I refuse to let Amazon define Rust infoworld.com/article/363300…
At some point, we all have to have a serious conversation about Amazon's involvement in Rust. It's been far too long without me saying this.
Amazon now has:

* Lang team co-lead
* Compiler team co-lead
* decided to not have a Rust Foundation ED, meaning Chair has outsized power in the Foundation

they've also taken steps to marginalize the core team. and some other dirty shit I won't say rn.
the first three though, are undefinable. they're just facts. And now they want to actually take Amazon's principles and claim that they're Rust's.

So, what do we do? Is this okay?
I want big companies to be involved in Rust. I don't want Amazon to go away!

I *do* want them to start playing nice instead of playing badly.

I've tried to get this message across in private. They just don't care.
In the beginning, Rust did have one sole patron: Mozilla. Everyone was uncomfortable with that arrangement, including Mozilla.

We spent years trying to get away from this situation. It had tons of negative effects.

Why are we regressing here?
I know @mjasay left Amazon recently, but note what this article is: it's an article by someone from Amazon talking about how two other people at Amazon are writing Amazon's tenets as Rust's, and that's why Rust is so beloved.

Rust is not beloved because of Amazon. Sorry.
Now, I should also say this: lots of hard workin Rustaceans at Amazon. I like most of you. You're doing good work, and trying to keep doing the right thing.

This isn't about individuals. This is about structure. This is about leadership.
(also, since I pointed him out: the above goes for @mjasay too. Not trying to say he's a terrible person here. I don't think that; I actually respect him quite a bit.)
ah see this is what i mean by "doing things behind the scenes to marginalize the core team"
note that this was also retweeted by the lang team co-lead
a lot of people seem to think the core team is irrelevant, yet somehow worth attacking

the reality is this: the core team *has* become less relevant over time. because the core team used to be the only leadership in the rust project. but that wasn't okay.
we delegated out real, actual leadership powers to the subteams. im on the core team. i don't get to veto language team decisions. that's their role. and i'm glad they have it!
a lot of what core does at this point is to be "the buck stops here." we handle all of the work that's not explicitly delegated to another team.

that work is *never* sexy, and often not able to be made public.
the role of governance has to change as the reality changes. and we've been intensely wondering about what that means for rust governance for like, a long time, actually!
we can have real, upfront conversations about that, and figure out what we as a community want things to be, *or* we can

1. decide to do the work of other teams
2. complain about them in private and then in public

there's been a lot of #2 going on
there is also worse stuff! still not going to talk about that though.

point is: there are bigger and deeper issues here.
to elaborate on #3: The structural issue here is that the foundation decided to forgo extending the interim ED contract while looking for a new ED; this means that the foundation currently does not have one, and we don't know when a new one is coming. 1/2
During that time, the chair of the board has more power than they usually would, and Amazon is chair of the board. 2/2
Oh and one thing I should say too: suggesting that core doesn’t do anything during the same year we managed the implosion of Mozilla and the creation of the foundation is incredibly disrespectful to those on core who did all of that intense work.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

Keep Current with steveklabnik

steveklabnik Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!


Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @steveklabnik

13 Sep
i am gonna turn this one into its own thread:

you know how i've had like, seriously declining mental health lately?
it is incredibly difficult, personally, to put a lot of volunteer work, heart, and soul, into doing something for a project, and then to have others malign it
i can handle heat from random people. that's fine. people can disagree with things. that's also fine!

but some of the stuff being said and done has just... it's tremendously painful. i've cried a lot. some actual friendships destroyed at this point
Read 9 tweets
11 Aug
all i can say about 1password is that it gets my highest possible praise for a product, which is that i use it every day, it works perfectly, and i never need to think about it except when nerds get really upset about it online for whatever reason it is this time
the enlightened orange website user, on a tab about facebook: "if you're not paying, YOU'RE the product"

on a tab about 1password: $3/month is too much, use this free oss program with terrible ux instead
"ugh, an online vault that Just Works across every device you own no matter the OS? don't use that! just put this file in your dropbox and make sure to configure all the various apps to use that and if it gets out of date just manually re-sync it"
Read 5 tweets
25 May
PSA: I plan on blogging about this, but haven’t yet, but semver is now a dtolnay crate. There’s basically nobody else I’d have given this too. Very glad to see what he’s doing with it
I have been trying to get a 1.0.0 across the line for like two years. It’s kind of been an albatross for me. He actually did it, and it’s very good.
psa @zkat__ ^
Read 4 tweets
25 May
"Rust is a wave of the future" utcc.utoronto.ca/~cks/space/blo…
one interesting thing about this post that's been in the back of my head all day
Read 5 tweets
18 May
on my sixth week of bullet journaling. I didn't really give it a chance before, but after seeing some tweets (I believe from @yoshuawuyts) and reading about its creation, I decided to give it a try regardless of my feelings.

i am so glad i did.
i like it so much i actually am considering trying to do a paper-based zettlekasten and just like, end my accounts with various online-based productivity and knowledge management tools.
i've got a lot more to say here. maybe i'll blog someday. let me write that down in my "projects quick capture" page...
Read 12 tweets
6 May
I am gonna die
Okay number two I had a tiny tiny bit and thought “this is fine” but I know better, gave it a second, and it’s still fine but I feel it in my whole mouth. Not sure when I’ll feel okay about trying 3, I put too big a dab hahah
Haven’t died yet. FUCK that is spicy though. I could not eat a full wing with this on it
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!