Thread by @Mahesh10816

My Conversation with a DK ( Ramaswamy Naicker's Periyar club )
D : Sago i see you always criticise Periyar, its only because of him today we have got rid of castes, you are manuvadis you follow manusmriti
Me :wait ! Lets talk one topic at a time
D : Ok ,Hindu society is Casteist

Me : How do you say Hindu society is Casteist
D: Yes ,all your scriptures talk about caste including Bhagawad Gita
Me :can you quote what is said in Gita
D : It says on the basis of ones birth one is classified as Brahmana, Vysya, Kshatriya and Shudra
Me :Can you quote the sloka

D: I don't know the sloka
Me : Have you read BG
D : No
Me : Then who told you about BG propagating caste
D: Its there in all Periyar books
Me : This is the problem with you guys , you make up your mind on heresay, you dont verify the source
D: you mean to say iam wrong

Me : Let me quote the original sloka

Chapter 4: Transcendental Knowledge

TEXT 13

catur-varnyam maya srstam
guna-karma-vibhagasah
tasya kartaram api mam
viddhy akartaram avyayam

TRANSLATION

According to the three modes of material nature and the work ascribed to them, the four divisions of human society were created by Me. And, although I am the creator of this system, you should know that I am yet the non-doer, being unchangeable.

D: What does it mean
Me : It says people are classified into 4 varnas based on ones GUNA ( qualities ) & not JANMA ( birth )
D : But vedas classify people on birth not qualities
Me :BG is the essence of all Vedas,i have clearly quoted, its says people are classified on ones GUNA

D: But
Me : let me explain iam born in a Brahmin family , if all members of my family are Doctors and iam a businessman, just because my father and mother are Drs , will i become a Dr ?
D: No
Me : Similarly to be in any varna one has to be qualified, and based on one's

Qualification people are classified
D :perfect i don't find any problem in this if this is fact, but Manusmriti says something else
Me :there are 4 yugas and each yuga has prescribed way of worship, prescribed scriptures and different life spans
D: 4 yugas?
Me :Yes let me explain

There are 4 yugas

Satya yuga-

100% purity , lifespan 1 lakh years , method of going back to Godhead is meditation , prescribed scripture - Manusmriti

Duration - 17,28,000 years

Treta Yuga

80% purity , 20 % polluted
Life span 1000 years
Back to Godhead by performing Yagnas
Duration - 12,96,000 years

Dwapar yuga

50% purity , 50% impurity
Life span 1000 years

Back to God head by building Temples and deity worship

Duration : 8,64,000 years

Kaliyuga

20%purity 80% impurity
Life span 100 years
Back to Godhead by Just Chanting the holy Name of Bhagwan

Duration : 4,32,000 years

We have just completed 5000 years

D : amazing info but come back to Manusmriti
Me : As it is clearly stated, Manusmriti belongs to Satya yuga, we are in Kaliyuga, Scripture for Kaliyuga is BG and Srimad Bhagawatam, why do you apply satya Yuga scriptures to kaliyuga?

Can you apply test match rules to T20 ?
D: No

Me : My friend there is varna even in a modern day corporate world
D: 🤔
Me : Yes
Admin :Brahmana
Finance marketing: Vysya
Security :Kshatriya
Workers :Shudra

Again not on the basis of birth but on the basis of qualifications

D: Now iam getting clear and a different perspective

Me : Varnas were created not to divide society but to synchronise people with various qualities and bring harmony and progress to our society

The Mughals and British twisted this system to divide us and convert us

D: thank you so much for removing me from darkness
Me : 🙏🙏🙏

Typo 10000 yrs