Now with the perspective of a couple weeks it’s clear that really the only problem with the withdrawal was the collapse of the government. That forced an emergency evacuation which was very successful, though came at the cost of a dozen American lives.
2/ The collapse of the government wasn’t because the withdrawal was misplanned. It was a confirmation of the decision to withdraw itself. Remember Mike Allen saying it was a calamity that would be studied as long as humans read history? Wtf was that about?
3/ This was an embarrassing press freak out that mixed bad faith, denial and evasion. The layered upon that was a whole universe of people who apparently think governments fall in an orderly fashion, with postponements if people want to leave the country.
4/ Now you have folks like Martha Raddatz clinging on to the catastrophe narrative like it was a Huey helicopter rescuing her from her collapsing storyline. They’re upset because Biden’s decision and refusal to budge from it put the lie to decades of fables …
5/ which most of these reporters had made themselves a part of.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Josh Marshall

Josh Marshall Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @joshtpm

14 Sep
@benyt This is not accurate. Everybody has a hard time losing. People contest elections. But there is a clear and deepening pattern going back to 2000 to push conspiracy theories abt vote fraud to cue up election challenges and to create the premise for restrictions on voting.
@benyt 2/ There's simply no corollary to this among Democrats. The closest to this was the black box voting activism in the early aughts. But there's no comparison. This goes back to vote fraud propaganda in the 2002 midterm. It's what was behind the DOJ scandal in 2006/7.
@benyt 3/ It's what's behind the activism about voter ID. You seem to be referring to people contesting elections. And yes, there's tons of that in New York. But you're eliding a trajectory that traces back two decades and has had a massive effect on national politics.
Read 4 tweets
13 Sep
What this article doesn’t mention is that two days before DeMonia had to be hospitalized Donald Trump held what the state GOP said was the biggest political rally in Alabama history literally in DeMonia’s hometown of Cullman. DeMonia was hospitalized …
washingtonpost.com/health/2021/09…
2/ for and later died from cardiac issues after his local hospital in Cullman checked over 43 hospitals in the state looking for an available ICU bed. He was eventually airlifted to a hospital in Mississippi where he died. At two days earlier Trump’s rally clearly didn’t …
3/ cause the surge that filled all the ICUs in the state. But it illustrates the capacity situation in which he had a massive rally which was probably mostly unmasked. And there’s no doubt Trump is a central reason why vax levels are so low in the state. And again, his hometown…
Read 4 tweets
11 Sep
I've trained as an historian and keep a lot of records. I was looking through my emails from 9/11 and had totally forgotten about this episode. That summer I'd started hunting around on story about how we'd let bin Laden slip through our hands when we supposedly ...
2/ had a chance that the government of Sudan would hand him over to us. I'd interviewed various FSOs and intel folks about it. First I thought I had a story, then it seemed like I didn't. This was also a time when I was desperately trying to get some traction writing for the ...
3/ big magazines. I'd pitched the idea to an editor at the Times magazine and they weren't terribly interested. When you're starting out you pitch a lot of articles into the ether. Then on September 10th around 5pm I shot my editor and said the story seemed live again.
Read 7 tweets
8 Sep
Despite having grown up reading and admiring Tim Edsall’s writing, almost revering it, I’ve become accustomed for the last 20 years or so to a growing amount of absurdity in his writing. I was particularly struck by this.
2/ I don’t so much disagree with what’s being argued here. Many people claim there’s an intolerant left and to a significant degree I agree with them. But the switcheroo he’s talking here is perverse. More educated and younger people have long been more open to expressive …
3/ diversity. Various kinds of nonconformity, etc. sexual, etc. What’s really happened is that that same impulse has become more militant. And it sometimes escalates to a kind of speech policing that certainly some people find stifling. But this isn’t so much …
Read 8 tweets
6 Sep
this is a powerful meditation on grief. my wife is a therapist who specializes in grief. it’s a topic I encountered early in life. when I was 12 my mother was killed in an auto accident. i remember an incident something like what Norm describes. the morning after my mother …
2/ died my dad put me on the phone with my uncle (my mother’s brother). he said he could relate because he had also recently lost his mother. (my grandmother had recently died from cancer.) i remember thinking ‘man, I’m sorry but these things are just not the same.’
3/ people say dumb things to people who are grieving. if you are so unfortunate as to suffer a particularly catastrophic loss you learn this very quickly. mainly people don’t know what to say but feel they must say something. people experiencing acute grief are something …
Read 8 tweets
29 Aug
Fascinating account of the collapse of Kabul. But the Twitter commentaries on it have been more telling. Kabul was surrounded and destined to fall. But the US didn't expect it and neither did the Taliban. washingtonpost.com/world/2021/08/…
2/ Ghani's flight - at least partly based on false reports that Taliban were inside the palace looking for him - precipitated the collapse in Kabul. That disrupted a plan to create an interim power-sharing govt. Now there's no govt in Kabul. Taliban contacts US and ...
3/ says either you take over security in Kabul or we'll have to. The US response was that evac was our only mission. So we would only hold the airport. So the Taliban went into the city and took over. A stunning turn of events. But almost certainly the right decision.
Read 12 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(