Genetic testing: there are so many tests to choose from! Karyotype, Microarray, Whole exome sequencing, they all sound the same. What's the difference? Read on and hopefully things will become clear... 🧵 #meded#tweetorial#medgen
First, let's remember that our DNA is found in really nice organized packages called chromosomes. Humans have 23 pair of chromosomes = 46 in total. Each chromosome has a short arm (p=petit) and a long arm (q=comes after p).
Genes are segments of DNA where each codes for a specific protein.
Genes are found along chromosomes in a predictable location and order. For example, the CFTR gene is found on the long arm of chromosome 7 in all humans.
OKAY, I CANNOT STRESS THIS POINT ENOUGH. There are different tests to look at mutations in 1. Chromosomes (blue tests) vs. 2. Genes (orange tests).
See how the blue and orange tests don't really overlap? They are looking at different sized genetic changes.
The main chromosome tests are: 1. Karyotype 2. FISH 3. Microarray
Imma gonna teach you the differences
1. Karyotype
This is a really good test for looking at chromosome number, large changes to the chromosomes, and its structure. But it's not really good at looking at the chromosomes in fine detail. That's why we rarely use the test anymore. We have better tests now.
2. FISH (Fluorescence In Situ Hybridization)
There are chromosome deletions and dups that are too small to be seen on karyotype (microdeletion/microdup). That's when you can use FISH! But you need to know exactly the region you're interested in (eg. 22q.11 FISH for Digeorge).
3. Microarray
This test will detect ANY size imbalance in chromosomes including microdel/dups, may miss balanced changes. Thankfully, most chromosome diseases are caused by imbalance. That's why microarray is the bomb diggity of chromosome tests.
IN summary: if you're suspecting a chromosomal disorder, send a MICROARRAY.
Rarely do you need a karyotype or FISH. If you are thinking of sending these, you may want to talk to a genetic counsellor, geneticist, or lab first. We good?
Okay, what about the other non-chromosome tests, the orange tests on that previous slide? AND WHEN AM I GOING TO TALK ABOUT AN EXOME?
There are different tests that look at your GENES.
There are many gene-based tests:
A. Targeted sequencing
B. Whole exome sequencing
C. MLPA/deletion duplication testing
D. Repeat expansion testing
E. Methylation testing
F. Mitochondrial sequencing
Let's start with our favourite, SEQUENCING. Recall that genes contain exons that actually code for the protein. Sequencing is great at picking up common gene variants (SNVs and small Indels) and mainly within exons.
The main sequencing tests are:
A: Targeted sequencing of specific gene(s): Single gene testing (eg. CFTR) OR Multiple genes (eg. Epilepsy panel)
B: Whole exome sequencing: Sequence all exons of disease genes at once
It's not without its limitations, but it's a darn good test.
C. MLPA (deletion/duplication testing)
What if there was a deletion or duplication within the DNA that was larger than a few nucleotides (like say several exons large), but MUCH smaller than a chromosome microdeletion/duplication? You can use a test called MLPA to pick these up.
D. Triplet repeat testing
Testing for expansion disorders like Huntington disease, Fragile X, myotonic dystrophy, or many forms of cerebellar ataxia? The best sequencing will miss these mutations and you need to send for these conditions separately.
E. Methylation testing
How about Angelman and Prader-Willi? Where diseases can be caused not by changes to the sequence but by methylation defects of DNA? These can be missed on sequencing too. You need a methylation test.
F. Mitochondrial sequencing
Not all of our genes are found on those 46 chromosomes. We have some mitochondrial genes that we all inherited solely from our moms. These genes are tested using different methods. Mitochondrial sequencing.
Do you see how these gene-based tests mostly don't overlap? they are looking for different types of mutations in the genes.
Okay, how about:
Whole Genome Sequencing?
This looks at chromosomal changes (remember those?) + sequences exons, non-coding regions, and triplet repeats all at once. It will still miss a few conditions though.
It's available, just not clinically everywhere yet.
Sending the correct test is actually the easy part. Don't forget about the possible results you can receive and will have to interpret.
These apply mainly to microarray and sequencing tests. We recommend you counsel patients about these before you send them for a blood draw.
And since you've made it this far, don't forget about my hot tips, my fellow nerds!
RE: Race descriptors- While there is a place for them (like when discussing social determinants), it is not useful when stratifying cohorts as it is not binary nor a great surrogate for ancestry. We can do better!
ALSO: We need to stop using the term Caucasian.
I'm surprised that many ppl are not aware that the term Caucasian has supremacist roots. The term originated in the 1700s by a bunch of bros who believed the ppl in the "Caucus region" were the most beautiful ppl in the world, made in "God's image". sjsu.edu/people/carol.m…
Here is an excerpt that I hope will convince you to retire the term Caucasian from your lexicon.
Out of curiosity I attempted to book a COVID-19 test in Toronto today using the screening tool and followed ALL the links to the assessment centre sites at 7 pm. Shall we see what happened? Get your popcorn and Kleenex ready. covid19toronto.ca
Women's college. Alarm set for tomorrow at 5:45 am. If I'm not successful, at least I will see the sunrise.
University Health Network. Thoughts and prayers until I log on at 7:59 tomorrow, I guess?
In my job as a doctor I handle risk assessment regularly. I am also a parent to two kids. My daughter has been sent home to quarantine due to a confirmed case of COVID-19 in her class. I have some concerns as it pertains to Covid containment in schools. 1/ @tdsb@TOPublicHealth
High risk ppl (confirmed close contact w covid19) are in the SAME lineups as low risk ppl (runny nose).These lineups are LONG rn.If you don't believe me check out covidwaits.com. Social distancing is not always maintained. Glad these lines are mostly outdoors for now. 2/
Turnaround times are the SAME for high risk people vs. those with a runny nose, sometimes up to a week now. While I'd like to think everyone is self-isolating while they are waiting for results, in reality we know that there are a lot of people who will not, or cannot. 3/
As we may be headed into a long few months and bummed about everything-here is a thread of easy trails and gardens you can visit with kids around Toronto and vicinity for some nature therapy. We visited all of these:
Williamson park ravine. Entrance on Gerrard east of Coxwell. Short half km walk but sweet. Smalls creek runs through it.
Glen Stuart ravine. Off of Kingston rd, in upper beach area. Boardwalk and stairs is about 1.5 km. Easy. Very pretty.
Review on sickle cell trait and covid outcomes in Black popl’n by @UofT resident Dr.Osundiji. So important for us to study genetics in non-whites to better understand health outcomes in these populations. There is a caveat tho. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/P…
It is not a pass for the genetics community to ignore the well established non-genetic determinants of health outcomes in Black people. I’ll call this, “the other things”. blackhealthalliance.ca/home/social-de…
Genetics professionals need to be v. aware that our genetics enthusiasm is gobbled up by the laypublic and risks drowning out a commitment to fixing “the other things”. Genetic code cannot be fixed.
How can I make a decision re: my intentions when I have no guiding info, @tdsb? "To help with our planning, you will be receiving beginning Tue Aug 11 an automated School Messenger phone call from the TDSB asking for you to indicate your intentions for your child for Sept."
I know nothing about final class sizes or how they're going to do lunches or if there is more outdoor time. I know nothing about what is the protocol if my kid gets a fever or someone gets COVID in my kid's school. I don't even know what the actual hours of school will be?!
So a mere few weeks from the start of the school year, it seems that the only thing I really know for certain is that I will NOT be able to indicate my actual intentions about school to the automated school messenger tomorrow.