What so many who interrogate American Jews about their Israel views do not get is that most American Jews do not think much about Israel, because they are *Americans* with American concerns who do not define themselves by what's happening somewhere thousands of miles away.
On the right, there's a perpetual effort to assail American Jews for supporting "anti-Israel" Democrats. On the left, there's a perpetual effort to make American Jews in progressive spaces answer for Israel. These are both racist constructs that collapse all Jews into a monolith.
https://twitter.com/Yair_Rosenberg/status/1392846399872684035
Like every American minority, American Jews are Americans. They spend most of their time thinking and worrying about the same things as other Americans in their social and political class. They are not cut-outs for whatever Israelis or Israel politics you support or oppose.
https://twitter.com/Yair_Rosenberg/status/1392848209387692036
People do the exact same thing to Muslims as they do to Jews: attack them and hold them to account for acts of completely different co-religionists thousands of miles away in the Middle East. This is textbook bigotry and yet distressingly common even in "enlightened" spaces.
https://twitter.com/deepnhearttx/status/1392851878233448449
Given my journalistic profession and personal inclinations, I am one of those American Jews who thinks a lot about Israel. But I try to explain to audiences that I am unusual in this regard. Like most Americans, most American Jews have enough to worry about in their own lives.
https://twitter.com/Yair_Rosenberg/status/1392846399872684035
The replies and retweets here are a mix of Jews affirming this statement from experience, and non-Jewish partisans insisting *their* side doesn't do this. Trust me, it does. Talk to some Jewish people! Some of us have been fortunate not to experience this, but others, less so.
https://twitter.com/Yair_Rosenberg/status/1392848209387692036
So many folks from other minority communities responding to this thread sharing similar experiences. Whether you are held collectively accountable for people who look/seem like you overseas is one of the dividing lines between being in the majority and being a minority.
https://twitter.com/mahal_mt/status/1392937348837478400
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
