THREAD: For those following the Sonia Appleby v Tavistock Trust employment tribunal...Ms Appleby told the tribunal she first had concerns about the Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS) in 2016. At this point the service had undergone enormous change: tinyurl.com/38bu4z9f
During his evidence, Dr David Bell said concerns had not only been raised in 2015, but as far back as 2005. @BBCNewsnight fought for 15 months to get Dr David Taylor's 2005 report into staff concerns about GIDS released via the Freedom of Information Act: tinyurl.com/re9fr28s
The tribunal has heard claims GIDS clinicians were discouraged from seeking safeguarding help from Sonia Appleby. In June 2020 Newsnight first made these allegations public, having seen some interview transcripts forming part of the official GIDS review: tinyurl.com/2465fdk8
The transcripts included claims that some assessments failed to take adequate account of trauma or mental health problems; that some were referred for puberty blockers after 1 or 2 appointments; and homophobia was discussed in all interviews we read. tinyurl.com/phakzrmn
The Tavistock Trust told the BBC then it "stands by" the 2019 review of GIDS and is "confident that it fairly addressed the issues raised". A spokesperson said "GIDS is a safe and caring service which supports a wide range of children" and "[We] strongly refute the allegations."
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
THREAD: DAY 6 – Sonia Appleby v Tavistock and Portman Trust employment Tribunal
SA - Sonia Appleby
DS - Dr Dinesh Sinha, Tavistock Medical Director
YG - Yvette Genn, Tavi counsel
AP - Anya Palmer, SA counsel
EJG - employment judge Goodman
Questioning of DS by AP continues
AP refers DS to an email sent following his review email
AP - it's quite clear you cut hims off and move him on again. I'm going to suggest that you seem remarkably uncurious for some one charged with investigating safeguarding concerns in the trust. Do you agree?
DS. No I don't
THREAD: DAY 5 – Sonia Appleby v Tavistock and Portman Trust employment Tribunal
SA - Sonia Appleby
YG - Yvette Genn, Tavi counsel
AP - Anya Palmer, SA counsel
EJG - employment judge Goodman
Questioning of SA by YG set to continue, but some technical difficulties at the mo…
YG - Meeting w Dr Sinha July 2019. You were expecting to meeting his to discuss voluntary redundancy?
SA - Yes
YG - ... even though your role wasn't redundancy, was it?
SA - no. my job wasn't redundant but i was responding to a previous scheme the trust had in place, but when i spoke to HR in June they advised the scheme was no longer in place but should talk to line manager..
Sonia Appleby’s employment tribunal against the Tavistock and Portman Trust begins today. Ms Appleby is the Trust’s Safeguarding Lead for Children. Details of her claim emerged after Newsnight reported staff at GIDS claimed they’d been discouraged from seeking her advice. ⬇️