1/ I spent most of this week in DC meeting with members of Congress and heads of various federal agencies, along with @RonConway@katie_haun and @iampaulgrewal.
2/ Goal was to establish relationships and help answer questions about crypto. And to see what we can do to help the U.S. get more regulatory clarity in this space, as part of the newly formed @crypto_council.
3/ Crypto is as important as the birth of the internet in terms of the jobs, GDP growth, and innovation it can create. The U.S. will need to be a major player in crypto to stay relevant long term.
4/ The reactions ranged from very positive (those who see enormous potential) like @SenatorSinema and @PatrickMcHenry, to admitted skeptics who asked thoughtful questions about illicit activity and I think left with a much more open mind like @MarkWarner, and everyone in between.
5/ The politicians and agency heads I met with were all thoughtful and committed individuals, and I was happy to have our teams connected, and new friendships formed.
6/ There is not a ton of regulatory clarity today in the U.S. because crypto is not just one thing. Some cryptos might be securities (SEC), some are commodities (CFTC), some are currencies/property (Treasury/IRS), and some are none of the above.
7/ So it's a bit of a jump ball across existing federal regulators, and this means fewer startups who are able to brave the legal uncertainty. Some of them wind up founding their companies abroad, or not at all. This is a major problem.
8/ Coinbase is big enough to afford the legal costs, and we’ve proactively created our own self regulatory frameworks when needed (for example cryptoratingcouncil.com). Smaller crypto startups are more harmed because they can't always afford it early on.
9/ One of my biggest takeaways is that the U.S. could really use a safe harbor/sandbox for crypto startups to get off the ground, before having to grapple with these issues. This would go a long way, and give the SEC/CFTC/Treasury/etc a common framework to follow.
10/ Also, a signal from the current administration that crypto companies are welcome in the U.S. would go a long way.
11/ Credit to @FEhrsam and @crypto_council for finding this gem - but watch this amazing video of the Al Gore and the Clinton administration announcing the Electronic Commerce Initiative in 1997
12/ Al Gore outlines the government's role to "first do no harm", to applause, and sets the stage for a safe industry with appropriate consumer protection. Think about the downstream effects we have today of this signal they sent to the market.
13/ Side note: great example of why government is best suited to set the legal and policy frameworks, but not try to pick winners. The two companies they chose to represent the future of the internet were IBM and another one I haven't heard of!
14/ I also relayed my thoughts on China and their central bank digital currency. It is real, they are moving quickly on it, and I believe it represents a threat to U.S. reserve currency status long term if the U.S. doesn't move quickly to create their own.
15/ Coinbase provides services to customers in over 100 countries around the world, and we're seeking to speak with policy makers everywhere. But our parent company is based in the U.S. and I'd love to see the U.S. embrace the exciting use cases of this new industry.
16/ Including banking the unbanked (and underbanked), which crypto has the potential to do (especially self-hosted wallets).
17/ Coinbase stands ready to help as a resource for all those who would like to learn more about crypto, and help drive toward regulatory clarity, and innovation.
18/ Here are a few fun photos - I only got permission to post a few (there were a lot more meetings where I didn't!). Btw Coinbase is committed to being bipartisan in any policy efforts.
21/ The U.S. is at a critical juncture in making holistic decisions around cryptocurrency. Imagine the U.S. without the internet. If you’re a policymaker interested in learning more, reach out to: info@cryptoforinnovation.org
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
9 years ago today, I founded Coinbase. One of the most important lessons I come back after all this time is long-term focus.
I’m grateful to see how far crypto has come since Coinbase was founded. Hard to imagine that only 9 years later we would see crypto regularly discussed by Presidents, Saturday Night Live hosts, and Tom Brady. Or that it would show up in songs by Nas.
It’s tempting to get caught up in the excitement of the current moment, but the truth is there have been many ups and downs of the 9 years.
The idea wasn’t perfect (I misjudged the merchant angle for instance, simple buy/sell turned out to be more lucrative).
But...
...highlights the importance of resilience and ignoring haters when trying to build something new. Nine out of ten people will think it’s a terrible idea, and be quite articulate explaining why this is to you. This will go on for YEARs.
Even after five years and many millions of dollars in revenue, I would say still about 50% of people (investors, prospective employees, etc) I spoke to thought it was a bad idea.
1/ Today is a big moment for @coinbase as we become a public company. But it’s also a big one for crypto. This all started with the Bitcoin whitepaper 12 years ago, a deceptively simple 9 page document by Satoshi Nakamoto that ignited a global movement. bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf
2/ The Coinbase journey started when I read the Satoshi whitepaper while I was home for Thanksgiving in 2010. As I read it, I realized that crypto had the power to unlock a future where economic freedom was a reality for everyone.
3/ This has driven me ever since as I believe creating more economic freedom is one of the biggest meta problems of our time. It has so many positive downstream effects in society. blog.coinbase.com/how-digital-cu…
1/ Over the next few days I'll be releasing some electronic music that I created with DJ DAVI (David Khanjian). We'll be releasing them as NFTs.
2/ I listened to a lot of electronic music with no vocals as I was coding up the early versions of Coinbase, and always enjoyed David's music. (no vocals because I couldn't concentrate with other words in my head)
3/ Last year during COVID I decided I wanted to learn a little bit of electronic music composition as a hobby (I do something like this each year), and David was kind enough to take me under his wing and give me some free music lessons.
2/ We want to work with tech-forward countries who are pro-crypto and can move fast
3/ Things that would help: connect us with key decision makers, countries who can help us fast track a license and bank partnership, and help us get crypto into the hands of their citizens through advocacy and marketing
And it is showing up on Substack!
Mainstream media is missing out on these stories.
There are so many exciting stories to tell in technology. Mainstream media serves an important function in society holding functions accountable, but when the entire incentive system is build on who can tear something down, there are great stories that will be missed.
Not to mention the inherent conflict, working in an industry that was disrupted by tech. We wouldn't ask Pepsi for an unbiased review of Coke, and we can't ask mainstream media for an unbiased review of tech.