I went on @ReliableSources with @brianstelter today to talk about U.S. media coverage of the war in Afghanistan, which has been its lowest in recent years, despite record pace.
There are many negative consequences, but one I want to emphasize the most is this...
Because most Americans are only now waking up to the war, they're informing themselves about the debate over withdrawal based mostly on sudden coverage from Kabul over the last few weeks—not the the years of context that's essential to having an informed debate about this war.
Most of the war in Afghanistan over the last 20 years has been fought in rural areas — not Kabul.
These areas are harder to access, admittedly, and some reporters have really gone to great lengths to report from them.
These are places where ordinary Afghan citizens have experiences the brunt of the war, from U.S. bombings, Taliban attacks, night raids by Afghan forces, ISIS-K attacks, kidnappings & more...
U.S. bombing in Afghanistan ramped up to record levels in recent years—not just against the Taliban, but ISIS-K, the group responsible for Thursday's airport attack.
In fact, in 2017 the U.S. dropped a 21,600-pound bomb in a small village in Nangarhar, intended to target ISIS-K.
Better known as the “Mother Of All Bombs...
Bombings & air support are primarily how the U.S. has been engaging in direct combat in Afghanistan in recent years.
In 2019, the bombing campaign was so intense it reached record levels in America's long war: usatoday.com/story/news/pol…
But American media tends to prioritize covering the war most when Americans are on the ground, and especially when they are dying.
The shift to air war meant (with some exceptions) news orgs focused little on the bombing and the impact it was (or wasn't) having on the ground...
Here are some of the impacts of that bombing, according to my ground reporting and that of many other journalists who have prioritized trying to understand how the war has been playing out in rural areas:
The intense scale & pace of bombing resulted in large numbers of civilians dying.
Those deaths created space for the Taliban, including many of its recent recruits, but it also left many civilians in battlefield areas desperate for the war to end.
Many Americans would struggle to relate to these civilians. They don’t speak English. Most have never had a smartphone. And you’d be hard-pressed to find a video of them going viral online.
But their voices are essential context to understand this war:
Investigations into America's aerial war in Afghanistan are essential to understanding the approach the Biden administration seems to be weighing right now, based on the bombings yesterday against ISIS-K and today in Kabul:
a future of continued aerial warfare in Afghanistan.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
"But in the areas where most U.S. funding was concentrated — territories that were key to winning the war — American efforts have fallen woefully short of the grand claims the government made, claims that it knew were false."
In some cases, American efforts to provide education have actually backfired, embittering local people rather than winning their hearts and minds. ...
a fmr USAID manager on education in Afghanistan for years, watched the military’s counterinsurgency goals steadily creep into the agency’s work. USAID officials & contractors were summoned to presentations by generals, who asked how their work fit into the military’s strategy...
Throughout America's war in Afghanistan, reporters told story after story of the politicians, contractors, commanders & warlords who filled their pockets with billions meant for the Afghan people.
We've heard the numbers, but what were the true costs to Afghans?
🧵...
Many who pilfered the country have now escaped to luxury homes in places like Dubai & London, where they're desperately trying to re-write their histories.
When confronted with evidence of their corruption or wrongdoing, they're telling lies that are easy to fact check.
Some claim they have no ties to a company they founded.
Or pretend they didn't close one & start another under a new name.
That they didn't move business ops to the UAE to hide profits & a paper trail.
But perhaps the most brazen lie is the one they tell themselves...
Most of the war in Afghanistan has been fought in rural battlefields, places like Sangin and the Kandahar countryside, where Americans rarely hear the voices of women who have experienced decades of conflict.
Read this deeply reported story about women in Helmand's Sangin Valley
"But the vast majority of incidents involved one or two deaths—anonymous lives that were never reported on, never recorded by official organizations, and therefore never counted as part of the war’s civilian toll."
"There was Muhammad, a fifteen-year-old cousin: he was killed by a buzzbuzzak, a drone, while riding his motorcycle through the village with a friend. 'That sound was everywhere,' Shakira recalled. 'When we heard it, the children would start to cry, and I could not console them.'
"I Helped Destroy People," @janetreitman's @NYTmag cover story about @TerryAlbury, an FBI agent who provided journalists key documents about the war on terror—and went to prison for it.
Amid the Trump news cycle, many ignored the revelations from his leaks, but...
@TerryAlbury's firsthand account is an unvarnished view from the inside of what the FBI has been doing to Muslim and immigrant communities across the United States for two decades:
"His first partner, who worked primarily on cases involving Palestinians, used to argue to keep open cases that even his bosses wanted to close... “You invest years in it and begin to believe it’s your duty to find evidence, no matter how small, confirming your suspicions.”