What victory is Hamas claiming?
Arab life remains to a large extent a life captivated by symbols and politics are not an exception. Arab politics is the arena of intense struggle and conflict over symbols due to the symbols of the high power hold. Major conflicts over who /1
represents the abstractions of Arabness, Islam, Honor, etc. are not an exception. The Muslim Brotherhood is an entire political project with absolutely no substance but symbols. Hamas is no different and is engaging in symbol-hoarding and symbol-accumulation. Their ability to /2
start a war with Israel and come out is that symbolic victory. This is why the destruction and the deaths count does not matter, if anything they add to that symbolic power. There is a brilliant scene in the 2014 Israeli movie Bethlehem in which 2 Palestinian terrorist groups /3
are having a standoff in the morgue over who can claim the body of a martyr. The reason for such a standoff is that the "martyr" is of significant symbolic value which makes the standoff is basically over finite resources. Every seemingly senseless attack on Israel is basically/4
a symbol-generating process. Think about how Muslims get angry over cartoons. It's a world of symbols through and through. The reason so-called experts and foreign policy professionals are systematically wrong is that they are not smart enough for this. Moreover, their /5
education and training is exactly the wrong kind of education to understand any of this.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Hussein Aboubakr Mansour

Hussein Aboubakr Mansour Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @HusseinAboubak

24 May
Arab Culture and Violence
Why the ME clearly seems to have a high propensity for violence why the violence so brutal and cruel? There are many reasons, one of them is culture. Arab culture lacks many tools for conflict resolution aside from violence due to various issues. The /1
lack of peaceful conflict resolution mechanism coincided with modernity in its effect of democratizing claim-making and politicizing wide segments of human populations hitherto never politicized, creating significantly more conflict of interests. This made means of coercion /2
to become more central culturally. Using violence and coercion is naturally however not the first line of action when resolution is not possible. Threat and fear are first used in order to prevent violence. This is why, for example, many punishments are performed in public, /3
Read 7 tweets
24 May
Prior to the mid 50s, Egyptian leaders and intellectuals were not interested in Arab Nationalism, and most Egyptians had never heard of it. Arab Nationalists from the Levant were very frustrated with the Egyptians home they had to drag to Arab conferences and only participate /1
As observers. In the mid 50s Nasser of Egypt accepted a bribe in the form of a promise to turn Egypt to the "Germany" of the Arabs with permanent status of leadership in exchange of bringing Egypt to Arab Nationalism. The venture failed, Egypt paid the price and got nothing /2
This left Egyptians with one of the most severe narcissistic injuries in the ME due to loss of status and a failed investment. The entire venture left Egypt indeed like Germany of the Arabs, but in the negative sense. Egyptian culture, not policies, remain a very negative /3
Read 4 tweets
18 May
Many in the media, including anti-Isreal bigots, are whimpering about how Palestinians are dehumanized. The thing is, they are right! When you are told that your body is a bullet to be shot against the Zionists, that is dehumanizing. When you are told that they best thing you /1
can do with your life is to die for land or for AlAqsa, that is dehumanizing. When you are told you should go by a 5 shekel knife and go stab Jews and its okay if you die trying that is dehumanizing. When you are used as a human shield, that is dehumanizing. When you are used /2
as another casualty number in order to agitate public opinion against Israel that is dehumanizing. When your life is sacrificed on your behalf by terrorists for the sake of the glorious cause, that is dehumanizing. But no, we don't hear much about that. The bigotry is /3
Read 4 tweets
12 Mar
With all the good things coming out of the Gulf, its important to understand there are still a crucial problem for thr Gulf to solve, the indigenouization of skills. The Gulf has impressive infrastructure, made, maintained, and managed by foreign skill and Indian programmers
The native skills are mostly concentrated in finance and real estate. The educational efforts of importing American campuses is yet to show results. The reasons this issue is so difficult to overcome are very complex and don't give in to quick solutions. However, if there is a
country that shows the potential for the kind of human capital needed for information based economies, it is actually, no kidding, Saudi Arabia. Most of my life, I, like many, resented the Kingdom for reasons that are well known and no need to restate them. But things have
Read 4 tweets
8 Mar
One of the things that is hard for me to explain, even to many Zionists, is that the Palestinian cause was never about Palestine at all, it was always about other major struggles for power in the regions. The words that can describe Arab politics best for the 20th cent
is "crisis of legitimacy," questions of who is to have power, why, and to what end WERE THE QUESTIONS. Nothing else existed. Coups, civil wars, assassinations, militias, and a metaphorical jungle of prime chimp power competition. Palestine was the only tool in the Arab
political toolbox to circumvent those questions. If you wanted power, the only legitimacy you could find was Palestine. It was the only thing that let you carry arms, come in over tanks, and grab all the power your tormented soul is lusting for. Nasser, the Baath, PLO, PLFP, Amal
Read 5 tweets
7 Mar
There is a major process going on in the Middle East right now to which most western observers are completely blind. There is a major multi dimensional process of identity and social structure reconfiguration. All over the region, people are starting to play with most intimate
things, faith, identity, and sex. Individuation on multiple levels, national identities are breaking off of pan identities, Individual identities breaking off of collective ones, and new think breaking off of group think. Its happening at home, on the street, in institutions,
and on national levels. 15 years ago I prefered to read and listen to western conversations because Arabs had nothing interesting to talk about. Today, without exaggeration, its the complete opposite for me. Even SAUDI podcasts are far more interesting than American ones
Read 8 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(