Ok so we know the “commercial in confidence” argument is the bullshit excuse they use to hide how much money they’re burning on #CashlessDebitCard “trials”, but how, HOW, can they pretend AAT cases are CIC? Somebody help me out here. #BTPM#Budget2021@aimnau
this is not *all* the money they will spend bullying poor folks over minor accounting errors, just the little bit for the Attorney-General to spend. she prob requested it specifically since she doesn’t get to punish unemployed people in her day-to-day job much anymore.
an assortment of things that won’t do what they say on the tin
look, “savings”
when will we start adding up the cost of the harm done
why even have this line item
(the second one is the rebranded CDP)
It’s so lucky that people don’t food or a place to live until they’ve been here four years. A miracle of science.
Huh.
All this increased support, so kindly
I think we need to be talking more about how this WON’T help
It’s not actually more money they’re just putting back money they already cut. I know this cos @damiyahayden is the expert and she told me so.
god there is so much absurd shit in here it is very difficult to refrain from posting
nothing good can ever come of myGov
this is just going to be another disastrous waste of public money, with private training orgs that offer pointless courses profiting while uni and TAFE are gutted
unemployed folks WANT meaningful help, not this
THIS 👏 NEEDS 👏 MORE 👏 COVERAGE 👏
✅ more bullying people into self-employment
✅ more job agency cash for covid
✅ more Highly Successful job fairs to lure poor people into the defence force
✅ more Highly Successful relocation assistance to lure poor people into unsafe, exploitative farm labour jobs
👎👎👎
huge if true
side note: I can’t think of anything that will fill unemployed folks w more dread than “intensive support” from their job agency
for DES folks: countdown to 1 Jan when you can escape your provider
check out @mjelmas’s article on this huge saving – the gov will treat ppl equitably by making sure *everyone* has to wait longer to get a payment, instead of making sure everyone can get it when they’re eligible
literally just stop forcing millions of people to live in poverty and exposing them to terrorising job agencies / dangerous ‘mutual’ obligations you fucking monsters
love these open admissions that they’ve been doing something SHIT
overall the gov is banking a saving here, spending even less money on remote communities
I have no faith they’ll replace CDP w something actually good, but these communities need and deserve that money + more
Just no words for this cruelty
The “trials” apparently going to continue at least two years beyond the current life of the scheme, which sunsets in December 2022
The gov has learned nothing from the damage done + lives lost from it’s debt recovery activities
@lukehgomes on the absurdity: “the taskforce was provided $10.7m in the 2019-20 financial year, and recovered $9.22m in welfare payments over the same period” theguardian.com/australia-news…
This leaves people more than $15 a week FURTHER BELOW the poverty line than they were before COVID #HPL
Guess this explains what they did with the $200 million saving from making NEST participants wait longer for payments @mjelmas
And thx to @lukehgomes for keeping an eye on what’s happening w DobSeeker – cheeky $2.5m for it. A reminder that <0.001% of ppl refused work in 2019
Your reminder that this is NOT new funding but replaces earlier funding cuts, relentlessly scrutinised by @damiyahayden
Far as we know they only seem to be closing Centrelink offices. Probs just using this money to get out into the community spruiking the cashless debit card I guess @aimnau
I am fascinated by this. @lukehgomes have you ever looked at how/why this one community has managed to secure this arrangement?
And here’s $7 billion they ALREADY planned to spend on unemployment payments.
So simple to just start lifting payments above the poverty line by keeping this money for unemployed people. But no. Cruelty and austerity is the only choice. #BTPM#HPL
Every year they do this and every year I will point out that the vast majority of this is spending on pensions, not unemployment payments. These used to be represented separately, but the gov realised they could boost their demonisation of unemployed folks by combining the two.
Incl the covid supplement + w highest ever unemployment, JS payments were about 16% of ALL social security spending. Age pension was 28% in same year. This yr JS will be just 10% of social security spending, or THREE PERCENT of total spending.
It’s not that we can’t help older folks and disabled folks. It’s simply that we can also help unemployed folks to survive. I can’t stand this.
This is not an investment in unemployed people.
You will all be relieved to know that I have run out of time to continue reading the #Budget2021 papers. May your TL return to normal programming.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
2) The government has put a lot of spin on its woefully inadequate mental health, family violence and housing policies. But the fastest and most effective thing it could do RIGHT NOW to help people on all these fronts is increase payments to at least the Henderson poverty line.
A housing payment that funnels public money to landlords, is hard/impossible to access for 100s of 1000s of people on Centrelink & is a tiny fraction of our rent isn’t going to keep welfare recipients housed.
People on JobSeeker who have a mortgage – yes, they exist – don’t get CRA. Pitiful as it is, for some $70 is the difference between paying mortgage or not. Older women in particular have been forced to sell their home, but hey, at least they can qualify for rent assistance then!
CRA is not available to people who don’t already have a lease. For many, this means they can’t secure a rental at all, and therefore apparently “don’t need” rent assistance. For others, they might be paying rent but not have a lease.
Watching estimates ... so Ray Griggs from the Department of Social Services doesn't know that NDIS recipients are NOT a subset of of DSP recipients 🤦
More than 9000 people have exited the #CashlessDebitCard in the first month since they've been eligible to do it ... that's 73% of the people who are allowed.
55 people have said they want to continue on a voluntary basis.
55.
you think to yourself "gee the labor party are pathetic" and then you see slade brockman and jacinta price in senate estimates and think "fuck that's right you can be worse than the labor party and we are all fucking doomed"
It seems @RedCrossAU have chosen to appear at the hearing about the #CashlessDebitCard repeal bill to make a lengthy pitch for … further funding for Red Cross.
Non-profit industrial complex get in the fucking bin.
Now they’re saying people in community should decide what happens with cashless welfare, except people who DON’T “volunteer” for cashless welfare should have to be “helped” (presumably by Red Cross) with paternalistic services that assume none of them can manage their own life.
“Community consent” is the basis on which the Coalition politicians who introduced the Cashless Debit Card in 2015 and the Labor politicians who voted for it have always justified the program.
The charade that must be maintained is that CDC isn’t just another form of colonial violence inflicted through another racist welfare experiment, but is instead a self-determined response to challenges faced as a result of harms caused by generations of genocide & dispossession.
Responding to @Malarndirri19 during the Dec 2020 senate debate on making CDC permanent, @Anne_Ruston claimed she'd "consulted" on changes to the bill in the preceding 24 hours, but couldn't recall who with 🤔
If you speak to actual experts – people living on unemployment payments – instead of using obscure studies from Brazil bearing no relationship to our lives, you'll know the welfare system directly causes psychological harm & disability.
It "leaves us behind."
From the article:
Following work from @AusMHThinkTank, @MTeesson said “the first and most decisive action the government could take” to address the alarming increase in psychological harm is to return to 2020 unemployment payment levels, when they were at the poverty line. theguardian.com/australia-news…