In Southern states with the slowest rollout of the COVID-19 vaccine, the strongest indicator of very low vaccination rates is … Trump voters. Simply, where Trump got more votes, fewer get vaccinated.
.@VincentDGabriel and I have chipped away at this big story since February. Yes, it is behind a paywall. Yes, you must be a subscriber to read it. But it will publish in @USATODAY Network papers throughout the south, so you can read it if you are a subscriber to any of them.
If you aren't a subscriber yet, please consider becoming one. Subscriptions are not a reward for one good story. They are an investment in the journalism on horizon. We need you. And, I believe, you need us. cm.tennessean.com/specialoffer/?…
For those of you who aren't subscribers yet, I’m going to summarize a few of the major findings from this story here. But this thread will only cover the basics. There is much more depth and substance in the article, including a detailed map featuring county-by-county data.
Also, for those of you who read my coverage regularly, there is a little scoop at the end of this thread.
It is a rare bit of good news.
This article examines vaccine data from 800ish counties in 9 southern states for about 2 months. We found the correlation between Trump votes and low vaccinations was widespread, but is strongest in states with the slowest rollouts: Alabama, Louisiana, Mississippi and Tennessee.
Vaccination rates are below the national average in nearly every inch of these four states. But they are lowest in areas that overwhelmingly voted for former President Donald Trump in the 2020 election. Where Biden won or the election was close, many more people are vaccinated.
In fact, the correlation between Trump support and low vaccination rates is stronger than any link between vaccines and race, age, poverty, unemployment, population density or general health. In short, even now, it appears nothing matters more than Trump.
Also, while many feared Black Americans would be the most hesitant to be vaccinated, our results show the exact opposite. This is most visible in Alabama, where the few counties that are mostly Black account for 7 out of 10 of the highest vaccinations rates in the state.
Some of the findings of this story were predicted by public polling. Polls have shown again and again that Republicans are the most unwilling to be vaccinated. But those polls forecast the future. Our findings are built on real-world data. This is happening, for real, right now.
Why is this bad? A few reasons. First, low vaccination rates increase risk for those who can’t get vaccinated, like kids. Second, low rates increase the chances for the birth of a dangerous variant that may spread to everywhere, regardless of political leaning or vaccine rates.
And third, some of these Trumpian counties REALLY need vaccines.
For example, in East Tennessee, the counties where Trump won biggest don't just have the lowest vaccination rates. They are also far more likely to be poorer, unhealthier and more vulnerable.
We have the fewest vaccinations in the places that need vaccinations the most.
How do we fix this? Trump. Every expert we interviewed said no one has more power to sway conservatives than the former president himself. Trump could convince many of them to reconsider. So far, he hasn’t really tried.
Since leaving office, Trump has repeatedly talked about how he deserves more “credit” for vaccines, and even floated renaming them “Trumpcine.” But he rarely actually advocates for vaccinations. And he kept his own vaccination quiet for months. That was a deliberate choice.
There is no doubt Trump remains a power player in American politics. He could use his reach and influence to encourage his supporters to protect themselves. If he did, would they listen? I don’t know.
I would like to live in a world where we find out.
Finally, I promised a scoop if you got to the end of this thread. Here it is: This will most likely be my last big story for a while. After a challenging year of nonstop virus coverage, I will be taking a month off so my partner and I can welcome our first child.
This was a terrifying year to have a kid on the way, especially if you spend your days (and nights) seeped in virus stories like I do. Pregnancy makes my partner more susceptible to COVID-19 complications, and even the best hospitals can’t eliminate the risk of exposure.
Fortunately, as the big day finally approaches, we can move forward with lots of excitement and little trepidation. Why?
I believe we are as ready as new parents can be.
And, also, because we are both fully vaccinated.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Today, The @Tennessean published an investigation in which I identify dozens of links between known coronavirus clusters in Nashville through an analysis of contact tracing data. This is my most complex journalism of 2020. And this is a thread. 1/ tennessean.com/in-depth/news/…
My story is behind the paywall, so you must be a subscriber to read it. If you aren’t a subscriber, this thread will highlight some of our findings. But please consider a sub to support journalism like this. We need you. tennessean.subscriber.services/?gclid=CjwKCAi…
I started this story in July. In the quiet moments between the daily deadlines, data entry and bad tweets, I chipped away at the reporting. I worked lots of extra evenings, some weekends. I am quite proud of the result, and I’d be honored if you read it.
Today I return to covering the coronavirus in Tennessee after a much-needed vacation. This thread is will recap major outbreak trends over the past 10 days or so, just in case you need a refresher. (I did.) It's not pretty. 1/
After weeks of flattening, the coronavirus outbreak in Tennessee has begun to grow again. Since a low point on Oct. 3, active infections have risen 34% to about 18,000. This is bad. public.flourish.studio/visualisation/…
State officials insist active infections is not a great measurement for the virus. They prefer test positivity rate. Well, after weeks of decline, Tennessee's positivity rate has stopped falling and is ticking upwards.
Tennessee’s coronavirus stats went wonky today because both the Nashville and state governments separately changed how they present data. I know many of you attempt to follow this closely, so I’m going to try to explain it all. This is going to get weedy.
.@TNDeptofHealth made two major changes. First, they revised how they define “recovered” coronavirus patients, resulting in a big reduction in the count of active infections in every county. Second, they corrected about 1,700 cases that were listed in the wrong county. Whoopsie.
There is no one standard for what it means to be “recovered” from coronavirus. Previously, Tennessee classified you as recovered in one of two ways:
1. Infected people should have daily convos with contact tracers, who deem them recovered when symptoms are safely over.
In the past month, Tennessee has made incredible gains in the campaign against coronavirus. But we have so much to lose. This is a short thread about how it could all go wrong. tennessean.com/story/news/hea…
Today, I spent about an hour listening to health policy researchers at Vanderbilt University (@VUHealthPol). They’ve been quietly modeling the coronavirus in our state for a few weeks. I was anxious to see what they knew. There is a lot to unpack here. Here we go.
First, social distancing is working. In mid-March, an infected Tennessean was believed to spread the virus to 5 people. At that rate, the virus grows uncontrollably exponentially. Then we started the hard stuff. Staying home. Closing businesses. Missing our friends & families.
Yesterday, Tennessee Gov. Bill Lee (@GovBillLee) ordered Tennesseans to stay home, saying cell phone tracking data helped convince him to take stronger action to stop coronavirus. I dug into that data, wanting to understand what he saw. This is a thread. tennessean.com/story/news/hea…
First, it is important to know Lee did not want to do this. At every step of the virus outbreak, he has resisted ordering Tennesseans around. Lee, a small-government Republican, said he believed in advising, not mandating. But, as the outbreak grew, he had to change his tactics.
On Monday, Lee issued an executive order “strongly urging” Tennesseans to stay inside. Many people didn’t think this was enough. On Thursday, Lee changed his urging to a mandate. He said he was compelled by traffic and cell phone data showing too few people were moving too much.
The Tennessee government got 1,800+ public comments on its plan for a Medicaid block grant. I read them all so you don’t have to. This is a thread about health care, journalism and how a heap of public records dissolved my brain into soup. It will be more fun than it sounds. 1/
If you haven’t heard, @GovBillLee wants to convert TennCare to a block grant. The state would get more control over billions in federal money that funds insurance for poor families, kids and people with disabilities. It's complicated but important. 2/ tennessean.com/story/news/pol…
But lots of people are afraid the block grant will hurt, not help. They suspect state officials will use this new authority over TennCare to intentionally weaken or reduce coverage, cut costs and divert money elsewhere. 3/