Toolkit status after 60 hours - Thread

On 18th morning, screenshots of two documents went viral, and was claimed to be a Congress 'toolkit'. Many top leaders of BJP shared these screenshots and accused Congress of trying to make political capital out of a pandemic.

1/n
This 'toolkit' came about at a time when the Modi govt had been criticised from all quarters, including some of their own leaders, for their failures, which has led to the deaths of thousands of Indians, deaths that were completely avoidable.

2/n
Since these were screenshots of documents, that inherently meant that the authenticity of these documents could not be determined without access to original documents. However, that did not deter mainstream media from making this a prime time talking point.

3/n
The document that was the basis of all outrage was titled, "Cornering Narendra Modi & BJP on COVID Management".

The other document was titled, "Central Vista Redevelopment: Vanity Project Amidst the Pandemic".

8 screenshots were shared on social media, 4 of each doc.

4/n
For the purpose of this thread, the first document will be referred to as the 'toolkit' document, whereas the second document will be referred to as the 'vista' document.

5/n
On 19th morning, many in BJP started sharing the file properties of one of the docs. The file name suggests that this was of the 'vista' document. The properties can be seen if one has physical access to the doc, or someone who has physical access sends this information.

6/n
At this point, it was clear that at least someone in BJP had access to a pdf copy of the 'vista' document. Alt News was also able to get access to this said document through @rajeevgowda, and the file properties match the version shared by BJP members.

7/n
The PDF copy of the 'vista' document can be accessed at the following link:

altnews.in/wp-content/upl…

@rajeevgowda, who heads AICC research wing, told @AltNews that this is a genuine document, a PDF version of which was shared internally within Congress on May 7th.

8/n
After 60 hours of the screenshots of two docs initially appearing on social media (SM), and 36 hours of the file properties of the 'vista' document being shared on SM, there's still NO trace of the specifics of the 'toolkit' doc. Congress has termed the 'toolkit' doc as fake.
9/n
It is this 'toolkit' document which was the basis of all the outrage, so why hasn't BJP shared the original document yet, thus enabling mainstream media and BJP IT cell to plaster it all over, so people at least momentarily will get distracted from the pandemic?

10/n
The reason of this delay is probably because the 'toolkit' document, the reason for all outrage, was manufactured by someone on a forged letterhead. When @AltNews analyzed the screenshots of the two documents and the original 'vista' doc, the letterheads did not match.

11/n
@rajeevgowda also shared with @AltNews another doc created by the AICC research wing, besides the 'vista' document. When we compared these two original docs with the 'toolkit' screenshots, it was found that the header and footer of the toolkit doc did not match the others.

12/n
The other thing that stood out was that a lot of the 'organised propaganda' that Congress was accused of had already happened in April 2021, while this document was created for May 2021. [Check the dates highlighted with boxes]

13/n
The very idea of a toolkit is to dictate a future course of action. So why was this 'toolkit' document suggesting propaganda that was already carried out in the past?

14/n
The longer those who created the 'toolkit' document take to put out the original 'toolkit' document in public domain for forensic analysis, the more it would seem like this 'toolkit' document was manufactured as a distraction.

15/n
Of course, if this was indeed manufactured, then we can totally expect the mainstream media to zip up, and not question as to why such a nefarious strategy was adopted when thousands are dying everyday. Let's wait and watch.

16/n
The complete analysis of the documents, and how @AltNews concluded that the letterhead of the toolkit was forged can be read below:

English: altnews.in/covid-toolkit-…

Hindi: altnews.in/hindi/covid-to…

n/n

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Pratik Sinha

Pratik Sinha Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @free_thinker

21 May
While many are rejoicing Twitter marking posts of BJP leaders as 'Manipulated Media', and others are accusing Twitter of bias, I think we must all pause and reflect on this policy.

{Thread}
Why has Twitter decided to mark those particular posts as 'Manipulated Media'? - That is the question any user will have when they see that tag, but there's no answer to it. How did Twitter determine? Have they provided a reference to their findings for their users?
Fact-checkers debunk misinformation, on all sides of the ideological spectrum, every single day, and very often of the kind where original media has been manipulated. Twitter doesn't mark those as 'Manipulated media'.
Read 5 tweets
19 May
Rahul Roushan runs a rather popular portal and has a significant following on Twitter, but still continues to depend on these proxy accounts.
What was this account @totalwoke called till a while ago? - @MyFakingNews
Who used to run @MyFakingNews?
Read 4 tweets
19 May
In the latest toolkit episode, screenshots of two documents were shared initially by the Twitter handle @Teambharat_. One was titled, "Cornering Narendra Modi & BJP on COVID Management". Other was titled, "Central Vista Redevelopment: Vanity Project Amidst the Pandemic". 1/n
While the claim by BJP is that both the documents have been created by Congress, certain discrepancies in the 'COVID Management' document show that the document is not genuine. The primary issue is that letterheads used do not match. 2/n
Anyone who has used Microsoft Word and has created template docs would know that the header & footer section do not auto-magically change unless they're manually edited or created anew. In this case, clear differences can be seen in the header and footer of the two documents. 3/n
Read 9 tweets
1 Feb
[Thread] Twitter had earlier claimed that it had shut accounts which had asked for a repeat of 1984. I did a quick search and found tens of accounts which had used the phrase 'repeat 1984' that are still active and merrily tweeting away.
How easy it is to find these tweets? Check the search query in the screenshot. You enter that query that I have used => 'repeat 1984 until:2021-1-27' into the Twitter search box, and then go to the 'Latest' tab (arrow).
If it is this easy to find these tweets, how is that @TwitterIndia hasn't found these tweets?

Set 1.
Read 6 tweets
17 Jun 20
Thread:

After 14 months of the Pulwama attack, we still don't know who's been held accountable for the death of 40 CRPF personnel. We haven't been told how 300 kilos of explosives were sourced and transported. Who leaked the route that CRPF convoy was going to take? No answers.
The media doesn't ask these questions despite all the claims of putting 'Nation first'. That's because for them, 'Nation first' = 'Government first'. Those who ask these questions are declared anti-national, and rest will wait for a figure of how many of 'theirs' could we kill.
Eventually, a friendly news agency will quote 'sources' and put out some figure of the number 'we' killed, and it will be diligently broadcasted by every media org, again without any questions asked. In case of Balakot, till date we haven't seen a single image of the 300 dead.
Read 5 tweets
3 Jun 20
He's a columnist at @ThePrintIndia. Talks about flashing at mothers and spitting on them. A proud moment for the investors, owners and employees of @ThePrintIndia, who continue their association with this individual without protest.
He also appears regularly on channels like @IndiaToday, @republic and @TimesNow. I have very little hope in Indian TV channels making any amends because these channels are beyond shaming.
However, I do intend to shame every organisation who chooses to give space to this individual at every opportunity I get, and let your audience know that this is your choice.
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(