Alex Profile picture
15 Jun, 10 tweets, 3 min read
BMW i4 versus Model 3 competitive Analysis

Internal document leaked:

"The new BMW i4 is currently competing in retail primarily against the Tesla Model 3 as its most important competitor, while the Polestar 2 from the Chinese Geely Group is a competitor in only a few markets"
BMW continued to with their competitive anaysis

"Audi and Mercedes currently have no offerings in this class of vehicle"

"The Tesla Model 3's driving performance has been praised by the media, as has its handling"

"The cumbersome operation & build quality earn clear criticism"
BMW informs in the internal document that the consumption of the Top Model i4 M50 is 19-24 KWh/100km while the Model 3 Performance has 14kwh/100km

An up to 70% consumption difference, that's huge🙄

The i4 is heavier, slower, less acceleration, and has less range & higher price
Comparing the 'low-cost' Models BMW i40 and the Model 3 SR the statistic looks even more negative for BMW

With a 58KWh Battery 🔋 versus the i4 with 83KWh the hyped BMW BEV has less top speed, a up to 50% higher consumption, is heavier, and has a higher price too
Where BMW obviously tried to stay at par is torque & range for the i40 which is considering the much larger battery, not a win

Even at the prestigious 0-100km/h is the i4 inferior with its top Model

The BMW i4 is losing against Model 3 in all specs for a higher price
BMW expressed they believe to lead in ergonomics and customization

"BMW iDrive with BMW Curved Display and BMW Operating System 8 as a new form of ergonomically perfect driver orientation"

"numerous customization options, e.g. for wheels and colors"

Will that be sufficient?
The BMW charging options sound like an attempt to convince their own sales team

"Extensive charging standard equipment and customized charging solutions from BMW Charging for fast, convenient, and easy charging. Monitoring and control of charging processes via My BMW App."
BMW i4

"Safe use of iPhone apps while driving. Integration of content in Head-Up Display and, new for the i4, Apple Maps ... also support for the Apple voice assistant - new - without pressing the push-to-talk button, simply by activating it with the voice command 'Hey Siri'"
My conclusion

The BMW i4 will not take any market share from Tesla but from other BEVs but the largest part will come from the BMW ICE vehicles

In that respect, the BMW i4 will be a win for the Tesla mission, the 'transition to sustainable transportation'
Finally, the polarising i4 design that received a strong push back in social media may be a challenge to win new customers and keep old ones

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Alex

Alex Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @alex_avoigt

16 Jun
German Transportation Minister Scheuer

"I'm in direct talks with manufacturers like Tesla to get existing infrastructure for example Tesla Superchargers opened up to other manufacturers as well. There are some technical issues to work out but I expect we will come to a solution"
While Tesla for many years offered to share Superchargers with other manufacturers either pride stood in the way or for technical or financial reasons they didn't want to

With many BEVs on Germanys roads open them up to everybody would be a competitive disadvantage
Scheuer wants to have easy customer access over a smartphone like Tesla has and makes pressure on existing charging providers

"Then you can relax and get a real or vegan currywurst while you're charging, and you're on your way"
Read 8 tweets
15 Jun
🇩🇪 Giga Berlin

State Office for Environment confirmes, the public must be involved again in the construction of the Tesla factory in Grünheide

Timewise this is already priced in and no further delays are expected

A new public hearing will happen
The display of the documents in four different offices and the web will begin on Friday, June 18th

Follwing docs can be reviewed

"the complete application documents as well as immission forecasts for air pollutants, odors and noise, the species protection expert report, (...)"
" (...) the expert report on the Water Framework Directive, vibration and oscillation expert reports and other expert reports and statements."

Docs will be available for 4 weeks until July 17th

Another 4 weeks are granted until August 16th to file complaints or questions
Read 7 tweets
12 May
Cyber Truck Use Cases

#1 Police
#2 Taxi
#3 Ambulance
Read 4 tweets
9 May
Porsche R&D Head Steiner

When the next Porsche BEV Model will come to market?

"We are targeting the first half of 2023"😳

"Then the all-electric Macan will be ready for the road. The well-camouflaged prototypes are now leaving the factory premises for the 1st time"

2 years 🤭
Steiner continued about the next 2023 BEV

"The Macan will indeed be built and developed on the Premium Platform Electric shared with Audi"

Nevertheless, he adds, it will be clearly different from future Audi vehicles. "The Macan will have the soul of a Porsche."
Planned delivery of the next Porsche BEV in 2 years tells us that they either have problems developing a competitive BEV SUV or feel good about continuing selling ICE & making profits with it

In any case, these lazy timelines prove that the pressure is still not high enough
Read 5 tweets
30 Apr
VW initiated a task force to fight against the semiconductor shortage

Head of task force

The situation remains critical in the second quarter and could even worsen. "We are fighting for every vehicle"
VW Head of Chip task force

"The situation will remain tense in the second quarter. Further production adjustments cannot be ruled out"

Hundreds of parts are affected at all car & truck brands

"There are always supply shortages but we've never had a situation like this before"
The chip shortage results in issues much more severe than the market anticipates

The task force involved in purchase chips for their suppliers now and has done 10,000 broker requests to solve bottlenecks but only half of it could be solved
Read 4 tweets
30 Apr
VW expands its Software Org

VW Group CEO Herbert Diess "In Cariad, we are investing 2.5 billion euros per year"

"Then on top of that, there's an acquisition or two"

According to media sources he retreats from supervisory boards at Seat & Skoda bc he wants to focus on SW
VW had already invested around €2bn in the start-up Argo AI, which is jointly operated with Ford, for this purpose

Diess "will be the cardiovascular system of a car".

"It will be beyond 2025 before this (AVs) becomes a business model."
But then, Diess said, things could move very quickly.

"I expect that by 2035, about 40 percent of all cars will be able to drive autonomously."
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(