THREAD: Yesterday, @CarnegieEndow, @MilanV released their survey on Indian Americans. As a Hindu American advocacy group, we ask for clarity on a few important points.👇🏾 1/n
First off, the survey contains important on the 4 Million strong Indian American community, including everyday social realities, religious practices, attitudes towards civic and political engagement, social networks, etc. However... 2/n
In an unfortunate display of how colonial categories like “caste” continue to haunt long after the colonizers have departed, the survey attempts to query respondents -but only those self identifying as Hindu-on their “caste”. This defies logic...3/n
If Indian laws are a guide (appears to be the case here), we find hundreds of "castes" among the country’s Christians, Muslims and Sikhs. These categories are well defined in India among said communities, not just among the Hindus. 4/n ncbc.nic.in/user_panel/cen…
So, why this obsessive need to show Hinduism=Caste? This, even after admitting that OBC category is common among Muslims, while SC category is found among Buddhists, Sikhs, Christians and Muslims. 5/n
Also footnote 7 - "The term 'Dalit' refers to individuals who occupy the lowermost rungs of the traditional Hindu caste hierarchy." Unfortunately, this smells of bias against Hindus and Hinduism. Dalits also exist among Muslims, Christians, Sikhs, etc 6/n thehindu.com/news/cities/ch…
What’s a “traditional Hindu caste hierarchy?" "Caste" is a Portuguese word not found in ANY Hindu text. As Prof. Dirks wrote, British "caste" censuses forced thousands of jatis & groups into a "caste hierarchy" & then blamed Hindus for all problems. 7/n deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/hand…
What does “identifying with caste” mean? If Carnegie is interested in Hindu beliefs, the question should probe on Jati/ Varna/ Kula/ Gotra/ Shreni. Those are Hindu concepts, not “caste,” a racist, colonial import. A good reading list on our website - cohna.org/decolonize. 8/n
We then see Figures 27 and 28. While the institute finds it interesting to point out that "caste" discrimination is "an equal opportunity offense," (28), it also urges readers to exercise care in any "subgroup analysis" due to the small sample size (27)...9/n
...This is important, because only 5% of respondents reported experiencing any such discrimination over the past 12 months. So, take "caste discrimination" with a grain of salt. 10/n
And in Figures 19 & 21, we see two key observations - First, a quarter had NO knowledge of "caste" in their networks, while barely 21% of an already tiny group of self-selected respondents even think "caste" is an issue in formation of their social networks. 11/n
Nor is this affinity of like minded folks to cluster together an anomaly. A study in Aug 2020, showed similar results among social networks of different Christian religious groups within the US. See chart below. 12/n americansurveycenter.org/research/relig…
Finally, Footnote 29 punches a big hole into the false propaganda of Equality Labs' "Caste Survey" & their allies- asserts that it does not fully represent the South Asian American population, likely has skewed data, thus intensity of "caste discrimination" can be contested. 13/n
For #Hindus living in America, life changed a year ago as we woke up to the horror of #SB403. On March 22, @SenAishaWahab changed an innocuous ancestry bill to one that weaponized #caste, selectively singling out and profiling #Hinduism. 1/n
Ironically, we learnt about the changed bill from its #Hinduphobic co-sponsor #EqualityLabs. They shared the news in a press interview, BEFORE changes were even tabled in the #California Senate! Can there be stronger evidence of the #privilege & access this group enjoys? 2/n
Soon we'd see their raw hate for #Hinduism in an explosive @hinduoncampus video. The SB403 co-sponsor minced no words & spared nothing - #Yoga, #BhagavadGita, #Namaste, #Upanishads -nothing was safe. And California & @SenAishaWahab were ok with this 3/n
It's deeply disturbing to #HinduCanadians that publicly funded universities like @usask and @UofT would provide a platform to an openly #Hinduphobic individual, Mohammad Hijab. 1/n
As per @ncri_io's report on the Hinduphobic riots in Leicester, UK last year, Mohammad Hijab made derogatory comments about Hindus, saying: "If they (Hindus) believe in reincarnation, what a humiliation of them to be reincarnated into some pathetic, weak, cowardly people like that…I’d rather be reincarnated as a grasshopper." 2/n
He posted a photo on his Instagram, on the same day, where he was leading a mob; the photo was captioned: “Muslim patrol in Leicester”. 3/n
Delighted to see sanity prevail in #California. Thank you @GavinNewsom for vetoing #SB403. A victory for common sense, for American laws and a win for those who fought for #justice.” 1/n
Today is dedicated to the spirit of #MilindMakwana who will live on in our hearts for his dharma & sacrifice. 2/n
“This is a culmination of the efforts of the entire #HinduAmerican community, and the hundreds of organizations, temples, businesses, and allies that fought against #profiling. We rose above the lies, the insinuations, and the wild accusations - and we prevailed. Thank you! 🙏🏾3/n
Remember the case against @BAPS Hindu temple in 2021 that alleged "caste discrimination"?
#JUSTIN: A dozen artisans claim coercion, promise of US citizenship and large sums of money to testify against BAPS, are withdrawing the case.
In May 2021, a @nytimes article by @anniecorreal claimed "Hindu Sect Is Accused of Using Forced Labor to Build N.J. Temple" and that @BAPS "had exploited possibly hundreds of low-caste men in the yearslong construction project."
Two years later, this turned out to be a complete fabrication of events & attempt to defame the Hindu community.
In a letter filed July 13 in the Rajasthan High Court, the artisans stated that they were "pressured to join as plaintiffs in a civil complain in New Jersey court."
#BREAKING: 🧵A day of mixed emotions for the CoHNA family today. We are disappointed that CA lawmakers passed up a chance to #SayNoToHate and voted for a bill that still contains the #Hinduphobic word “caste.” Yet, we are also proud of the tireless grassroots work of our...1/n
...volunteers, other Hindu orgs and allies, which resulted in the CA Assembly Judiciary Committee voting on a bill that has been stripped of much of the outright xenophobic language of the original version. UNFORTUNATELY, the final nail in the coffin still remains...2/n
...and we intend to fully fight this all the way to the courts. No one said that this was going to be easy. 😀. BUT, let’s review how far we have come. 3/n
Disappointed to see @theJagmeetSingh conflate the Nazi #Hakenkreuz with the sacred #Swastika, perpetuating a colonial lie that demonises Hinduism. This is painful, especially given his Dharmik heritage.
The Swastika can be found in and around Gurdwaras in India.
(2/n)
What is more disappointing is that this isn’t the first time the NDP leader has helped in furthering this misinformation, which was promptly refuted by CoHNA.