There's so much lacking in Morrison's latest policy backflip: a quarantine station in the middle of Brisbane. I barely know where to start. After his failures on quarantine, this smells like a political fix aided and abetted by Murdoch's #CourierFail.
A thread.
Morrison has made an unmitigated mess of quarantine, evidenced by the thousands of Aussies still trapped overseas. He promised they'd all be home by last Christmas. Many (including me) called on Morrison to consider regional defence bases for quarantine. He has repeatedly refused
While Albo & Labor Premiers campaigned for national quarantine, Morrison's Liberals scoffed & criticised. They rejected a concrete QLD proposal for Toowoomba, outside Brisbane. Rostered staff could stay on-site to prevent constant interaction between them and the community.
The Brisbane quarantine floated by Morrison would almost inevitably have staff moving around the city in their off-hours, spreading the virus around the community. It's much safer to have properly paid staff staying on-site while rostered on, then going home.
This is one of the biggest problems using hotels - one potentially deadly outbreak every six weeks. At Howard Springs, where staff stay on-site, there have been ZERO breaches. Morrison arrogantly wants us to think he's doing great. But here's what other countries are saying...
Morrison's proposed facility won't even be ready until next year—two years into the pandemic. QLD's completed Wellcamp proposal was on the table 4 months ago. If Morrison had backed it then, it would be running now. At every turn, Morrison slow-walked Labor's solutions to death.
And how has Murdoch aided this shameful backflip?
First, this proposal went to Palaszczuk on Thursday night. But Murdoch's #CourierFail already had it ready to roll for the front page. Do Murdoch's henchmen stop to question their role in this propaganda machine? Not for a moment
Second, Murdoch's papers have personally blamed premiers for outbreaks and border closures in Labor states, but show none of the same ruthlessness when state and federal Liberals are in charge. Relax everyone, it's "Covid calm".
Third, pretending national quarantine is a fresh debate. Experts have called for purpose-built facilities since early last year. Even if Morrison wants to claim ignorance, in October 2020 he was directly advised by Jane Halton AO to build the facility for 'surge capacity'.
And did you ever notice how Murdoch editors love using Morrison’s self-ascribed nickname “ScoMo” to soften his image? Sometimes it’s the very respectable “PM” when he needs a bit of gravitas, but rarely “Morrison”.
This brings us finally to why we're talking about this today. The answer: Morrison knows he's stuffed quarantine and vaccines. He doesn't want to be blamed for Sydney lockdowns so, with Murdoch's backing, he rushes out these wafer-thin proposal as a distraction. Pure politics.
Australians need news that isn’t dominated by a single player. Murdoch functions like a party in coalition with the LNP, advancing their narrow commercial and ideological agenda. It's a rotten protection racket.
Can you believe Murdoch's #CourierFail? They commissioned polling to confirm their campaign targeting Premier @AnnastaciaMP was working. And when the data did NOT show what they wanted, they went overboard to misrepresent it.
Here’s some analysis. 1/9
Let's start with their front page "SHOCK POLL: PALASZCZUK TRAILS NEWMAN"
It's based on the Queensland Premier's satisfaction rating of 40% compared with Newman's (supposed) rating of 41% when he was defeated in 2015.
But there are THREE big problems with this claim. 2/9
1) Cherry-picking data
When choosing a poll for Newman, the #CourierFail picked a Galaxy poll from 7-8 Jan 2015 and claimed it was "the eve" of his defeat on Jan 31. That's a lie.
Murdoch's actual election-eve poll showed Newman's popularity had crashed from 41 to 35. 3/9
November marks the 15th anniversary of the 2007 election. I'm constantly asked where to find an authentic #KEVIN07 t-shirt. So we're marking the occasion by firing up the printers! All profits to @Murdoch_RC's campaign for a #MurdochRoyalCommission. kevinrudd.com/shirts
If you’re in Queensland, I’ll be getting together with the @QLDLabor family for dinner at the Gabba on Sunday 20 November. I’m looking forward to it. Tickets here: form.123formbuilder.com/6275077/form
If you can’t make it in Brisbane, I’ll be visiting Sydney, Melbourne, Canberra and Newcastle later this month. Come say hello. avoidablewar.com/events
Here's a great example of Murdoch and Morrison working hand-in-hand to sow false and misleading information into our national debate… This article is packed full of Liberal lies, none of which were fact-checked prior to publication, and no real opportunity to comment. Thread
The Australian sought comment from my office at 6.55pm last night (almost eight hours after the speech) on a one-hour deadline. My staff offered to help them check the LNP's facts in the morning, but they refused. They were running these lies immediately, no matter what.
Since I don't spend my Sunday nights sitting by the phone waiting for it to ring, none of this reached me before their one-hour deadline passed. When the story was published today, it was packed with desperate falsehoods and misrepresentations. Let's take it one element at a time
Morrison has been talking about "Rudd economics". What does he actually mean? Morrison would be lucky to have an economic record anything like my govt. We consistently delivered lower taxes, lower spending, lower debt, lower waste and higher wage growth than under Morrison.
Taxes under my govt averaged 21.8% of GDP and as low as 19.9% during the Global Financial Crisis.
Morrison was collecting 23.1% in taxes before the pandemic and is predicting taxes will be even higher, reaching 23.9% in 10 years' time.
The record on taxes is crystal clear.
Spending under my govt was 24.7% of GDP on average, peaking at 25.9% during the Global Financial Crisis during our stimulus, and dropping back to 23.9% before we left office.
Morrison is still spending 27.8% and forecasts 26.5% (i.e. higher than the GFC) in 10 yrs' time.
There is nobody in the parliament who knows more about Australian science, research, industry and higher education than Kim Carr. His retirement will be a loss to the Senate.
During much of Kim's career, it was fashionable to talk down the manufacturing industry as merely the inefficient and embarrassing remnants of a bygone era - something we no longer needed in a globalised economy based around financial and professional services.
But Kim has never subscribed to that doctrine. As a student of the German post-war manufacturing model, he rightly rejected this notion as a neoliberal fantasy. Like me, Kim knew the most successful countries on earth were countries that actually made things.
This bloke Forrest’s claim that my government “avoided doing or saying anything” to upset China is complete and utter nonsense. Anyone serious at @ASPI_org would have told him as much. Here are eight examples... THREAD
1. We massively increased defence spending, linking it explicitly to China's arms build-up and the need to prepare for the worst in our region. Biggest naval expansion since WW2. Defence budget was boosted by one-third to 1.96% of GDP in 2009-10. smh.com.au/national/defen…
2. We issued visas to Xinjiang activist Rebiya Kadeer to tell Australians about her homeland. The Liberals sided with Beijing against free speech, accusing us of having “failed to work constructively with China”. abc.net.au/news/2009-08-2…