Kent Lee Platte Profile picture
May 8, 2021 31 tweets 12 min read Read on X
You know what we haven't looked at in a while? Some outliers.

For #RAS, this normally refers to players who found success in the NFL despite not testing off the charts.

I think it's important to keep some of that in context, that it's not a death knell when a guy isn't superman
Let's kick this off with what is still my favorite low #RAS card, Jarvis Landry!

Landry's combine performance in 2014 was one of the worst in this history of the NFL, in no small part due to pulling his hamstring.

I mean, just look at it!
Landry would test better at his pro day (shown here with his Combine bench since he didn't redo that), but like...still not good. But better!
Another all time terrible Combine performance that's a bit more recent was from Orlando Brown, formerly of Ravens now with Chiefs. This performance is a big reason Brown fell to where he did, and might have fallen even further if not for his familial connection to the Ravens.
Brown himself would do an excellent job of highlighting why he's still successful in the NFL. Frankly, it should be required reading for anyone trying to evaluate NFL talent, to help identify outliers in the data by better understanding film.

baltimoreravens.com/news/orlando-b…
Larry Warford was described as out of shape at the 2013 Combine, resulting in an all time oof description that "his body just looks sloppy". He had some injury issues with Detroit, who drafted him, but would go on to have a few pro bowl seasons with the Saints.
Warford would change his diet and work out with former pro bowl guard LeCharles Bentley before his first training camp, showing up to the Lions in "incredible shape", which seems a lot better than sloppy. He would go on to start and play well whenever he was on the field.
Another former Lions player, Quandre Diggs came out as a corner and would start at nickel for the Lions. He was very good out the gate, but had a really rough follow up where he allowed more than 90% of his targets to be completed.
Later, after injuries to their starters, Lions would move Diggs to Safety, a role he would go on to thrive in. He picked up 3 picks in each 2017 and 2018 before the Lions traded him to Seattle, where he made a pro bowl in 2020.
Devonta Freeman was one of the more exciting running backs in 2015-2017 before injuries really started to pile on. It might be surprising to some that he tested quite poorly, including in areas he seemingly had no issue on the field.
Mark Ingram remains the only RB taken in the 1st round since 1987 with a #RAS lower than 5.00. While it wasn't until his 6th season that he broke 1,000 yards, he finished his Saints career with over 6k yards and 50 touchdowns on the ground.
It's fun to look back at players like Travis Frederick and see how the narrative shifted. Largely considered a reach at the time, Frederick wasn't a great tester to put it mildly.

He would go on to be one of the best interior offensive lineman in the NFL until his retirement.
You know, I skipped right over Vontaze Burfict since I was primarily looking at drafted guys.

Burfict famously had the worst Combine ever, bombing out at testing, interviews, pretty much everything.

Hard to put a finger on which part of the Combine he did the worst at.
While his reputation as one of the league's dirtiest players stuck, he had a productive career when healthy and not suspended...
Considering his level of play, I think it surprises some people to learn that Kam Chancellor didn't test well in any area other than size and bench. He would go on to be one of the most feared hitters in the NFL over his career.
Another favorite, Anquan Boldin wasn't a particularly good tester, but he also didn't win because he was fast or even particularly explosive.

All you had to do to beat him? Fight him for the ball.

Boldin put up 1,377 yards on 101 receptions his rookie year and never looked back
Considering how versatile of a receiver he was, it can be surprising that Randall Cobb didn't test well in any area other than nearly dead average speed.
Trent Brown, along with Orlando Brown no relation, is one of the only pro bowl offensive tackles in the last 20 years to have a #RAS below 5.00.
Za'Darius Smith is one of the players (along with DeForest Buckner, Arik Armstead, others) that led me to build a subset for DL. It's not up on the site yet, but it's easy to be fooled by 'poor' testing at DE for the larger guys who win inside.
Injury is part of why Jordan Reed's score is so low and that would largely be the story of his NFL career.

He remains the only TE with a sub 5.00 #RAS to find significant NFL success in the last two decades.
Calais Campbell, like Za'Darius Smith, falls into a different type of end so his 'poor' testing requires more context.
Remember when Antonio Brown was just a decent punt returner prospect? His testing played a part in why that was the thinking at the time, and why he was drafted where he was.
There are few examples of edge rushers with poor #RAS finding success, but one of our recent ones comes in UDFA Shaq Barrett, who found his fit as well as his rhythm in Tampa.
Tamba Hali also falls into that sub group of DL I'm working on, but compared to regular DE it wasn't a good look.
Xavien Howard didn't test well at all at the 2016 NFL Combine, but I believe that was due to an injury at the time.
Shown here (compared up to 2021 instead of 2016), using his Combine bench and shuttle since he didn't retest, it's pretty clear that Howard's Combine was not as representative of his athletic ability.
Can't leave off Dalvin Cook, whose testing was as mind boggling at the time as it is today.
Ah, Josh Norman. This dude paved the way to people thinking that any slow corner could be good if given the chance.

As it turns out, speed is pretty important, which is why a guy from 2012 is still used as an example and there aren't plenty of others.
Sometimes poor testing is as simple as "He was literally injured on tape during his testing".
There are plenty of others, but those are the most notable.

Never forget that bad testing doesn't mean a player is destined for the scrap heap.
The chances are lower that they'll be drafted highly.

Lower that they'll find success.

Lower than they'll get the opportunities to start.

But not zero, and never lose sight that in this regard we're speaking solely from testing, taking into account nothing else.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Kent Lee Platte

Kent Lee Platte Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @MathBomb

Apr 28, 2022
We haven't had a player drafted in the 1st round with a #RAS below 5.00 since 2019, where we had three.

Deandre Baker, L.J. Collier, and Dwayne Haskins (RIP).

The COVID years limited testing, but I think teams also played it a lot safer than they would have otherwise.
Will any player under 5.00 be drafed in 2022?

I can't think of one that should. Offhand, I can't even think of a player that MIGHT go in the 1st with a lower score.
2018 only had one player under 5.00, Baker Mayfield who was taken first.
Read 6 tweets
Apr 27, 2022
Happy draft week!

It's been an awesome year and I've got some exciting things cooking for 2023. If youve enjoyed #RAS,please consider donating to help expand the site and help bring some new tools for the draft community in 2023!

venmo.com/mathbomb

paypal.me/Mathbomb
We've been able to add some cool new features to the site this year, courtesy of @StatManEric, including the RAS Compare tool, which allows a side by side comparison of any two prospects compared all time against the RAS database.

RAS.football/ras-compare
We also added a calculator to every single player page, allowing for quick hypotheticals like what a player would score if they were just a little bigger, or if they had tested in an area they didn't for the year.

Like what if Jordan Davis had done the bench and average agis. Image
Read 7 tweets
Aug 31, 2021
It probably won't be quite as fun as most years given the start of a rebuild, but let's run through the #Lions initial 53 mean roster for #RAS!
By now, if you follow me, you probably know my thoughts on Goff.

Clock is ticking before they have a new QB, but given...the next two guys...he's going to start every game he's healthy for.

Unlike the Rams, he won't get benched here for poor play. Not with his price tag.
Tim Boyle is not very accurate, nor is he very good at reading a defense.

What he is, though, is big with a strong arm and pretty athletic. That'll buy you some credit, at least with scout team, when your starter has only one of those things.
Read 53 tweets
May 6, 2021
It's still WAY too early to rank them, but having done my preliminary work on 16 QB prospects for 2022, here are my early thoughts.
There are no top tier talents like we had in 2021.

Prior to the 2021 season, there were three QBs vying for the top spot. All three of them would go at the top of the first round, with the addition of a fast riser in Zach Wilson and a late one in Mac Jones.

None like that here.
Doesn't mean that there won't be a top flight QB in 2022, and for reasons I'll go into there almost certainly will be at least one or two.
Read 14 tweets
Dec 14, 2020
Since we're talking about bad draft picks, I think it's time for one of those old walks down memory lane, y'all. Wanna walk through the past few GMs and their draft classes?

We're gonna go back a ways.
So the Lions have always had a wonky front office set up. How they've had it under Wood/Quinn/Patricia is probably the most easily understood power structure they've had in decades, and probably the best organized (in theory, obviously, still gotta hire the right people).
Pre-Millen, they had a guy named Chuck Schmidt.

Schmidt took over the Lions in 1989 and was pretty stand offish. Kind of like how Rod Wood is today, really, he just kinda hired people and then pissed off somewhere.
Read 97 tweets
Dec 11, 2020
Most of my followers are here for the football takes, but I'm a big film, music, and game guy as well.

There are few singers or musicians I mention more often than Sam Cooke, who died on this date in 1964.

Cooke had one of the most unique sounds, both of his day and until now.
These are his top five songs on Spotify, each a timeless classic in his own distinct style, but also varied in tone, topic, and mood.

Cooke could bring it no matter what you were feeling, and you couldn't help but sing along if you were the type to when the mood struck. Image
I'm currently nearly five years older than Cooke was when he was killed, and considering the quality and volume of his work I think it's one of the greatest cultural tragedies that we were robbed of what he could have done with a full career.

Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(