A thread about NVT, one of the first on-chain signals first published in Feb 2017.
This is a 2021 re-hash of my NVT learnings since then.
"How to use on-chain volume to establish a fundamental valuation for Bitcoin."
Ever seen this chart of BTC's on-chain volume vs its market cap and wondered why they track so closely?
On-chain volume measures the amount of money moving between investors as seen on the blockchain per day. It's highly correlated to market cap.
But why?
Let's lay down a first principles equation for a pure store of value network:
value moving between investors = value of the network * how much the money supply churns
In short form:
I = M * V
where:
I = Value moving between investors
M = Market Cap
V = Monetary Velocity
I = M * V
In other words:
M = I * (1/V)
Market cap should fundamentally be proportional to the volume moving between investors.
The co-efficient of proportionality is inverse monetary velocity.
Aha, that's why these 2 lines track each other.
Just like we can estimate the valuation of a company by looking at its earnings and multiplying by the expected PE Ratio for its category of company, we can do the same for Bitcoin... but instead of using PE Ratio and earnings, for Bitcoin we use NVT Ratio and investor volume.
I just introduced NVT Ratio.
NVT Ratio is inverse monetary velocity, the co-efficient of proportionality that we can multiple volume by to get market cap.
NVT oscillates around an imaginary mid-line. That mid-line is in effect the normal ratio that we should multiply volume by to get its valuation.
Oscillations below and above the middle region indicate the market is undervaluing or over valuing the network respectively.
Notice how NVT is drifting upwards? This is because not all of the investment volume has been accounted for, volume has been moving off the blockchain as exchange dominance increases.
We can actually see the dominance of exchanges increase in big jumps since 2017.
Exchange user count data via surveys by @CambridgeAltFin, while on-chain user count via forensic clustering of BTC addresses by @glassnode.
Putting it all together. We run a 2 year moving median of NVT Ratio, that gets us an estimate of the mid-line value also accounting for the drift upwards due to the missing exchange activity. Multiply this by the on-chain volume, and we get a fundamental network valuation.
Fun fact, this article was originally published in Forbes. @laurashin was the crypto editor there at the time and she approached me to write for them. I never did continue. Not long after, she went on to launch her amazing podcast.
How can $MSTR possibly trade at 2.7x their BTC treasury?
I suspect we are seeing the start of $5-10b of inflows in anticipation of a SP500 listing right now.
If true, then it's still warming up.
Consider 20-30% of the SP500's $50T marketcap comes from passive index tracking funds and ETFs.
Inclusion into the SP500 means MSTR gets a chunk of that money.
Inflow estimates:
$10-15b from passive index tracker funds
$5-10b additional from speculative inflows
When would it happen?
FASB accounting practices go live for MSTR on 1st Jan 2025, that's a prerequisite before a listing can take place. After that MSTR will meet most of the requirements, with the last requirement being a committee decision.
Until the start of Aug, we've been in a bearish stance with an influx of 100k coins (Germany, MtGox, DOJ) while speculation has been rife creating more paper BTC.
The price crash during the start of Aug flushed out much of the paper with a nice round of liquidations... open interest got wiped.
That's a healthy reset of open value (paper bets). It's really hard for BTC to climb when there's overheated speculation in the market.
This mid-June assessment is still in play.
BTC price action needs to get really boring.
I feel like we are 66% the way there. Much of the speculation has left, we still need more of the spot BTC to be absorbed.
Here's the 5 macro signals I'm looking closely at right now for #Bitcoin.
3 bullish, 2 bearish...
Miners capitulation is over, it's one of the most reliable bullish indicators.
Hash rate is recovering, the price and hash rate bottom coincided with upgrades to next gen hardware hitting the network.
M66s went live last week.
S21 Pros this week.
Hash rate set to scream.
Miner capitulation is a very responsive indicator. The breakout was preluded with hash rate recovery; price responded within a day. I gave early warning of this.
When it kicks in we normally have months of bullishness.
I don't usually do short time frame price action as it's the domain of gamblers. But worth a break down of what's happening given the fear in the market...
We've been flushing out the leverage, 62.5k was the target to get most of it.
...speculators kept adding to new long positions, just adding more fuel for more liquidations in a cascading long squeeze.
Bridging us down to the 58k cluster, which just got taken out.
Superimposed on this liquidation squeeze, we have a post halving miners capitulation. Miners are on a BTC selling spree to pay for hardware upgrades due to the old hardware no longer being profitable. The weakest miners closing shop and being liquidated.