There is a certain type of trad who exemplifies the actual Dravidian thinking - that service castes, landless labour and Brahmins should be humble recipients of their feudal largesse. Fact is, Hindu society never worked that way. The state of affairs in late 18th and 19th CE /1
was an anomaly, in which certain mercantile moneylending castes and landowning village administrator castes were able to rapidly advance in capital and land banks. Accumulation of capital and land proceeded at such a pace because other opportunities of investment were /2
no longer available - say textiles, handicrafts, due to deurbanization of the British Raj and rural agrarian distress. For example, there is no real office of a Chettinad Raja. The title - Raja - was bestowed upon Sir Annamalai Chettiar in 1929 for loyal services to the Crown /3
All the latter day Dravidian elite were minted only in the 19th CE. Their titles and privileges, including temple patronage, were bought. And the fortunes were made through usury, tax farming and clerical services as dubashes and gumasthas to the EIC and then to the Crown. /4
Like the robber barons of America bought respectability through endowing universities and libraries, these Indian moneylenders bought respectability by endowing pathashalas and temples. All the rage told and retold through stories are of rich landlords being forced to humble /5
themselves before a lawyer or a collector. Strangely, the memory of their humility and servitude to the white man never seems to hurt. Prof Karunandan is so on-the-money when he says that 'their villains' like Macaulay are 'our heroes'. It is true. British education enabled /6
their loyal service to the Crown. Even today, any Dravidian idealogue will extol the wonders of European values. That thinking is what percolates down to having Amy Jackson dress as a Tamil village girl. The flip side is their rage at the slightly lighter-skinned Tam Brahm /7
and their contempt for the darker among Tamils. The worst skin tone jokes are told by Tamil comedians, to a population most of whom are dark by Indian standards /END

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Suren

Suren Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @zeneraalstuff

10 Aug
Report from @NCPCR_ - "IMPACT OF EXEMPTION UNDER ARTICLE 15(5) W.R.T. ARTICLE 21A OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA ON EDUCATION OF CHILDREN OF MINORITY COMMUNITIES"
Findings: ImageImage
@NCPCR_ Recommendations ImageImageImageImage
Read 5 tweets
12 Jul
When Victoria Venkataramanamma's brother was the Premier of Madras Presidency, the world went through the Great Depression. Even after economic recovery began in the rest of the world, this Province remained in a decade of stagnation from 1932-1937. The rich zamindars who /1
made up the Cabinet took 50% higher salaries than Ministers in other provinces. Congress brought a resolution asking for ryotwari tax to be reduced so that suffering peasants could get relief. The zamindars refused to reduce taxes unless it was reduced for them, too. /2
As a consequence, the peasants were drowning in debt. The zamindars and their moneylender cronies who ran the Govt swooped in and took over lands. In some regions like Tirunelveli, half the peasant population was dispossessed of their lands. Crop prices across all crops fell /3 Image
Read 7 tweets
2 Jul
CSI - Thoothukudi Nazareth Diocese has 100 odd parishes and 2 lakh parishioners in one district of TN. They run 10 colleges, 19 High Schools, 1 Teacher's Training Institute, 6 High Schools, 5 schools for special children, 5 hospitals. All educational institutions get Govt aid /1
All 100 odd parishes will have Churches that can solemnize marriages. They also have halls and catering for wedding functions, betrothals, baptisms. A lay secretary is elected by parishioners. Naturally, this is tightly contested. Among the reasons given by the current /2
Lay Secretary's rivals is that he has married 'out of caste' to a Roman Catholic. They are also demanding that families whose members have married people from other religions without converting them must be disqualified from the vote as they are no longer really parish /3
Read 4 tweets
21 Jun
This will play out exactly the way Aryan Vandheris want it to.
These Vandheris have come with their begging bowls in hand and a innocent Mulnivasi Zamindar has given them traditional advisor position.
They will make one trip per quarter and stay with parents in Besant Nagar. /1
Take Amma and Appa to hospital, kutcheris, stock up on Grand Sweets murukku and Nalli Sarees. One ppt for bored babus and ministers.
After the presentation,
Babu 1: Sir, your point on debt servicing was simply brilliant. Are there any openings in the next batch at /2
your university for mid-career public policy programmes?
Babu 2: Sir, I never thought about household investment that way until you explained. My Periya Athan's brother's nephew is applying next Spring. Would it be possible to give a recommendation?
Minister: Saar, how to /3
Read 5 tweets
19 Jun
Excellent social experiment by Vignesh. Proces how Dravidam flies under the radar by using language of social justice.
- 3% is dog whistle/code for Brahmins, specifically Tamil Brahmins
- The speaker belongs to a community that owns a huge part of capital and businesses
enjoys huge clout in media and in religious institutions and has claimed exalted ritual position for millenia. However, you will never see him discuss what his people could do. Rather, he brackets his people as victims along with the most marginalized.
- To transpose this, go to
Punjab, and make the claim that Khatris are the reason why the rest of Punjab are trapped in poverty. Create a term called Khatrism, which you define as the social order that keeps SC people out of gurdwara and that the Khalistani movement was a result of Khatrism.
Read 5 tweets
8 Jun
Chellam Sir is an exemplar of why we, as a nation, are such under-achievers. He's the Vidhayak Chacha of 'Deus Ex Machina' plot devices. Everytime the writers have absolutely no clue on taking the plot forward, he just steps in. The fact that we make a big deal of him also /1
shows up our mindset as a people. Like the fact that in one of our earliest rockets launched out of Thumba had to be ferried to the launchpad on a bullock cart. Because they failed to plan for a truck. And we think that it is a cool thing to do. This, by the way, is something /2
even our most celebrated writers have done. In Sivakamiyin Sapatham, one of the late Kalki's worst novels (which was the first made into a movie, predictably), the Pallavan Emperor plays 'Deus Ex Machina' disguised as a sannyasi to help a young prince woo his own daughter /2
Read 8 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(