Capital Delegation at the Founding:
Scholars @nicholas_bagley @jdmortenson & Nick Parrillo have found broad delegation by Congress to executive officials in the Founding Era.
I stumbled on another example:
The Residence Act, the 1790 statute creating the District of Columbia 1/
2/ The 1790 statute is here. And it is very short.
It was one of the most contentious debates of the first Congress, and it became part of the famous deal between Jefferson/Madison and Hamilton over assumption of state debt ("The Room Where It Happened").
www2.gwu.edu/~ffcp/exhibit/…
3/ The statute delegated power to a commission of 3 who "shall under the direction of the President survey, and by proper metes and bounds define and limit a district of territory, under the limitations above mentioned."
Those limitations?
Only this 70-mile span of the Potomac!
4/ The distance along the Potomac from "the mouths of the Eastern branch" to the Connogochegue is 70 miles from Williamsport, MD (near Hagerstown!) to where DC sits now.
There is no "intelligible principle" anywhere in the statute giving any further guidance to the commissioners.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Jed Shugerman

Jed Shugerman Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @jedshug

21 Jul
Why is the arrest of Trump campaign insider Tom Barrack a big deal?
He is being prosecuted for acting as an unregistered foreign agent for Saudi...
My 2019 thread on how his corrupt nuclear lobbying for Saudi implicates:
Mike Flynn
Jared Kushner
Rick Gates, Rick Perry, MBS...
2/ @WendySiegelman and I were working in 2018-19 to explain how Brookfield (links to Qatar and United Arab Emirates) bailed out Jared Kushner on his 666 5th Ave. debt disaster.

She notes the Brookfield deal also implicates Mnuchin, Ross, Mattis & Pompeo
3/ Correction: Tom Barrack was indicted for acting as a foreign agent for UAE, which is more connected to Brookfield than Saudi.
@politico: "Also charged in the case were an aide to Barrack at his firm Colony Capital, Matthew Grimes, & a businessman from UAE, Rashid Al-Malik..."
Read 8 tweets
4 Jul
Bottom of 11th inning, @redsox at @Athletics.
1 out, runners on corners, sharp grounder to 2d base at double-play depth...
Instead of turning an easy inning-ending double play, @marwinGF9 just throws to first.
And these @fox announcers think he actually did a good thing. Whut.
The next hitter hit a deep fly for the 3d out, so no harm, no foul.
And then @marwinGF9 drove in the first run of extras for a 5-4 lead, so all forgiven.
Except for those slow Fox announcers.
I was not a fan of the Sox letting go of Betts, Bradley, and Benintendi, but I can get over it after watching a half-season of Alex Verdugo, Enrique Hernandez, and Hunter Renfroe (and tonight Martinez in LF and sometime soon Jarren Duran in CF)
Read 4 tweets
1 Jul
Kagan canonical dissent in Brnovich:
"If a single statute represents the best of America, it is the Voting Rights Act...
If a single statute reminds us of the worst of America, it
is the Voting Rights Act. Because it was—and remains—so necessary."
The majority is very bad news.
Kagan dissent:
"Rarely has a statute required so much sacrifice to ensure
its passage. Never has a statute done more to advance the Nation’s highest ideals. And few laws are more vital in the current moment. Yet in the last decade, this Court has
treated no statute worse."
2/
3/
In the next page, Kagan drops in a none-too-subtle reference to Dred Scott to shame the shameless Roberts Court:
Read 5 tweets
23 Jun
A Unitary Puzzle, as we await Collins v Yellen:
Why are judges & academics who otherwise are decentralizing states-rights federalists and opponents of the modern administrative state so in favor of centralized expansive presidential power?
Explainer:
shugerblog.com/2021/06/23/a-u…
I also recommend this article by Stephen Skowronek from a decade ago:
cdn.harvardlawreview.org/wp-content/upl…
3/
I filed this brief in Collins with @protctdemocracy:
The first Congress rejected “presidentialism,” that the President alone can remove principal officers, and it rejected the more specific claim of exclusive or “indefeasible” presidential removal:
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cf…
Read 5 tweets
2 Jun
This is a non-story on the @ManhattanDA race on both @TaliFarhadian & @AlvinBraggNYC.
There is zero conflict of interest here.
Being interviewed for a federal judgeship indicates no political favor or grudge. To the contrary, this story shows Tali's merit & independence. 1/
2/ @nytimes reports HLS Prof @NoahRFeldman recommended @TaliFarhadian to the Trump administration on his own initiative - b/c she is extraordinarily qualified to be a judge.
Remarkably enough, Trump staffers actually interviewed her, a progressive Obama DOJ veteran!
3/ Tali had no contacts with Trump world, but was so impressive that they interviewed anyway.
She bravely told the Trump staff things they didn't want to hear, and the interview "became heated during a disagreement over constitutional law."
And her candidacy ended.
Good for her.
Read 12 tweets
26 May
Good essay by Gov. Mike DeWine on Ohio’s Vaccine Lottery.
But this gave me pause:
DeWine quoted baseball owner Bill Veeck, “To give one can of beer to a thousand people is not nearly as much fun as to give 1,000 cans of beer to one guy.”
1. NO WAY...
nytimes.com/2021/05/26/opi…
2/
First of all, has DeWine or Veeck ever been to a party? The best parties are giving a beer to a 1000 people. The worst party is where one guy has a thousand beers.
(You know what I mean).
And this is really about happiness, diminishing utility, and policy.
3/ DeWine says his team discussed cash payments or prizes for each person who got the shot. But they loved the flashiness of the lottery.
First: Do we really know whether the lottery was more effective than cash or other prizes?
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(