Check out the full discussion of Critical Race Theory between @wu_wenyuan and me, hosted by @jamiljivani. Thread incoming! 🧵
Link didn’t copy; here it is: iheartradio.ca/newstalk-1010/… starting at around 10:14
Jamil introduces us and kicks off the discussion by asking us to define CRT.

Dr. Wu: CRT is "a subschool of political thought that has its academic roots in theories such as Marxism, Neo-Marxism, the Frankfurt School, radical feminism, critical theory, and postmodernism."
Note that no specific commitments of CRT have been identified!

I identify one: the impact of race on the world as we know it has been massive, we still feel its effects, and this has important implications; we must interrogate the entanglements of race and power in society.
Next we move on to the "Ban-CRT-Bills." Jamil asks, "Why is it so controversial that these sorts of actions are being taken against CRT in the US?"

Wu: "In my opinion, [CRT] is a very narrow framework to examine our social relations and our policies."

But WHAT IS THE FRAMEWORK?
Dr. Wu goes on, talks about a racism witch hunt and EDI trainings, but she never articulates what these CRT or CRT-infused/informed assumptions are that are supposed to be so dangerous they must be legally prohibited from classrooms.
When Jamil asks me why I think CRT has become so controversial, I have to explain the disinformation campaign that has made this possible. Chris Rufo and James Lindsay are intentionally--and quite transparently and shamelessly--poisoning the well, and thus CRT has become toxic.
Here are receipts for my comments about the organization of which Dr. Wu is the executive director. These are from the booklet they recently published on their website (cferfoundation.org/wp-content/upl…) -- which I will certainly be talking more about on my Substack soon.
Jamil then asks us about the #Loudouncounty parent who went viral...

Hitler and the KKK aside, let me just point out the glorious hypocrisy in her insistence that people be treated w/ colorblindness while she shouts "You cannot tell me what is or is not racist. LOOK AT ME!!!"
When Jamil asks me for my take, all I can really do is reiterate how influential the right-wing propaganda machine is, and note that this new moral panic is really just the same old dance in newer clothes.
And here is how the interview concludes. I hope @jamiljivani does decide to invite @wu_wenyuan and me back on the show to discuss in further detail soon; I think the debate we had demonstrates that it's a topic worth diving deeper into and does require long-form discussion.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with ⚒ Sam Hoadley-Brill ⚒

⚒ Sam Hoadley-Brill ⚒ Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @deonteleologist

11 May
I used to hold @cvaldary to a higher standard than many anti-CRT voices in the culture war, and I'm afraid I can't say that's true anymore.

This article is flooded with falsehoods from the first sentence, which identifies CRT as "a social science."
newsweek.com/black-people-a…
Valdary claims CRT "has been popularized by people like Ibrahim [sic] X. Kendi and Robin DiAngelo" & that in practice CRT has manifested as "demonization of white students." It's clear from the framing she means K-12; I'd love to know which curricula include law review articles.
Valdary thinks the most fundamental problem with CRT is deeper still: "It stems from a fundamental misunderstanding of the complexities of our social and political realities, reducing them to a single factor: racism."

I am unaware of any CRT scholar ever doing any such thing.
Read 5 tweets
6 May
I recently stumbled upon this panel on the topic of Critical Race Theory (what else?) hosted by The Manhattan Institute and was shocked by the lineup. Why the hell was Chris Rufo in the same conversation as Harvard Law professor Randall Kennedy?!?!

What I saw blew me away. 🧵
For folks who don't know, Randall Kennedy was the first scholar to publish a full-throated critique of CRT. He and Derrick Bell were colleagues at Harvard for some time. Bell took his criticism seriously, but also noted how politically damaging it was to the movement:
The first 45 min of this "panel" consisted of @jasonrileywsj & @JohnHMcWhorter casually shooting the shit about how bad CRT is. When Prof. Kennedy was introduced, I was expecting more of the same. To my pleasant surprise, however, the conversation was turned entirely on its head.
Read 14 tweets
6 May
Since they can’t identify, point by point, where my debunking of James on CRT goes wrong, the noble knights dedicated to preserving the scholarly reputation of Jimmy Concepts have decided to attempt to influence potential readers via a coup of the comment section.
“Surely he was raised by lesbians in a privileged intellectual silo. And b4 Sam thinks this is from some anon homophobic account and uses it to further his twitterversies I'm gay as fuck and have a lesbian mom.”

Most convincing thing I’ve ever read, tbh
Is it just me or do all these comments and names have too much in common for them to all be from different people?

Clearly I’ve struck a nerve, either way. It seems some people are very invested in getting me to stop exposing James’ fraudulent bullshit. Gonna have to do better.
Read 5 tweets
26 Apr
I am struggling to focus on my coursework because I keep thinking about the conservative media's engineered CRT panic based almost entirely on a total lack of respect for racially oppressed groups and a total disregard for reality.

So: a thread illustrating a prime example. 1/9
This is an article by Chris Rufo. It is one of *fifteen* he has released on CRT in the past 4 months. It's average for him in terms of its spin, dishonesty, sophistry; Rufo always plays no defense, only offense. But this article is far from his worst. city-journal.org/philadelphia-f… 2/9
It opens with strong accusations. As we know from Hitler & Goebbels, nothing scares the masses more than a racialized Other engaged in a communist plot to destroy society. They don't want their children to "praise" or "celebrate" those thugs--or worse, to praise communism. 3/9
Read 9 tweets
8 Apr
I thought this preview was bad. Then I listened to the entire interview. This might be the worst single interview from any of the Grievance Hoaxers, and I have put myself through a mortifying amount of content from these people. Let me set out the highlights briefly [1/n]
Here's Peter claiming all teaching programs in the US "participate in some variant of CRT or the Woke ideology..." in ways that lead K-12 teachers not to form beliefs based on evidence, to be unwilling to revise beliefs, to have no semblance of rationality. I have no words. [2/n]
Mask all the way off, he praises the Strongman Fascist Dictator model of addressing the problem of Wokeness, namedropping Viktor Orbán and saying his method is the only way because things like peer review and reason aren't used in Studies departments. (This is just false.) [3/n]
Read 10 tweets
4 Apr
Nice find from Martin Jay, pioneering historian of the Frankfurt School. The basic subtext of the neo-Nazi conspiracy theory that passes through the mainstream as "Cultural Marxism"
Jesus Christ. First I am hearing of this, also in Jay's most recent book. A Trump aide in the NSC wrote an unhinged memo claiming Cultural Marxism is "the dominant cultural meme," adhered to by "‘deep state’ actors, globalists, bankers, Islamists, and establishment Republicans."
Some screenshots from the memo. Literally invokes the notion of some "cabal" pulling all the political strings, trying to "destroy" Trump.
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(