A couple of years before 9/11, I participated in a scenario exercise about terror threats that Wall Street might face. It was on the top floor of the World Trade Center. It was sponsored in part by Cantor Fitzgerald.
Tragically, a number of those who attended from that firm died in the attack. Not too long after the attack, I recall running into Howard Lutnick, the chairman of the firm, and I will never forget the look in his eyes, how haunted he was by the losses on that day.
On the day itself, I was on the phone with a friend whose apartment had a view of the World Trade Center. He stopped talking and just started repeating "oh my God, oh my God" and then he told me to turn on my television because a plane had flown into one of the twin towers.
I turned on the TV in my office and walked next door to the office of my then business partner, Anthony Lake, former US National Security Advisor. John Gannon, a former top CIA official and Susan Rice, later National Security Advisor herself, joined us.
We watched on the TV in Tony's office as the towers collapsed. John leaned over to Tony and said "Bin Laden." Later we walked to a nearby restaurant and sat outside for lunch. Washington seemed deserted. The skies were cloudless and blue.
Every so often you would hear a jet fighter overhead. Tony commented that we had entered a new era. We speculated about how much our lives would change, about how much U.S. national security priorities would change.
My daughters were at Georgetown Day School not too far away. I thought in the tumult surrounding the attacks that was the safest place for them. Later they would report that they were among the only kids left at the school, that the other parents had come to pick their kids up.
They were bewildered and troubled and, like everyone else, once home, we spent the day watching reports and finding out the horrific details, the toll the attack had taken.
That morning I had an appointment scheduled with a client, an admiral at the Pentagon.
He had cancelled the night before. I was pretty pissed off at the time. Later I learned that the wing in which his office was located was where American Airlines flight 77 had struck the Pentagon. He had been called away and was safe. But it was unsettling.
A close friend's sister-in-law was a flight attendant on that flight. Other friends of friends were lost. One of the kids I grew up with, a boy we played football and softball with on the street in front of the house I grew up in in Summit, NJ, then a finance executive...
...was at his office in the World Trade Center and lost. Of all the losses, I suppose that is the one that lingers with me the most because all of my memories of him--and I did not have any contact with him once we all grew up and went to college--were of him as a kid.
They were just memories of sunny days and sports and of him and his dog and, as a result, mostly of hope and living in a world that was secure, where nothing bad could ever touch us.
Because of the number of lives lost that day, everyone has memories and stories like this. 9/11 was one of the important moments of history that was deeply personal to each of us. That is as it should be and fuels the memories that keep those we lost alive.
Sadly, political opportunists demagogued our sense of loss and our understandable desire to bring the terrorists to justice into wars and loss and expense and damage to our nation that far outstripped in cost that terrible September day.
I was worried that would happen. Three weeks after the attacks, around the time we deployed troops to Afghanistan, I wrote a column for USA Today in which I worried we would be drawn into a kind of global intifada, a long-lasting conflict in which our disproportionate responses..
...would ultimately weaken us and strengthen our enemies. Unfortunately, that is exactly what happened. And for years there...and as we saw the crimes and errors politicians tried to justify by associating them with the names of victims of 9/11...
...we thought our misguided response would never end. And that is why, I am so grateful that on this, the 20th anniversary of the attacks on America, that @JoeBiden has finally brought those errors, those endless wars, to an end. I am glad because it is the right thing to do.
But I am grateful because it will also allow us to honor those we lost as we should have done all along, by remembering their promise and their goodness and seeking to infuse the future of this country with those qualities.
That means both investing our country and seeking to promote and strengthen our values, out of respect for them and because such steps are in the end, the only way to truly keep this country strong and safe.
For too long our response was driven by arrogance and vengeance. It actually has compounded the damage done by Bin Laden. Now perhaps we will respond as we should have all along, by seeking to be our best selves and the best America we can be.
After all, in the end, nothing truly defeats our enemies like putting the lie to the criticisms of us they use as rallying cries...and demonstrating that within this country the good ultimately, is indomitable. With that in mind, we must now also acknowledge...
...the greatest threats we face come from within. Indeed, our flawed response to 9/11 demonstrated that as does the current willingness of some among us to attack the very foundations of our democracy and our society.
In other words, twenty years later, it is high time we undertook exactly the job of work that this administration has made its priority. But it is not just a job for a government. It should be an agenda that is beyond politics, shared by us all.
Pursuing it is, in the end, the one and only right way to commemorate what happened on 9/11 and to ensure history sees that as a turning point that, after two decades of grievous missteps, ultimately led to a new period of American growth, security and leadership.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Another failed NY Times oped by Bret Stephens. Is it a bigger failure for Stephens (who is consistently bad...but seldom this bad) or the editors at The NY Times (who chose to give this kind of fact-ignoring, reality twisting sophistry a platform)? nytimes.com/2021/09/07/opi…
Biden has presided over a logistical miracle w/the vaccine distribution, an unprecedented economic recovery, more job creation than any other in his first 6 months, undoing of Trumpian damage done by executive order, record appointment of judges (& w/unprecedented diversity)...
...reentering the Paris Accord and the WTO, leading the world in vaccine diplomacy, ending a 20 year disaster of a conflict, getting 125,000 people out of Afghanistan in a matter of weeks in the face of huge challenges, making combatting the climate crisis a priority,...
And now, the latest Biden report from the Conventional News Network...
It's been a rough summer for the president folks because...
--Job growth slowing slightly (although yes, Biden has created more jobs in his first six months than any president in history)
--COVID spiking (although yes, the admin performed a miracle getting the vaccine out & the GOP has systematically undermine admin efforts to save lives)
--Afghanistan exit chat (although yes, the president ended a futile 20 year war and the administration managed to evacuate 125,000 people so far in one of the biggest humanitarian airlifts every and ending wars is chaotic by nature)
From Afghanistan to infrastructure, the climate crisis to defending democracy, China policy to inequality, today America is having a major debate about its priorities going forward. In many ways we have squandered the first decades of this century. It is time to rethink that.
President Biden has argued that rather than investing $3 trillion in wars--the vast majority of which goes to a handful of major U.S. defense contractors--we should invest it in the real sources of our security and strength: our people, our infrastructure, R&D, health, education.
He has argued that rather than focusing on wars that cannot be won, we should prepare for the challenges of the coming century, great power rivalries, competitiveness, and addressing urgent needs like the climate crisis.
In the months & years ahead we need to do a deep accounting, not just within the government but on the national level, of the flaws in our system, our politics & our society that lead us to make mistakes on the scale of the Afghanistan War, the Iraq War & the "War on Terror."
While the war in Afghanistan began with a natural impulse to seek justice in the wake of 9/11, the policy process guiding it quickly was hijacked by opportunists with personal agendas that were ideological or industry-driven. Lies became the foundations for massive national endea
But they were not effectively challenges. The Iraq War was an indecent and indefensible distraction from the mission to get Al Qaeda and Bin Laden, but the majority of the foreign policy establishment supported it and accepted many lies without questioning them.
I largely agree with Dan's view here. The idea that "the blob" is after @jakejsullivan is nuts. The sources cited in the article ranged from not credible to just wrong. But I would go further. Jake is precisely the national security advisor we need. washingtonpost.com/outlook/2021/0…
And look, I say that as a certified member of the original blob. Also as someone who has written two books on the NSC, countless articles, and met with every national security advisor who was alive in my lifetime.
Jake has the right experience, temperament, relationship with @POTUS and respect for process. He is brilliant, creative, widely respected and has a clear vision for where US foreign policy should be headed.
The intellectual dishonesty that we have seen in critiques of Biden's handling of the exit from Afghanistan has been spectacular.
That's not to say some critiques are not warranted. They certainly are. But, some of the arguments being used are so indefensible they require us to question the critics' motives or expertise. Here are some of the worst ones.
1. Biden owns this. (No. The authors of 20 yrs of war own this. The corrupt Afghan govt & the Afghan military who stood down own this. The Trump Admin that set the deadlines, drew down the troops, left behind the materiel & released 5000 Taliban own this.)