Hold2 Profile picture
Jun 12, 2021 25 tweets 12 min read Read on X
***Master NY BOE Unmask🧵***

I've created this to gather all the NY BOE letters being sent to Gov Cuomo and Legislature.

It started with Hauppauge, a Long Island district that was open 5d/wk ALL YEAR. Yes, even in NY. They set the pace.

This is Science. This is Leadership. ImageImage
Then Massapequa jumped in the ring for tag team support while adding their own #RationalGround verbiage:

"We respectfully request that you either provide the data and science that supports the universal masking of our children, or you lift the mask mandates for schools."

🔥🔥🔥 Image
Next, the floodgates opened.

A scorcher from William Floyd.

"...masks are causing anxiety and mental anguish, along with physical issues such as nosebleeds and trouble breathing..."

How many times have you heard, "what's the harm?" or "well my kid doesn't mind wearing one"? Image
Followed by a heavyweight blast from a huge school district.

In terms of BOE-to-Governor comms, this one is a flamethrower.🔥🔥

"...the balance has shifted to the point that the greater threat to our students is the psychological damage caused by overreaching requirements..." ImageImage
Then Lindenhurst...

A flood of anger.

Local decision-making and clear communication. That's all we're asking for.

"We urge you to grant school boards the IMMEDIATE authority to change their district's mask guidance." ImageImage
Oyster Bay. Long Island again, of course.

"We agree with school representatives who have stated that children should not be treated differently in the educational setting than in every other aspect of their lives."

How obvious and rational is that statement? Image
Not to be outdone, we then received a 4-in-1 atom bomb:

- Comsewogue
- Miller Place
- Port Jefferson
- Rocky Point

"authority to manage 300,000,000 in funding"

but

"...why are we not being trusted to make decisions regarding mask protocols...?"

Data and science again. Image
Here's Wappingers who actually sent their letter on June 9th ahead of Hauppauge.

Kudos.

"The requirement to wear a mask has contributed to health issues for those students and staff who have respiratory issues, asthmatic conditions, and other heat sensitivity ailments." ImageImage
And here is Arlington who also sent their letter on June 9th.

"enforcing the use of masks has meant sending children to the nurse for heat related ailments, an increase in the # of students refusing to wear a mask, and has caused interruptions and disruption in our classrooms" Image
Ok, I got a clean copy for Locust Valley.

"At a minimum, we request guidance that would allow mask-wearing to be optional, regardless of vaccination status, and/or at a minimum allow similar rules as we have in restaurants where the removal of a mask while seated is permitted." Image
Ok, now we have a clean copy for Garden City.

4 very reasonable requests on pg 2.

And this great quote:

"The community is blaming the School Board and the Superintendent for the mess your office has created. Let us be clear, it is not our mess. It is your mess to clean up." ImageImage
#15 has arrived: Clarence Central!

"I respectfully ask that you release the specific CDC response to your letter, especially the scientific data that caused the Governor and the NYSDOH to maintain the indoor mask mandate. Such information would be extremely helpful..." Image
#16 thanks to @EWoodhouse7: Mohonasen!

BOE held a special meeting Sat and passed a resolution.

"...we ask...for immediate relief from the wearing of masks for our students for in-person learning..."

"...petitions...to immediately allow K-12 schools to make their own policy..." Image
#17 Warwick!

The hits keep coming. This District actually held a survey and found 81.62% in favor!!

In our BOE meeting this week, a parent specifically asked for a survey to be sent instead of the Superintendent using personal anecdotes.

No response. Image
Whoa, #18-22 with this 5-in-1:

- Bellmore
- North Bellmore
- Merrick
- North Merrick
- Bellmore-Merrick

It's not strong against masks, but it does request local control, which is what we all need and want so we can fight head-on instead of being told nothing can be done. Image
Here's #23 overall and #18 from Long Island.

Seaford!

This District stayed open 5d/wk in-person all year (unlike most in NY) and has a strong message.

"...the social emotional toll of remaining masked has escalated and has become untenable." Image
#24 is Connetquot!

Yes, a District on Long Island (#19).

"...if this is not the time to unmask, when will be the time?"

"If there is no scientific reason to wear masks indoors...then move New York State schools in the right direction, now!" ImageImage
#25 is Island Trees Levittown!

"With the local COVID infection rate less than .40% and the vaccination rate at almost 80% in Nassau County, we ask that the New York State abolish the mask mandate for our school district, or at least provide us the autonomy to make this decision" Image
#26 is West Islip, which is #21 for Long Island!

"To treat students differently in the educational setting...is inconsistent and perplexing."

"We respectfully request that you either provide the supporting documentation and reasoning...or lift the mask mandates for schools." Image
#27, finally, is _my_ district: Kings Park. #22 for Long Island.

Our BOE sent a weak letter on June 8th, but we lobbied hard and bombarded them with other District letters. Today, they published a new letter that we are happy to see.

Original letter also shown. ImageImageImageImage
#28 is our neighbor Smithtown - #23 for Long Island.

Definitely read this one. Multiple statements in here are🔥🔥🔥.

"We continue to be acutely aware of the...toll that this
compliance has taken on the social, emotional, and physical well-being of our children and our
staff." ImageImage
Here's #29: Akron (upstate)!

"Yet, for reasons not supported by any scientific
data, school age children will still be required to wear masks indoors..."

"...revoke all mask mandates for students and staff so that we can focus on...promoting social and emotional health..." Image
#30 has arrived: Half Hollow Hills.

Another District on Long Island near me (#24 for LI).

"...indoor mask wearing should be optional based on an individual parent or employee choice."

I like the CC at the end. 😉 ImageImage
#31 showed up on Thursday: Cornwall.

Data and Science throughout!

"Throughout this last year we have been told to follow the science and follow the data. Both science and data, at this juncture, would strongly show that our children do not need to be wearing masks indoors..." ImageImage
#32 also arrived on Thursday (6/17): East Islip (#25 for LI).

"We write on behalf of the East Islip School District Board of Education in support of our neighboring districts that have requested to lift the mask mandate in schools and providing local decision making..." Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Hold2

Hold2 Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Hold2LLC

Feb 20
Nature is pretty amazing, eh?

Look how this year is tracing with last year. Remarkable.

% of ED Visits w/CoV2 Image
Zoomed in. Image
All years - Hospital Admissions Image
Read 6 tweets
Jan 15
Hello, @m_scribe and @guardian , this article has false claims about Flu, CoV2, and RAV, which should be corrected.

None of the 3 are rising, and the CoV2 weekly changes are out of date. You gave the weekly changes for week-ending 12/30, but CDC updates through week-ending 1/6. Image
All 3 can be seen declining no later than 12/30.


Image
Image
Image
Image
Will you fix the article based on the above, or is there a better method for requesting a formal correction?
Read 4 tweets
Mar 15, 2023
Kelley, did you know the WHO actually did reduce that harms list in the Dec 2020 update of that same document?

Conspicuously, they removed both “self-contamination” bullets.

More undue influence yet again?

(Before and After shown here) ImageImage
Oh, and these same 2 documents say the following about mask effectiveness. ImageImage
And what was their final recommendation?

“Despite the limited evidence of protective efficacy.”

They still advised community mask wearing in certain settings.

This is Dec 2020, not April. Image
Read 4 tweets
Mar 14, 2023
Dr. Gandhi, I do not believe PH will simply “recommend.”

I have hate in my heart for your profession, and it will not go away easily.

I say this because I have always believed you cared even when I was screaming at you to stop promoting school masking based on Hosp census.
If you are truly trying to drive the PH ship towards being helpful and trustworthy, please take my comments and those of others to heart.

We don’t just not trust you. WE _HATE_ YOU (public health community).

It is a deep resentment that must first be addressed and atoned for.
Exactly right.

And the CDC + Fauci + all major US Gov PH is still doing it. They haven’t budged an inch.
Read 5 tweets
Mar 13, 2023
Sure, I will respond genuinely on the basis you are asking earnestly.

First, I think EVERYTHING in the screenshot is bad:

1) “Ritual and solidarity” are brainwashing techniques. Fooling/coercing people into accepting and then propagating a measure is dastardly to begin with

/1 Image
2) Doing that with a measure that is ineffective is downright evil, because it brainwashes people unknowingly into a self-harming act both directly (unsanitary, dehumanizing, social detriment, etc) and indirectly (increased exposure due to false sense of security)

/2
3) Nothing wrong with people protecting themselves, but community masking with any material was not protective for the individual and especially not the community. It was always a lie even if Zeynep truly believed in masks personally

/3
Read 4 tweets
Feb 7, 2023
NYC CoV2 Update: 2/7/23

Not many Unvaxxed getting Vaxxed since July 2022.

Ratio of Vaxxed outcomes remaining steady since March of 2022.

Limitations/Caveats:
- I'm using 2020 census pop as the denominator
- I'm combining Boosted + Full Vax
- NYC excludes Partial Vax outcomes
The reason I show NYC data as "% Share of Outcomes" is because @nycHealthy chooses to show "age-adjusted per 100k" Vax vs. Unvax rates.

...but doing that is susceptible inaccurate Unvax denominators.

Here, you can see how far off those denominators are:

Hold2 vs. DOH
How do they explain this?

1) Double-counting multi-race individuals
2) Still using the 2019 intercensal population estimates based on the 2010 census

How can they still not be using 2020 Census numbers in 2023?
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(