A few thoughts. Christianity's decline has been fueled by the desertion of the professional-managerial classes. By contrast, Islam's revival in the 1970s and 80s drew considerable strength from some of those same groups—engineers, doctors, technocrats, lawyers, and teachers
Over the course of the 20th century, Islamic thinkers consciously tried to refashion the religion as rigidly rationalist and anti-supernatural. Rashid Rida, one of the most influential Islamic revivalists of the 20th century, described Islam as the "religion of reason"
Over decades, as the influence of Sufi orders diminished in the Middle East, the spiritual and mystical aspects of Islam were deprioritized in favor of making Islam more "practical" and relevant. Not surprisingly, this is something engineers and doctors found compelling
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
I have a new essay out today on why Christianity failed. Thought I'd share a few thoughts here about what inspired it. The piece brings together a few different strands of my thinking on religion. 1/x wisdomofcrowds.live/why-christiani…
In my recent Atlantic essay 'America without God,' I focused on what Christianity's decline meant for the American idea. But that still leaves open a different, challenging question on why Christian attachments have declined so rapidly. 2/x
The intellectual and spiritual vacuum intensified due to an unlikely confluence of events in the 2000s, and Trump was able to benefit from this. But there's a counterfactual history where instead of Trump filling the vacuum, Christianity could have made a return. It didn't. 3/x
Last week, @dmarusic wrote our first ever Friday Essay, and it's very, very good. I'm biased, but it's one of the most insightful pieces on American religion that I've read in a long while. Check it out.
The goal is that a year from now, we'll have 50 or so essays that are high quality but also a little bit odd, because they won't be meant for tens of thousands of people to read.
One of the main insights from @douthatnyt's book is that decadence is obviously "bad," but it's by no means the worst thing a society can experience. If the choice is between living with decadence or being "rescued" from it by a Napoleonic figure, I know which I'd choose
For me, the most fascinating thing about the new edition of @DouthatNYT's book is that COVID "hardly plays a role"
As @matt_hw8 points out: "If a once-in-a-century pandemic can’t jolt us out of our somnolent decline, maybe nothing can"
1. New Gallup numbers are out on US religion. Yes, church membership isn't an exact proxy for religiosity. But membership tells us about the structured presence of religion in people's lives. As a measure, it's likely to have more political implications than personal belief
2. But individual religiosity has *also *decreased, if not to the same extent. There has been a significant decrease in number of Americans who say God or religion is important in their daily lives, and the numbers are particularly low for young Americans
3. Secularization is real and rapid. "Nones"—atheists, agnostics, and those claiming no religion—today represent a quarter of the population. And this has happened over a relatively short period of time
Who knows. Maybe “whiteness” doesn’t explain everything.
It's been hard to watch otherwise smart liberals twist themselves into knots trying to figure out how to apply absurd and arbitrary constructions around race to current events
Critical race theory, or whatever you want to call this silliness, is objectionable for a number of reasons, but at a very basic level it makes people sound ridiculous