Nelson: If a person has drugs in their system and that drug causes an overdose in the context of the police restraint, it's not the natural consequence of the restraint, it's the natural consequence of the deceased's actions.
Nelson is now running through the medical witnesses called by the state.
Nelson: I submit to you that the testimonies [of the state's medical witnesses], it flies in the absolute face of reason and common sense. It's astounding.
Nelson reminds the jury that a "homicide" classification is a medical term, not a legal one.
Nelson highlights the contributing conditions on Floyd's death certificate, including hypertension and "recent methamphetamine use."
"If something is insignificant to death, you don't put it on the death certificate," Nelson says.
Nelson plays a couple of minutes of body camera footage, arguing Floyd was in the side recovery position during this clip. "You cannot take a single, isolated frame and reach any conclusions," he says.
Nelson now shifts to talking about toxicology.
"The history of Mr. Floyd's use of controlled substances, it's significant," Nelson says.
Nelson highlights the still image of a white object in Floyd's mouth. "Is it gum? Is it banana? Is it drugs?" he says. Notes the pills found at the scene and the drugs found in Floyd's system.
Nelson criticizes the state's medical witnesses for dismissing Floyd's drug use. "I ask, would any of those doctors prescribe illicit methamphetamine to their patients? Would they give it to their kids?" he says.
Judge Cahill interrupts Nelson to call for a 30 minute lunch break for the jury.
Court is back and Nelson is resuming his closing argument. WATCH LIVE: wcco.com/cbsn
Nelson appears to be having technical issues with his accompanying PowerPoint.
Nelson is attacking Dr. Tobin's (one of the state's medical witnesses) testimony that Floyd died of brain hypoxia.
Nelson: [The timeline of Floyd's death] is consistent with a sudden cardiac arrhythmia. It is not consistent with the longer process of brain hypoxia.
"I have one last point to make and I should be fairly quick with this," Nelson says.
Nelson: When you take into consideration the presumption of innocence and proof beyond a reasonable doubt, I would submit to you that it is nonsense to suggest none of these other factors had any role. That is not reasonable.
Nelson: And when you as members of the jury conclude your analysis of the evidence, when you review the entirety of the evidence, when you review the law as written and you conclude it all within this - all within a thorough, honest analysis... (1/2)
...the state has failed to prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt and therefore Mr. Chauvin should be found not guilty of all counts (2/2).
The state asks for a curative instruction to jurors regarding some of Nelson's comments about "intent." Judge Cahill denies.
Prosecutor Jerry Blackwell is addressing the jury for the state's rebuttal.
Blackwell tells the jury about the 46th witness (they've previously heard from 45): "That witness is common sense."
Blackwell: Why is it necessary to continue applying deadly restraint to a man who is defenseless, who is handcuffed, who is not resisting, who is not breathing, who doesn't have a pulse?
Blackwell: Verdict is a Latin word that means truth. You're not going to reach a 'story' when all is said and done.
Blackwell: You were told that homicide is a medical term. That's not what Dr. Baker said.
Blackwell: What we need to show is that the defendant's actions were a substantial causal factor in [Floyd's] death.
Blackwell shows the jury a timeline of Floyd's life, with one dot representing each day he lived. "There was a 10-minute segment, nine minutes and 29 seconds, that he didn't survive ... What happened in that space? Well, you know what happened."
Blackwell: You heard the statement that the state is seeking to ignore significant medical issues and nothing could be further from the truth.
Blackwell: We're only required to show you that Mr. Chauvin's conduct was a substantial cause, a substantial factor in Mr. Floyd's death.
"What was there to be afraid of, here particularly at this scene?" Blackwell says before running through the bystanders: high school students, a second grader, a first responder, Donald Williams, Charles McMillian
Blackwell: If those bystanders did not respect this badge, they could very easily have taken the law into their own hands and simply removed Mr. Chauvin ... but none of them did that, because they respect this badge, even if it tore them up inside.
Blackwell: If you love life, you get excited when you see life getting taken.
Nelson objects to Blackwell's use of the word "stories." Cahill tells the jury to disregard the word.
Blackwell brings up the defense's focus on carbon monoxide. "If Mr. Floyd is being subdued on the ground by Mr. Chauvin" near the car's tailpipe, "why isn't that an unreasonable use of force?"
Blackwell: But here's the deal about the pills ... Why are we talking about pills that aren't in his system? We know what's in his bloodstream already.
Blackwell: You don't need a Ph.D., you don't need an M.D. to understand how fundamental breathing is to life.
Blackwell: The fact of the matter is, ladies and gentlemen, the use of unreasonable force, the unreasonable use of force is an assault. Here it was an assault and it contributed to the death of Mr. Floyd.
"The truth of the matter is that the reason George Floyd is dead is Mr. Chauvin's heart was too small," Blackwell says in conclusion.
Judge Cahill now giving the jury instructions.
"As jurors, you are being asked to make an important decision in this case," Cahill says.
Cahill: You must be absolutely fair ... I am sure you are aware that this case is important and serious and therefore deserves your careful consideration.
The jurors will now begin deliberations. Jurors 96 and 118 will be dismissed as the alternates.
Nelson is asking Cahill for a mistrial based on statements the prosecution made during closing arguments, such as alleging the defense was "shading the truth."
Here is the full quote from Blackwell, closing the argument: "You were told, for example, that Mr. Floyd died because his heart was too big. ... The truth of the matter is that the reason George Floyd is dead is because Mr. Chauvin's heart was too small."
Cahill: I think it was adequately addressed by the court's instruction to disregard.

They're moving on to other matters.
Nelson: The media attention is profound ... This case has found its way into even fictional television.
Nelson asking for another mistrial based on the media attention. "You can't avoid it and it is so pervasive."
The state responds via Steve Schleicher, who wants a specific offer of proof that the jury was influenced by the media attention: "I just don't think that we can muddy the record with vague allegations."
Cahill denies Nelson's motion for mistrial.
Chauvin waives his right to jury trial when it comes to aggravating factors - the state has noted it will seek an aggravated sentence if Chauvin is convicted.
"We are in recess until we hear from the jury," Cahill says.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with WCCO - CBS Minnesota

WCCO - CBS Minnesota Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @WCCO

19 Apr
After 14 days of testimony, closing arguments are about to be made in the #DerekChauvinTrial.

WATCH LIVE: cbsloc.al/32FEJCJ

LATEST UPDATES: cbsloc.al/3x4aMtQ Image
Prosecutor Steve Schleicher is expected to deliver the closing argument on behalf of the state.

After that, Eric Nelson, the attorney for Derek Chauvin, will make his closing argument.

Each statement is expected to last about an hour.
After the defense's presentation, the state is expected to give a rebuttal.
Read 41 tweets
8 Apr
Testimony is resuming this morning in the #DerekChauvinTrial. Medical experts are expected to take the stand.

Also, Judge Cahill is expected to decide on whether a man who was with #GeorgeFloyd in the moments before his death will testify.

WATCH LIVE: cbsloc.al/39Qfl0H
Before testimony began, Eric Nelson, the attorney for Derek Chauvin, noted that the state intends to call Andrew Baker, the Hennepin County medical examiner who performed the autopsy on #GeorgeFloyd, tomorrow.
First up today is Dr. Martin Tobin, a physician in pulmonary critical care.

He defined pulmonology as "the study of the lungs...of all diseases that effect the respiratory system."

He is being questioned by prosecutor Jerry Blackwell.
Read 69 tweets
7 Apr
Nelson: Doesn't "saying things like 'you're a f***ing p****, you're a b****" convey a particular intent?
Stiger: "I wouldn't say intent," adding it depends on the officer's training. | cbsloc.al/2PziOKt
Nelson calls up surveillance photo outside Cup Foods. Asks Stiger about Chauvin's position, and could that indicate less of his weight on his left side, where his knee is holding down Floyd. Stiger affirms.
Prosecution's Steven Schleicher begins redirect of witness Jody Stiger by asking about the risks of positional asphyxia, making a distinction between positioning as opposed to pressure and weight.
Read 84 tweets
7 Apr
Nelson plays video of Kueng's body-worn camera video. He asks if he can understand what #GeorgeFloyd is saying.

N: Does it sound like he says he ate too many drugs.

Stiger: I can't make it out.

WATCH LIVE: cbsloc.al/3uIJebF
Nelson notes that officers discussed using a "hobble device" on #GeorgeFloyd.

He suggests that because officers decided not to use it, it could be viewed as a de-escalation technique.
Nelson: You would agree that sometimes the use of force, it looks really bad?

Stiger: Yes.

Nelson: It looks bad, but it's still lawful.

Stiger: Yes

WATCH LIVE: cbsloc.al/3uIJebF
Read 7 tweets
7 Apr
Day 8 of testimony in the #DerekChauvinTrial continues this morning with Sgt. Jody Stiger, a use-of-force expert from the Los Angeles Police Department.

He is the state's first paid expert to testify.

WATCH LIVE: cbsloc.al/3uIJebF

LATEST UPDATES: cbsloc.al/3rUYSyM
Sgt. Stiger began his testimony yesterday afternoon. He called Chauvin's use-of-force against #GeorgeFloyd "excessive."

He is currently being questioned prosecutor Steve Schleicher.

WATCH LIVE: cbsloc.al/3uIJebF
Stiger reviews surveillance and body-worn camera footage.

Stiger testifies that Chauvin's left knee was on #GeorgeFloyd's neck and his right knee was on Floyd's back.

Stiger notes that Chauvin's feet were spread, with the majority of his weight pushing down on his knees.
Read 20 tweets
6 Apr
🔴LIVE: #DerekChauvinTrial testimony continues with Los Angeles Police Officer Jody Stiger taking the stand as a law enforcement expert.

WATCH: wcco.com/cbsn
LIVE UPDATES: cbsloc.al/3sUfLeb Image
Officer Stiger has been with the LAPD since 1993, and has worked with homicide and gang units. Has extensive experience with use of force reviews.
Officer Stiger, the state's expert witness, has reviewed all body cam footage, other videos including cell phone videos, reports, manuals from MPD, and training materials in his review of the May 25 incident.
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!