For those more focused on blame than saving what lives we can, please distinguish proximate cause from primary cause. Biden doesn’t make list of Top 5 Leaders Most Responsible for Losing Afghanistan: 1. Cheney (w/ Rumsfeld), 2. Bush, 3. Karzai (w/ Obama), 4. Trump & 5. Ghani.
1. Cheney (& Rumsfeld) at Bonn Conference and after committed the “original sin,” rejecting Afghan pleas not to hand power to their 80s era Northern Alliance allies who Afghans despised for their corruption and brutality.
2. Pres Bush compounded this sin in what now looks like the decisive moment: US & UN gutlessly breaking promise to bar warlords/kleptocrats from the 2005 parliamentary ballots. Thousands risked their lives for vetting. Bush caved & handed parliament to the most corrupt & vicious.
I first began spending time there in the months ahead of those elections, and you could see all hope drain from Afghans in that moment. Most Afghans didn’t even bother to vote after the decision, including just 34% on Kabul.
3. Karzai was given every chance and resource to lead and build a real government during the most secure years. The Obama Administration kept too much faith in him. H/t Holbrook
4. Trump made the failure official when he signaled surrender to the Taliban and cut the knees off the Afghan govt. this is the dominant proximate cause of this tragedy but less of a primary cause than above.
5. President Ghani absolutely failed his people when the test everyone knew was coming arrived. He was dealt a bad hand even before Trump stacked the deck against him. But the failure to even mount a fight or slow the advance is appalling.
Yes, Biden’s precipitous departure has tragic costs, but the blitz speed of the fall also shows that his decision was both accurate and principled. If you look at his positions over 20 years, he’s been far more right and honest than most of those lobbing criticism at him today.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Stop recycling this myth that Blue Dogs lost for supporting cap and trade? Most voted no & those of us who voted YES outperformed them.
They spent millions against me on this in a solid red district, and Election Day polling showed us winning on the issues of energy and climate. The bigger losers were those who didn’t take the vote and make the case / which was a winning argument for cap and trade.
One could argue individual losses - but what scenario has the amazing Rick Boucher holding VA-09 in the anti-Obama tea party wave of 2010?
A year ago, my mom let me escape the city to spend COVID with her and her view of the Blue Ridge. While we’ve shared many great moments, we’ve hit an impasse after 12 months on 5 things I just can’t explain to her…
(5) why a grownass man with a job still uses his friend’s Netflix account… (h/t @ProfAtuahene)
(4) how a justice advocate is ok with the DMX lyrics I regularly blast during work outs…
It seems increasingly clear that DC officials and Capitol Police - at a minimum - internalized the false and fatal logic of “both sides.” They keep mentioning lessons learned from last summer, but evidence shows BLM protesters do not show up the same way white supremacists do.
BLM crowds have been much larger, unarmed, & overwhelmingly peaceful even when provoked by law enforcement. White supremacist crowds have been smaller, heavily armed and violent in rhetoric and actions - often explicitly designed to terrorize public officials inside Capitols.
“Applying lessons” from justice summer to a Trump rally requires an epic level of bias and intelligence failures. Leaving moral inequivalence, it’s like saying you prepared to play the Steelers based on lessons from how you screwed up your game against the Cubs last summer.