Stephen Fisher Profile picture
Apr 9, 2021 50 tweets 18 min read Read on X
RIP His Royal Highness Prince Philip.

Prince Philip's war service is usually summarised as getting a Mention in Despatches at the Battle of Cape Matapan and saving HMS Wallace at Sicily. But I feel this overlooks so much more, and occasionally errors creep in, so here we go.
After completing officer training at Dartmouth, on 23 February 1940 the 18 year old midshipman joined HMS Ramillies at Colombo. He would spend most of 1940 with the venerable battleship and the cruisers Kent and Shropshire. 📷 IWM A8858
Early in 1941 he joined the battleship HMS Valiant in the Mediterranean. The Royal website confusingly claims that Philip joined HMS Valiant at the age of 17, which isn’t really possible. It appears he joined her in January 1941, at the age of 19. 📷IWM A12126
Probably thanks to a dodgy Wikipedia entry, he’s often said to have gone back to the UK in early 1941, taken a load of training courses, and then returned to Valiant as a lieutenant. This sort of thing didn’t happen – the courses were later (see further below).
Almost immediately on joining, he saw his first action when Valiant, part of a larger fleet, bombarded the town of Bardia in support of Operation Compass 📷State Library of Victoria H98.105/3251. It is Valiant, it's probably not Bardia!
He was on Valiant at the Battle of Matapan, when the RN and RAN engaged an Italian fleet south of Greece on 28 March 1941. The battle was an overwhelming Allied victory, with only light damage and 3 killed, for the sinking of 3 Italian cruisers and 2 destroyers. 📷AWM P00090.108
Philip’s role has been misdescribed recently, and sometimes exaggerated to commanding a 'battery' of searchlights and even being the person who ‘found’ the enemy fleet in the night action. Here is the Naval staff history, and Philip’s own words on his role.
His next posting was back to Britain, where he attended numerous courses at Portsmouth. In September he became an acting sub lieutenant and early in 1942 became a full sub-lieutenant shortly after he joined HMS Wallace on the East Coast.📷IWM FL10546
Philip would spend the next year on the East Coast, a largely forgotten battlefront, escorting convoys up and down the coast. This was his single longest campaign and bears a bit more detail. You can learn a lot from @NickHewitt4's excellent book on it. amazon.co.uk/Coastal-Convoy…
The convoys were vital to Britain’s war effort, carrying nearly 13 million tons of coal and 2 million tons of cargo each year. But they were vulnerable to S-boats operating from the Dutch and Belgian coasts. 📷Getty
On the night of 14/15 March, Philip met the Kriegsmarine for the first time during an attack by S-boats on convoy FN655. Wallace tangled with boats of the 4th Flotilla and with fellow escorts, saw them off. 📷No idea, sorry!
But that same night, the danger of their work was clearly highlighted by the loss of HMS Vortigern, sunk by S-boat S-104. There were only 14 survivors. 📷IWM Q75528
Wallace tangled with S-boats again on 14 December when 3 flotillas attacked convoy FN889. 2 flotillas attacked the escorts, with 2 torpedoes passing close by Wallace's bow – from different directions. With the escorts engaged, the 3rd flotilla sank 5 merchant ships. 📷AWM 128144
But the vast majority of convoys that Wallace escorted made it, thanks to the escorts (including destroyers, trawlers and motor launches) and the Coastal Forces operating in the North Sea. THIS was arguably Prince Philip's greatest contribution to the war. 📷Getty
In early 1943, Wallace was ordered to transfer to the Med. The ship escorted a June merchant convoy into the Atlantic and then a portion of it to Gibraltar. They deployed into the Med to escort the invasion convoys bound for Sicily in Operation Husky. 📷Naval History Net
The invasion began on 9/10 July, with Wallace providing AA support for the landings in the Bark West sector at the south east tip of the island. Here she came under air attack on the night of 10/11 July and again on 13/14 July. 📷National Museum of U.S. Navy
I believe the action in which Prince Philip saved Wallace was the first, when bombers dropped flares to try and illuminate targets. Prince Philip and skipper Commander Duncan Carson had a small flaming raft made to distract the bombers. A stick of bombs narrowly missed Wallace.
There were other, slightly embarrassing incidents though. On 12/13 July, Wallace engaged an enemy target. Fortunately only one person was injured before the mistake was realised - they had accidentally engaged an Allied Landing Craft Infantry (Large). 📷Library & Archives Canada
In August 43 Wallace returned to the UK to resume East Coast convoy duties. By now Prince Philip was a full lieutenant (Dec 42) & had been 1st lt on Wallace since Oct 42 (at 21). He's often said to be one of the youngest 1st lieutenants in service, but I don't find this credible.
In early 1944 he was transferred to HMS Whelp, a new destroyer still completing at Hawthorn Leslie on the Tyne. Here he stood by the vessel during its final construction and took up post as first lieutenant when it commissioned in April. 📷IWM FL2728
I have wondered if he might have lodged with other crews standing by their vessels at the yard at the same time. If so, it was with Sub Lt Baggott, standing by #LCT7074. He must have seen the LCT which was at the yard at exactly the same time. I wonder what he made of her.
The 27th Destroyer Flotilla, of which Whelp was a part, was not part of the Royal Navy's order of battle for Neptune. Instead she went to Spitsbergen, helping to replenish the small garrison there. 📷Bjørn Christian Tørrissen
Her next destination was the Med to support Operation Dragoon. She left Portsmouth on 2 August, escorting HMS Ramillies, Prince Philip's first seagoing posting. In the event, she was selected to proceed to the Indian Ocean so wasn't involved with the landings in Southern France.
I think I'll take a break here and complete Prince Philip's service in the Far East tomorrow. Thank you for reading.
This has proven more popular than I anticipated so I'd better finish it off!

Like his earlier service, Prince Philip's time on Whelp is usually reduced to being present at the surrender in Tokyo Bay. This implies some sort of ceremonial function, which was far from the case.
Like the East Coast convoys, in the Far East Prince Philip joined a campaign that has been largely forgotten, so it bears some explanation. A good intro for those in the mood can be found in this book (I didn't think it was so expensive!). amazon.co.uk/Task-Force-57-…
Simply put, the British Eastern Fleet, mauled by the Japanese in 1942, was slowly rebuilt in the Bay of Bengal, with Trincomalee as the fleet base. Another book that I'm sure details this well is this one (I don't have it sadly). amazon.co.uk/British-Pacifi…
In late 1944 the fleet was significantly bolstered with more warships, landing craft and a considerable 'fleet train'. The latter was necessary to sustain the fleet at sea: the vast distances in the Pacific and Indian Oceans prohibited operating from ports in the usual manner.
Chief amongst the warships were 18 aircraft carriers, who would operate alongside the US Navy task forces in the Pacific. With them came escort destroyers, including HMS Whelp, who arrived with the 27th Flotilla in October 1944. 📷IWM MH5309
Prince Philip, 1st lieutenant to Commander Norfolk on Whelp, first encountered the Japanese on 17 October during Operation Millet, a bombardment and carrier strike on the Nicobar Islands (800 miles from Trincomalee), intended to divert Japanese attention from Leyte Gulf. 📷Google
The attacks provided useful experience for the fledgling fleet. Late in the operation, they came under attack from 12 torpedo bombers. Seven were shot down for the loss of 3 fighters, but it signalled that aircraft were the chief Japanese threat.
In November 44, the greater part of the Eastern Fleet was formed into the British Pacific Fleet. That month they began a series of missions under the overall operation 'Outflank'. These were primarily raids on oil facilities in Sumatra as the fleet prepared to move east. 📷Google
In Operation Robson in November, Whelp and Wager escorted the fleet's fuel tanker Wave King, whilst the main strike force sailed closer to the northern tip of Sumatra to attack Pangkalan Brandan. The raid was broadly successful, although there was next to no opposition.
In January, Operation Lentil saw Whelp with the main strike force. It was the Royal Navy's heaviest carrier strike to date with 88 aircraft attacking Pangkalan Brandan again, including Gruman Avenger bombers (seen forming up below), Corsairs, Hellcats and Fireflies. 📷IWM A27166
Whelp was detached from the strike force a little early though. To the north, HMS Shakespeare had engaged a Japanese warship on the surface near the Andaman Islands and sustained damage. Whelp took over from HMS Raider to tow her back to Trincomalee. 📷IWM FL6117
On 16 January, Whelp left Trincomalee as the BPF redeployed to Australia. On their way, they took the opportunity to raid more oil facilities on Sumatra in Operations Meridian 1 and 2. @ArmouredCarrier has done some good films on these, starting here.
They were the largest carrier raids of the Royal Navy's war, employing 105 aircraft in Meridian 1. Both raids were successful, with significant damage to the oil facilities. For much more detail, read @ArmouredCarrier's article here: armouredcarriers.com/operation-meri…
Whelp was part of the forward AA screen in Meridian 2, and as such was one of the first ships that the returning aircraft saw. For Sub Lieutenant Halliday and his 2 crew, Whelp was a genuine lifesaver when they sustained damage over the refineries.📷IWM A29242
Here's Halliday's own account of their return flight and rescue by Whelp (shamelessly borrowed from Task Force 57 by Peter Smith).
For a bit more on this, there's also a very good 1/2 hour radio programme covering the raid and rescue. It's well worth a listen. bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00…
In March the BPF sailed north from Australia into the Pacific, bound for Okinawa. Whelp missed the opening invasion owing to radar defects but she returned to the fleet a few days later and Prince Philip witnessed the kamikaze attacks on the combined fleets. 📷IWM A29717
The fleet retired to the Philippines in May and Whelp escorted HMS Illustrious, badly damaged by a kamikaze, to Sydney for repairs. Once at Australia, Whelp also remained until July for repairs.📷AWM
On completion, Whelp escorted HMS Duke of York to Guam. In August the Allied fleets sailed for Tokyo, with Whelp allegedly the first Allied ship to enter Sagami Bay, outside Tokyo Harbour. 📷Naval History and Heritage Command. DoY is 2nd ship from front. Mt Fuji in background.
Prince Philip was present at the Japanese surrender on 2 September but he was not on board USS Missouri & was not a dignitary. He watched from the deck of Whelp, as did all her crew and those from the well over 200 Allied vessels in attendance. 📷Naval History & Heritage Command.
HMS Whelp then sailed south to Hong Kong to administer the Japanese surrender there. He remained with the ship as she slowly made her way back to the UK, arriving on 17 January 1946. He asked King George for Elizabeth's hand in marriage that summer.📷Navy Photos/George Knight
It should be fairly obvious by now, but Prince Philip was not shielded from danger and only sent on soft postings. The only time he was kept away from action was in 1940 when, as a Greek subject, he was technically not at war (Italy solved this for him in late 1940).
He had dangerous assignments, where people in his place on the next ship in line were killed doing exactly the same job. They were unglamorous and underappreciated – especially his work on the East Coast convoys.
Nor was he given rapid promotion or undue honours on account of his status. He was a prince yes, but it only warranted him an unusual entry in the Navy Lists!
Similarly, I don't put much stock in the claim, repeated a lot yesterday & today, that he was the youngest 1st lieutenant in the Royal Navy. There were plenty of younger skippers. Even if you only count destroyer sized ships it wasn't unusual to have 21 year old 1st lieutenants.
Put simply, Prince Philip's wartime career was not unusual. He took the same path, sailed the same ships and seas, and faced the same dangers as many thousands of men his age. That's not to say he wasn't anything special. They were all special.

Rest in peace your Highness.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Stephen Fisher

Stephen Fisher Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @SeaSpitfires

Oct 19
Last night I gave a talk about the archaeology and historical research I conducted during the restoration of LCT 7074. It meant revisiting a lot of my earlier work and updating some of it 4 years later. And I’ve found something rather exciting! Image
There were only 3 known surviving LCT when 7074 was recovered. LCT 147 is a museum ship in Haifa, and LCT 203 is a working ship on Lake Superior. Both served in the Med during the war – neither of them was at Normandy. 📷Bukvoed, via Wikimedia Commons & Paul Swansen Image
Image
During the restoration of 7074 I became aware of another LCT on the Zegrze Reservoir near Warsaw. From the hull it was clearly a Mk 5 but did not appear to have any identification beyond that. It had been converted into a floating theatre but seemed unused now. 📷© Rohatyniec Image
Read 13 tweets
Jun 19
This is not an attempt to justify what happened at Stonehenge today, or even to change anyone’s mind about it. I’d simply like to add some context that I feel has been missing from some reports, statements and tweets. Image
3 stones have been impacted, from L to R in the above image they are numbers 23, 22 & 21. They are sarsen stones, a type of sandstone and whilst they are porous, the substance thrown at them was apparently cornflour. The stones are not in any danger, nor are any carvings on them.
The stones have also suffered far worse. 23 and 22 were both re-erected in the 1960s, 23 after it mysteriously fell over a few years after it was whacked by 22 when it was itself being hoisted up by a crane. The lintel above 22 and 21 was similarly replaced by a crane. Image
Read 6 tweets
Oct 10, 2023
I should be writing, so here's an impromptu #DDayfromAbove instead. I say impromptu – this one has been sat on my desktop for a while and I've tried, but failed, to complete the jigsaw. But sometimes you just don't have all the pieces. Anyway, to Gold Beach. 📷 NARA Image
So, where are we? Well, that stream, the Ruisseau du Marais, is the perfect clue to line up an aerial shot like this. Here's the same spot today. 📷Google Maps
Image
Image
And where is this on Gold Beach? It's right at the far east end of Jig Red Beach. Technically nothing was supposed to land here, but the bunker at WN37 (far right of the photo) created sufficient chaos on Jig Green to force the beachmasters to close the beach and divert to red. Image
Read 13 tweets
Feb 1, 2023
Did the Allies almost land on Gem Beach on D-Day? Turns out, yes. So let's try and work out how and why this happened and what (if anything) it tells us about the final choice of perhaps the most famous beach names in the world.
I have tackled this before in this thread, but more has now come to light which helps to answer a few more questions. So you can read this again if you like, but I'm going to start from the beginning again anyway.
First, at some point in the early 1940s, probably 1942 or 1943, the Inter Service Topographic Department identified potential landing sites on the enemy-held European coast. This included beaches and chines in the cliffs where troops or vehicles could get ashore.
Read 35 tweets
Jan 27, 2023
One for @Books2Cover #photofriday is this paperback that arrived this week and will help inform my own book. And it comes with a little anecdote that is sure to be of interest to @copp_survey.
@Books2Cover @copp_survey Apparently HMS Middleton neatly rammed X23. Now I come across all sorts of extraordinary anecdotes a out D-Day and most can be discounted with a look at contemporary reports. But this one may actually be true...
X23 was marking position DD, the intended launch line of the DD tanks. In their report the crew state the main assault force passed them 1000 yards to the west. That puts X23 about where the green dot is. Middleton (red) would have sailed past her to get to her bombardment slot.
Read 4 tweets
Jan 25, 2023
Last week I discovered that a friend of mine (who shall remain nameless for his own safety) has never heard of:
•Richard Burton
•Where Eagles Dare
•Ron Goodwin's soundtrack.
The therapy is about to start.
Are there any Where Eagles Dare drinking challenges? A shot whenever there's an on screen reload may be a bit pathetic...
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(