We got 9th Circuit nominees, all of whom are already judges at the federal or state level: Judge Lucy Koh (N.D. Cal.), Justice Gabriel Sanchez (Cal. Ct. App., 1st App. District), Judge Holly Thomas (Los Angeles County Superior Ct., Family Law Division).
Here is Koh’s background:
Here is Sanchez’s background:
Here is Thomas’s background:
Unfortunately, no public defenders among the bunch — and one with prosecutorial experience (Koh) and another with government defense experience (Sanchez). Thomas, obviously, has civil rights experience, both at NAACP LDF and DOJ, so that’s great.
Among the five district court nominees, one has significant defender experience: Judge Katherine Marie Menendez, who spent nearly two decades — basically all of her non-judicial legal career — in the Federal Defender’s office in Minnesota.
Among the other four district court nominees, two have government defense experience and two have civil rights experience, both with MALDEF and one of those later ran Public Counsel. None of the district court nominees appear to have any significant prosecutorial experience.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
BREAKING: Supreme Court upholds district court order that the Trump administration "facilitate" the return of Kilmar Abrego Garcia, who was improperly sent to El Salvador.
A part of the government's request to vacate the original order is "effectively granted" b/c the deadline passed, SCOTUS holds, but the rest of the order stands. As to the requirement to "effectuate" Abrego Garcia's return, the district court should "clarify" that, w/ deference to executive.
BREAKING: On a 5-4 vote, the Supreme Court allows the Education Dep't to halt payment of grants.
A district court issued a TRO blocking the cancelation of the grants in a suit brought by eight states. The appeals court refused a stay pending appeal.
Today, SCOTUS stayed the TRO—blocking payments.
Thomas, Alito and the three Trump appointees formed the five-justice majority who issued the unsigned per curiam opinion.
Roberts wrote nothing but noted he would have denied the application.
Kagan and Jackson wrote dissents. Sotomayor joined Jackson's dissent, which does not hold back:
BREAKING: Chief Judge Boasberg issues a classwide, nationwide temporary restraining order, blocking removal of any noncitizens in U.S. custody who are subject to today's AEA order for the next 14 days.
With planes leaving, he says, "I am required to act immediately."
BREAKING: A federal judge this morning issued a temporary restraining order blocking the Trump administration from invoking the Alien Enemies Act of 1798 to deport several Venezuelan nationals with no process.
BREAKING: A federal district court judge in Kentucky vacates the Biden administration's Title IX rule, challenged largely for its transgender protections, a decision with nationwide effect.
The rule had been blocked in over half over the country as a result of several different challenges, but there had been no nationwide ruling — and appeals are pending in several appeals courts.
Schumer is filing cloture on several judicial nominations. Republicans are forcing them to go into executive session separately for each nomination. The Dems are just pushing ahead. Here was Schumer before the 10th vote, by my count, began.
By the Republicans refusing to give unanimous consent, the Dems are having to go through a series of procedural votes on each nominee.
They're passing on party-line votes, but the Republicans are literally just forcing them to take hours on this.
So far, cloture has been filed for:
- Amir H. Ali (D.D.C.)
- Sparkle L. Sooknanan (D.D.C.)
- Brian E. Murphy (D. Mass.)
- Anne Hwang (C.D. Calif.)
- Cynthia Dixon (C.D. Calif.)
This voting began at 6:32 pm, C-SPAN notes, after the vote on Kidd for the 11th Circuit.