Can I be really honest on this thing for a second? I was one of those fools who thought getting a good paying job, having excellent credit, & being debt-free was the key to buying a home.
It's generational wealth, actually.
No millennial has earned $200,000 for a down payment.
I mean, maybe there are like 3 who have. But this kind of spending on home-buying that I see where I am?? A lot of this is generational wealth. Parents who can lend a kid $200,000 or even $800,000 to buy a house in cash, and then get paid off by a mortgage later.
What is a way to eliminate this for historically oppressed groups that were actively prevented from developing this kind of wealth (through either theft or discrimination)?
Well, there could be loans with excellent mortgage rates and a small (5% or less) down payment, for one.
Yes, these loans exist, but are generally more burdensome and restrictive, and make it far less likely a person without family wealth can use them to gain access into the exact kinds of communities that purposefully excluded them in the first place.
I mean, yes, the obvious answer here is reparations (I'm ready). But since this country is like a deadbeat dad that doesn't want to pay what they owe, then easier access for historically marginalized groups that can show a clear record of discrimination seems like a no-brainer.
Black folks are stolen and displaced people, whose labor was stolen and used to build up the wealth OF FAMILIES WHO STILL HAVE IT. We were actively prevented from buying property, given home loans, or just had it stolen like in Tulsa.
Fannie Mae can give us a good mortgage.
Btw, the good loans that don't require a huge down payment is the only reason I was able to purchase a home when the housing market was still bad enough for mortgage companies to have that kind of flexibility.
Know what they call those mortgages now?
"Doctor loans"
(I also feel obligated to add that we bought a small house that was one of the cheapest on the market bc we could still barely come up with the down payment and closing costs. But if it has simply been based on our ability to pay and credit, we could've gotten a bigger place.
If we had been able to get a more expensive place, similar to white peers making the same amount but with generational wealth, we would have a house with considerably more. Now that we have kids, we're effectively priced out because of this insane market.)
*considerably more space*
l
I'm adding to this thread because I want to be clear that I suggested the EASIEST and MINIMAL reparational approach to making the housing market more accessible. The government could pay the down payments for descendants of American slaves. It could give us zero interest loans.
The govt could cover our closing costs. My suggestion above is simply based on offering historically marginalized groups (housing discrimination hasn't only affected Black folks) access to products that banks ALREADY GIVE to "doctor" clients (who are, you guessed it,
disproportionately white).
The most hilarious thing about the responses to this thread are people living in states largely subsidized by the wealthiest areas of the country expressing disbelief and dismissiveness about how much it costs to live and purchase homes here.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
What exactly is the worst police department in America? On one hand Chicago police had a secret torture site. On the other hand cops in Ohio killed a Black woman in her own house while she held her infant. Then again, the entire police department of King City had to close down
because so many cops were arrested. But then New York cops raped a handcuffed man with a plunger IN a police station. Though Harris County cops in Texas physically "examined" a woman's vagina on camera for 11 minutes during a routine traffic stop. But then Boston cops covered for
an accused child rapist for years, promoted him, and made him their union president. Still, plainclothes cops in Hugo Oklahoma shot three Black children ages 5, 4, and a 1 year old baby in the head. Then again, DC cops shot unarmed Miriam Carey dead with her baby in the car.
I'm a dark-skinned natural hair "inner-city" Black girl with a single mom from the projects raised by folks who believed in me and loved on me.
And today I was promoted to Associate Professor with tenure.
There are so many folks to thank- mostly folks who made this possible - introduced me to an editor, called a friend at a journal, invited me to be on a panel, told me that my writing was great.
There were so many voices that said I couldn't, but theirs were stronger.
A big thanks goes to my advisor @johnljacksonjr who continues to teach me the importance of grace and generosity in this career. I owe you an untold debt :-) I hope to pay it forward.
The whole cancel culture thing is the biggest scam because I’m pretty sure Fox News and Breitbart invented the thing where you bring media attention to someone being critical of cops, wealthy people, or white people to get them fired or deluged by death threats.
Was Breitbart’s attack on the working people’s org ACORN not cancel culture? Fox and Breitbart’s attack on Black USDA official Shirley Sherrod wasn’t cancel culture? The regular bits where Tucker Carlson & friends secretly record and broadcast a professor criticizing whiteness?
The truth is the invention of reactionary ideological assaults and rhetoric using media in order to silence, humiliate, and destroy the careers or organizations of opposing political groups is basically the Fox News and conservative media public sphere’s entire racket.
My student is texting me, upset at what's happening. Wondering if it's hypocritical to want to see these guys laying siege to our government leaders treated like they treated protestors who marched in defense of of Black Lives.
Here's what I told her:
Be careful of false equivalences here.
Racism and anti-blackness means that Black people are always presumed to be dangerous, even when peaceful.
And white people are assumed to be peaceful, even when they are dangerous.
Right now, police officers are failing at keeping people safe and are protecting folks who've explicitly declared themselves to be targeting elected officials.
This is not the same as me walking a public street asking police to not kill my child.
Just learned my 63 year-old kind, gentle, much beloved uncle was still working at his Pepsi job through the pandemic bc his wife lost her job. He’s been there for over 30 years and didn’t want to lose his benefits.
He died of COVID-19 yesterday. 8 months shy of retirement.
This country’s abyssmal, unimaginable failure to control this virus has devastated millions and millions of Americans. Our country is being run by people who expect the worst, do the worst, and make us the worst of what we can be.
I am so angry. This is just one more horrific story in a horrific landscape but it matters. We cannot continue to let those at the top devour those of us at the bottom. We deserve better than this.