"How did you go bankrupt?
Gradually, then suddenly."
- Ernest Hemingway
Warning signs in the early "gradual" phase
• Shipments slow down
• Quality slips a bit
• Inventories build compared to sales
• Payables are extended
• Gross margins erode a bit
• Cash balances are falling
Warning signs in the late "gradual" phase
• Production problems
• Material shortages (mgmt tries to conserve cash)
• AR days go up
• Payables > 60 days
• Cash balances low
• Hard to meet payroll
• Credit facilities in technical default
• Employee morale is failing
Warning signs in the "sudden" phase
• Total chaos
• Behind schedule
• Quality problems
• Collections
• Cash balances negative (after overdraft)
• Employees leaving
• Customers impatient
• Secured lenders lose confidence in management
Quantitative indicators to track:
• Debt/equity
• Working capital ratios
• Receivables / payable days
• Financing long-term assets with short-term money
• Financing costs
• Inventory days
• Declining margins
• Declining profits
• Declining sales
• Falling ASP
• Z-score
Qualitative indicators to track:
• Production problems
• Late shipments
• Incorrect shipments
• Returns
• Unusual allowances
• Rework
• Customer dissatisfaction
• Deferred maintenance
• Low morale / employee turnover
• Accidents
• Management reactive
• Late reporting
Data sources:
• Recent financials
• Management interviews
• Glassdoor / Kanzhun
• Customer review websites: Yelp, Google Maps, Amazon, Trustpilot, etc
• Earnings call transcripts
• LinkedIn for resignation data
• Financial regulator correspondence
• Lawsuit filings
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
"You don't know what anything is worth unless you know what can go wrong."
A 2.5-hour interview is perhaps overkill. But Anthony Deden is a smart man.
Key factors he looks at when analysing companies:
Scarcity
Permanence
Independence
What can go wrong?
Would you re-hire CEO if you were the controlling shareholder?
"I have never met a company that has grown subject to just acquisitions... When you look at something reliant on acquisitions or financial engineering, you are looking at an accident waiting to happen."