Paul Byrne Profile picture
Jun 23, 2021 • 20 tweets • 14 min read • Read on X
We have a new paper out in @PNASNews.

We found stuff that moved on #Venus.

Let's talk about it.

A 🧵
Most rocky worlds are what we call "one-plate planets": they have a single, continuous outer shell that we call the lithosphere.

Mercury (shown here), Mars, the Moon, Io... all one-plate planets.

(2/n)
We've long known that Venus is a lot more complex than those other, smaller worlds—but how hasn't exactly been clear.

It doesn't have plate tectonics like Earth. Is it a single shell? Did it *ever* have a mobile surface? What drove that motion?

That's where we come in.

(3/n)
We took old data from @NASA's Magellan mission (which ended when ST:TNG did) and started mapping.

There are many narrow bands of tectonic structures on Venus—the stuff in yellow here.

In lots of places those belts outline low-lying areas that are only a little deformed.

(4/n)
@NASA What's important here is that, within those belts of tectonic structures—some of which are where the crust was pushed together, others where it was pulled apart—there's also evidence for stuff having moved side-to-side.

That's really important.

(5/n)
@NASA Here's a map of that vast, low-lying area shown above, but with more geological detail.

Twitter compression aside, here's the take-home:

This is a big lowland, surrounded by tectonic belts that record a lot of horizontal, side-to-side-motion.

This thing moved, y'all.

(6/n)
@NASA Here's another example. (This one's my favourite.)

It's a smaller lowland, but by looking at the belts around its edges we can infer that it moved—to the southwest, in this case

***and***

it must have moved geologically recently

(7/n)
@NASA We can say that because in lots of cases tectonic structures cut through, and thus must be younger than, the lava flows that make up the plains.

Those flows are some of the youngest on Venus. We don't know *how* young... yet.

But not hundreds of millions of years.

(8/n)
@NASA And remember that smaller low? Here's a more zoomed out view of that region—the small low is near the top.

This region is full of belts. Which show lots of side-to-side motion. And this region is full of lows.

Which we think are individual chunks of Venus' lithosphere.

(9/n)
@NASA If we're right, then these chunks—we call them blocks—seem to have jostled, moved, banged into each other, pulled apart, rotated... in a way that's similar to how pack ice or drift ice behaves.

(10/n)
@NASA We've found this pattern of jostling blocks across Venus.

It's not everywhere, and it doesn't—yet, at least—seem to form a globally interconnected network of blocks.

There might just be regions where the lithosphere fragments, and others where it doesn't.

But why?

(11/n)
@NASA It's possible that, similar to Earth, Venus' mantle is convecting—moving as it's heated from below—with that motion being transferred to the surface.

So @PeterBJames ran some models to estimate how much stress a convecting interior might apply to the surface.

(12/n)
@NASA @PeterBJames Long story short—and short story interesting—we found that the stresses from movement in the interior are *at least* enough to overcome the strength of the lower part of the lithosphere... leading to movement of the surface.

(13/n)
@NASA @PeterBJames It's not plate tectonics like on Earth. These blocks don't subduct.

But it's *similar*—stuff has moved on the surface geologically recently in response, we think, to movement of the interior.

Not quite Earth. But definitely not Mercury, the Moon, or that dullard Mars.

(14/n)
@NASA @PeterBJames OK, so should you care?

Friends, OF COURSE you should care!

First off, if stuff moved on Venus in the geologically recent past, do you really think it shut down only a few million years ago? Venus is almost as big as Earth.

Earth has plenty of vigour left.

(15/n)
@NASA @PeterBJames But modern Venus might also hold clues to early Earth.

Much of Venus' lithosphere is probably thin, because the surface is so hot. Early Earth likely had a thin lithosphere, because the interior was hotter than today.

So maybe Venus tectonically resembles young Earth?

(16/n)
@NASA @PeterBJames And Venus might *also* tell us what to expect on planets that are Earth-sized—which basically means Venus-sized—orbiting other stars.

If so, then we can build on our findings for Venus to calibrate our expectations for how large, rocky exoplanets might work.

(17/n)
@NASA @PeterBJames We have more to do.

But the Magellan data aren't exactly *great* in terms of what we need.

Thankfully, within the next 10 years we're gonna get a BOATLOAD (as in, petabytes) of new data for Venus, both from @NASA's VERITAS mission (led by @SueSmrekar)...

(18/n)
@NASA @PeterBJames @SueSmrekar ...and by @ESA's EnVision mission, which is led by the second author on our paper, Rich Ghail (and who steadfastly refuses to join Twitter, so he can't tell when I abuse him).

PETABYTES of new data.

It's going to be wild.

(19/n)
@NASA @PeterBJames @SueSmrekar @esa So, that's our paper.

That's why this is potentially a big deal—we've found that our weirdo neighbour is more Earth-like than we knew, and is very possibly tectonically active *now*.

I've skipped a *lot* of detail here, but I hope you enjoyed this thread—and thanks for reading!

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Paul Byrne

Paul Byrne Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ThePlanetaryGuy

Oct 10, 2022
Friends, a few weeks ago I told you about something called Phantom—the Venus balloon mission concept I've been leading since January.

In July, we successfully flight-tested a subscale prototype of our balloon in the Nevada desert.

Now we've a video of those tests.

Take a look.
This video documents just a tiny bit of the *enormous* amount of work folks have put into developing these balloons—much of that work predating my joining the mission concept team.

Importantly, these tests validate the technologies we hope to propose to NASA for eventual flight.
You might remember, in my recent thread, that we might not even have the chance of proposing our mission concept to NASA in the next competition round.

That's something we're working hard on to fix.

But now, for the first time, we know we can fly a variable-altitude balloon.
Read 7 tweets
Feb 10, 2022
This. Is. Amazing.

NASA's #ParkerSolarProbe was able to image the surface of #Venus from space in a way we didn't think possible before!

Here, we can see the Aphrodite Terra highland *glowing* through the clouds (left), exactly where radar data tell us it should be (right)! ImageImage
Venus' thick cloud layer obscures the surface from space at visible wavelengths—but there are some "windows" at near-infrared wavelengths where cameras can see through to the surface.

PSP took these images at a wavelength not thought to be able to penetrate the clouds before.
This matters because, unlike Mars, Mercury, the Moon, etc, we can't easily see the Venus surface—we have to use radar.

But if we can "see" the surface in the near infrared, we can start to learn things about what it's made of. And thus we can learn new things about Venus.
Read 6 tweets
Jan 16, 2022
A quick 🧵 about the *size* of the #HungaTonga eruption:

Volcanic eruptions are generally assigned a VEI—Volcanic Explosivity Index—value.

This scale is a general indicator of the explosive character of an eruptive event.

1/
This scale, described by Christopher Newhall and Stephen Self in a 1982 paper, is a general indicator of the explosive character of an eruptive event, and reflects the interplay of an eruption's magnitude, intensity, and energy release rate.

2/
The VEI rating scale employs a set of criteria including ejecta volume, style of eruption, plume height, and injection of gases into the troposphere and stratosphere.

There's no question that the #Tongaeruption was huge—it absolutely was.

3/
Read 4 tweets
Aug 28, 2021
I need you to know I'm being completely serious here.

We have no idea what's inside Uranus.
We really don't have a clue what's inside this or there other "ice giant", Neptune.

It's possible that there's a rocky interior, perhaps at least as large as Earth. There might be a water–ammonia ocean above that rocky centre, topped with a thick atmosphere.

But we don't know.
Uranus and Neptune are the outer Solar System's Venus -- fascinating, largely unexplained, but to be honest pretty much ignored in the modern era of planetary exploration.

I am *so* happy we're going back to Venus.

But we can't forget the Ice Giants.
Read 8 tweets
Aug 26, 2021
The Solar System is *full* of incredible and fascinating worlds!

Mercury.
Venus.
Earth.
The Moon.
Jupiter.
Saturn.
Uranus and Neptune.
Ceres, Vesta, and the other main asteroid belt bodies.
The myriad other minor bodies scattered across the System.

Every one of them amazing! 🥰
People are pointing out that I forgot somewhere important!

Somewhere that fascinates everyone, that we need to explore more, that holds a special place in our heart.

I am so sorry, Pluto!
Did I miss any other interesting places?!

Let's add Charon, Eris, Makemake, Titan, Triton, Haumea, Io, Ganymede, Europa, Callisto, Dione, Rhea, Tethys, Iapetus, Umbrial, Ariel, Titania, Oberon, Miranda, oh my!
Read 6 tweets
Jun 4, 2021
Psst.

Interested in learning more about #Venus—and why @NASA's decision to go back there with the #VERITAS and #DAVINCI+ missions is such a big flippin' deal?

Read on.

(a 🧵 on comparative planetology)
It all comes down to one simple question:

Why is Earth's sibling not its twin?

(Credit to @efrankplanetary for that line.)

Venus and Earth are the same(ish) size, age, and composition (in roughly the ~same proportions), orbiting the same star.

So, uh... what's going on?
Here's where we come to our two different stories for Venus—and why figuring out which one is correct is *critical* to understanding not only our own world, but Earth-size worlds everywhere.

Scenario 1: Venus was *always* fucked.
Read 20 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(