Mar
Some intriguing headlines regarding d President of the Indian Medical Association (IMA) appeard on Indian RW media yday. As usual OpIndia's took the (cowdung)cake: "IMA President wants to use hospitals to convert Hindus." For someone interestd in IMA's history, this was imp stuff
I read the "incriminating" interviews of Dr Jayalal. And also d OpIndia etc content thru cached pages (in the hope that my clicks don't boost the views of what is the most hate-filled media platform in our country). Unsurprisingly, it was d usual Hindutva paranoia on display..
Here are those interviews of Dr Jayalal. These interviews paint a picture of a publicly religious biomedical doctor, which is not uncommon (tho something I personally dont appreciate)

haggai-international.org/in-the-name-of…

christianitytoday.com/ct/2021/march-…
Read 9 tweets
2 Feb
'Free' vaccination

Some ppl, for good reasons, believe that vaccines should not be made available free for all but only for the 'poor'. It's very noble when ppl volunteer to pay for services. If u wanna pay for vaccines, go ahead!

But still, let vaccination be 'free' for all...
Privileged ppl who wish to pay have multiple ways to contribute even if vaccines are free at the point of service. One cud, eg, go to a govt hospital or an NGO and donate there. Besides, EVERY person in India pays taxes, direct &/or indirect, thus also 'paying' for their vaccines
We need to get rid of d flawed notion that when govts make a service free, they are doing us a favor, or that they are encouraging free-loading. (It is in fact ministers, MPs, MLAs, with som exceptions, who perhaps do the most free-loading in India, but that's a diff discussion.)
Read 15 tweets
12 Oct 20
Caste and medical education in India:

While being exceptionally lenient towards the individuals who Dr Payal Tadvi specifically said had unbearably harassed her, the SC noted "Even a convict is allowed to... develop his [their word] potential as a human being to the fullest."
As many folks hav pointed out, how come courts don't apply this principle to so many other, certainly more deserving, frequently falsely accused, undertrials?

The amount of ongoing institutional injustice in Dr Tadvi's case is stupendous, & has shaken many of us to the core.
My research on d history of medicine in post-independence India has given me som leads on d early intersections of caste & healthcare. In the current context, d most relevant stuff I want activists to know about is a debate on caste that raged in d pages of NMJI in 1992-94
Read 11 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!