Stop equating all Palestinians w/ Hamas. This isn't accurate, first of all, and, second, Hamas has killed Palestinian civilians (including children) in this recent cross-fire as well.
Understanding this is the right thing to do for the Palestinian people. It also adds context to 1. Israel's choice of targets & 2. Hamas' decision to have military areas in civilian areas. Both 1 & 2 are bad and lead to many dead Palestinians.
If you care about civilian life, neither Israel or Hamas should be firing where they are firing. Both are either showing lack of care over civilian casualties or using casualties as a method of war (which is a war crime)
Even if you have a strong stance on Israel's "right"-to-defense, you should consider that Hamas /= to all Palestinians. Even if you have a strong stance on Hamas's "right" to strike, you should consider that they have placed their own military operations in populated areas.
It's important to recognize that Hamas has not shown care towards Palestinian civilians. Israel shouldn't be targeting areas w/ civilians in any case. &, when they do so, the death toll is unlikely to influence Hamas's actions. It will just be endless counter-striking.
Civilian deaths should always be avoided in warfare. Sometimes governments take the strategic--but very immoral--decision of targeting civilians to drive the other side into submission. In this case, this isn't just immoral, but the strategy won't work. Hamas doesn't care.
I am deeply concerned about the Palestinian death toll. I will also say that we should be concerned about Hamas firing on Israel civilians, too. No matter how you feel about the Israeli gov't, you should universally care about all civilians. No human should be a method of war

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Mangy Jay

Mangy Jay Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @magi_jay

16 May
One can say that the Israel gov't has enacted apartheid w/out stipulating that the state of Israel should be destroyed. There are many oppressive states in the world & the focus should be on reforming them, not destroying them & leaving citizens stateless, the pathway of genocide
Unfortunately, rampant anti-semitism has made it much more difficult to criticize Israel, such that, if one says they have engaged in apartheid, the inference is that the state should be destroyed, given that is what so many on the left argue. We need to decouple these things.
India is a oppressive state. So is Pakistan. And Chechnya. Yet we never let criticism of these states coincide with conversations about their destruction. We would never argue that the oppressive acts of factions w/in the states should leave all the citizens stateless.
Read 7 tweets
15 May
This is a really important piece by the @nytimes, in which they identify cases in which the sickle cell trait was used to explain the death of Black Americans in police custody. Note the sickle cell trait was also invoked in Chauvin's defense over the murder of George Floyd.
This research reflects a broader pattern in American culture wherein Black people are viewed as both so strong they must be restrained w/ extraordinary measures, but then their own health is blamed when they suffer. Here is my previous piece about this
This is not so disconnected from how we blamed Black people for being particularly susceptible to COVID. In white American society, Black people must be restrained & controlled. We also view their own health as a causal factor in their sufferings.
Read 7 tweets
14 May
Yes, Betty White is older than the official state of Israel. She was born in 1922, which would have put her in her early 20's when 6 million Jews were murdered and those who survived the genocide returned to countries & found their homes stolen before many were murdered some more Image
None of this justifies the current actions of the Israeli government or many of the state's actions since it was founded. But the argument over Israel's "right to exist" is ridiculous. The state exists. If you are concerned about Palestinians, fight for them to have a state too.
The age of Israel doesn't matter. The Israeli state could be 1000s of years old and 1. their current actions would still be wrong & 2. the Palestinian people would still have a right to their own self-governance. Fight *for* the Palestinians, not against Holocaust survivors.
Read 5 tweets
14 May
They know that the damn is going to start to leak & some unvaccinated people will stop wearing masks. However, that has fewer consequences w/ 45% of adults vaccinated than 10% of adults vaccinated. 45% could still be too early, but that's the calculation.
Also, again, this is likely informed by new info on mucosal antibodies in nasal/oral cavities post-mrna vaccine. Previously, it was assumed that vaccinated people prob couldn't transmit much, but it was still a theoretical possibility that virus could survive in nasal cavities
Now, it hasn't been proven that there is no way for virus to survive or to be transmitted by vaccinated people through, say, nasal expulsions (sneezing). However, the presence of mucosal anti-bodies means the body has capacity to fight virus in nasal/oral regions
Read 8 tweets
14 May
So I've seen a few accounts say that the Biden admin supports what's being done to the Palestinians and I think that's not the whole story. Before the current escalation, the U.S. was condemning Israel for evictions in East Jerusalem. Netanyahu ignored it.
Now, is the U.S. currently doing enough? Probably not. But they did speak out against the evictions in East Jerusalem and we should 1. support them in this cause & 2. push them to go further. Saying they support the actions is false and helps no one.
Let's develop a coherent policy message for what the U.S. can do right now. They are opposed to the actions in East Jerusalem. How do we make this into a singular message? Misrepresentation does nothing.
Read 5 tweets
13 May
I don't really care about Glem, but, since I see others make this mistake all the time, let me say: this is not how racism or sexism work. You cannot just say people liked one Black person or one woman once and therefore their brains are free from racism or sexism
There are at least two interrelated phenomena here. Men can approve of some women, but disapprove of others for reasons that arise from sexism. Think: cool girl syndrome. Same thing for white people vis a vis Black people. "Oh, well he's a *different* kind of Black man."
The other thing that both women & POC experience is that even if they are "accepted" for a while, they get rejected more and more over time. This is especially true if they ascend to positions of power, which is 1 reason why Obama's 2009 approval devolved into the 2010 midterms
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(